The History Book Club discussion
This topic is about
Byzantium
MEDIEVAL HISTORY
>
ARCHIVE - BYZANTIUM: THE SURPRISING LIFE OF A MEDIEVAL EMPIRE - TOC AND SYLLABUS
message 2:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Mar 23, 2011 05:03PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
List of Illustrations ix
List of Maps xii
Introduction: A Different History of Byzantium xiii
Part I: Foundations of Byzantium
Chapter 1: The City of Constantine 3
Chapter 2: Constantinople, the Largest City in Christendom 12
Chapter 3: The East Roman Empire 22
Chapter 4: Greek Orthodoxy 33
Chapter 5: The Church of Hagia Sophia 50
Chapter 6: The Ravenna Mosaics 61
Chapter 7: Roman Law 70
Part II: The Transition from Ancient to Medieval
Chapter 8: The Bulwark Against Islam 83
Chapter 9: Icons, a New Christian Art Form 98
Chapter 10: Iconoclasm and Icon Veneration 105
Chapter 11: A Literate and Articulate Society 119
Chapter 12: Saints Cyril and Methodios,'Apostles to the Slavs' 131
Part: III: Byzantium Becomes a Medieval State
Chapter 13: Greek Fire 141
Chapter 14: The Byzantine Economy 148
Chapter 15: Eunuchs 160
Chapter 16: The Imperial Court 170
Chapter 17: Imperial Children,"Born in the Purple" 185
Chapter 18: Mount Athos 192
Chapter 19: Venice and the Fork 203
Chapter 20: Basil II,"The Bulgar-Slayer" 212
Chapter 21: Eleventh-Century Crisis 220
Chapter 22: Anna Komnene 232
Chapter 23: A Cosmopolitan Society 242
Part IV: Varieties of Byzantium
Chapter 24: The Fulcrum of the Crusades 255
Chapter 25: The Towers of Trebizond, Arta, Nicaea and Thessalonike 266
Chapter 26: Rebels and Patrons 281
Chapter 27: "Better the Turkish Turban than the Papal Tiara" 299
Chapter 28: The Siege of 1453 310
Conclusion: The Greatness and Legacy of Byzantium 321
Further Reading 339
List of Emperors Named in the Text 354
Chronology 357
Maps 363
Acknowledgements 375
Index 377
Bently, I am so glad that we are going to explore a culture, that with all its faults, could have been an alternative to the Dark Ages.
message 4:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Sep 21, 2011 10:07PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
Great topic.
BN.com lists this as a textbook. Anyone know what that means?
BN.com also has no nook version! Annoying!
BN.com lists this as a textbook. Anyone know what that means?
BN.com also has no nook version! Annoying!
Bentley, do you know yet which isbn you'll be using?
I am new to Goodreads' groups and would like to know if this book has to be read by Dec. 4 or if that is when we start to read it as a group, chapter by chapter? Not quite sure how this works. Thanks!
Sandra, in this group we read the book together beginning with the start date. Usually a schedule is posted a few weeks ahead of time showing which pages to read for each week. See the second comment in http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/5... and the second comment in http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/5... for examples.
message 9:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Oct 31, 2011 09:30PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
message 10:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Oct 31, 2011 09:32PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
BN.com lists this as a textbook. Anyone know what that means?
BN.com also has no nook version! Annoying!"
Curious; not sure why that would be the case aside from the fact that it is published by Princeton University Press. It does not appear to be on Kindle either; but can be downloaded as an eBook from Waterstones.com and on Amazon UK. There is a free download from Reader Store if you have a Windows environment; I don't but here is a link for those of you who do:
http://www.ebook.honglinhsoft.com/?pa...
I have the paperback version.
ISBN:
0691143692
ISBN-13:
9780691143699
PUB. DATE:
September 2009
PUBLISHER:
Princeton University Press
We will read this over a three month period.
Mod
by Judith Herrin
March 12, 2011
The Wall Street Journal
One of the world's great empires is on the move, in our imaginations and in the place that it occupies in our understanding of the modern world. Byzantium used to call to mind a sterile, bureaucratic and yet violent society, corrupted by fatuous complexities. The worst failings in our own societies would be described as "Byzantine."
But over the past 20 years this image has begun to shift in important ways. Two great exhibitions at the Metropolitan Museum of Art (in 1997 and 2004)— and more recent ones in Paris, London and Bonn—brought a large audience face to face with a thousand years of riveting artistic achievement. And a new generation of scholars has emerged, re-evaluating the very idea of Roman decline or Dark Ages and arguing that the barbarian forces that occupied the empire's western provinces adopted, adapted and thus perpetuated many of the Roman methods of administration. The term "Late Antiquity" embodies this long period of transition, which transformed the Roman world while integrating aspects of Latin culture with the Christian hierarchy of bishops and monks, who were themselves often recruited from the senatorial classes. At the same time, the recent emergence of an Islamic challenge to the West has urged our engagement with the Christian power that first withstood Muslim attacks and defended Europe's eastern frontier for centuries.
Byzantium is unusual among empires in having a precise beginning and end. Constantinople was inaugurated by Emperor Constantine I in 330 and fell to the Ottoman Turks in 1453. And across that long millennium it developed from being the eastern half of the vast Roman Empire into a brilliant medieval state that expanded into the Balkans, the Caucasus and southern Russia before being split into three separate units when Constantinople was occupied by the Latin crusaders between 1204 and 1261. It was restored to Byzantine rule, but the state gradually shrank to just the city and a few outposts in mainland Greece.
The excellence of Byzantine administration—hardly Byzantine at all by our usage—is nowhere clearer than in the power of the Byzantine standard gold coin, the solidus (known as the bezant in medieval Europe). First issued by Constantine I in the early fourth century, it retained its 24-carat value and was the coin of choice in international trade for more than 700 years. It took a self-conscious and creative government to manage this extraordinary achievement: one that puts to shame our present devalued currencies and monetary instability.
Even after Byzantium's conquest by the Ottomans in 1453, its culture and traditions continued to be felt far and wide. Czarist Russia claimed to have replaced Constantinople as the leading patriarchal see and styled Moscow as the "Third Rome." The court rituals of Louis XIV's Versailles mimicked the Byzantine imperial ceremonies, creating an elaborate pyramid of family relations with court officials in fixed proximity to the monarch and distinguished by specific costumes and weapons. Even the British coronation ceremonies can trace their origin back to Byzantium. And in many regions the Orthodox Church still sustains the Greek liturgy, so richly endowed by Byzantine contributions.
In this way, an enormous pile of booty "transformed the crusading paupers into the richest citizens," as one Western monk put it. The famous horses of San Marco were robbed from Constantinople's Hippodrome and mounted on the façade of the cathedral of Venice—which is itself a tribute to the Byzantine architecture of the dome, perfected six centuries earlier in the cap ital's great cathedral, the Hagia Sophia ("Holy Wisdom"). In the years after 1204, a vast number of Byzantium artifacts, silks, ivories, enamels and jewels found their way into western cathedral treasuries.
The very designation "Byzantium" is a further complication (specialists dispute the name to be given to this empire). During the life of the empire, the term was reserved for Constantine's city, originally a Greek colony called Byzantion, whose inhabitants liked to vaunt their identity as "Byzantines." All the others who lived within the vast imperial borders called themselves "Romans," and they knew that their empire was Roman. Yet the adjective "Byzantine," first adopted by 16th-century humanists to distinguish east from west, is more than just a convenience; it recalls the city's original pride and draws attention to the extraordinary vitality of an empire that perdured with such success after the western empire's collapse. Constantine I's decision to be buried in a Christian mausoleum in the city set in train the process that helped to make Byzantium a Christian Roman Empire. All his successors wanted to be interred beside him, eventually creating a shrine to the Christian rulers of the Roman Empire.
So why has this remarkable empire for so long been perceived as abhorrent and rebarbative, when not being dismissed? The neglect of Byzantium by historians may be traced to the sack of Constantinople in 1204 by members of the Fourth Crusade. The crusaders justified their plunder and desecration of churches and monasteries by projecting onto the city and its civilization all their own worst faults: The eastern Christians were condemned as schismatics or even heretics; their wealth was therefore ill-gained and undeserved.
From the beginning, Byzantium manifested highly creative and original impulses to re-fashion rich, pre-existing traditions. Its inner Greek fire came from a unique combination of traits. When Constantine created his new capital, he brought together Roman administrative skills, law and military traditions; the Hellenic wisdom long sustained by ancient Greek education; and the dynamic new Christian belief (which later became the state's driving force). As he fought his way from York to Rome and on to the east, Constantine came to know these strengths at first hand. Like most Romans, he appreciated the superiority of ancient Greek culture, which provided the essential education for all ambitious men—and some women, like Hypatia, the fourth-century philosopher and mathematician. By the fifth century, Constantinople had schools to rival those of Athens and Alexandria (and Beirut for law), with teachers paid directly from the imperial treasury. This re-fashioning genius can be physically experienced today in the Hippodrome of Istanbul—the Roman race track, almost in the shadow of the Hagia Sophia— where Greek and Latin inscriptions appear on the base of an obelisk that originally commemorated a pharaonic military victory of the second millennium B.C.
The city quickly generated a highly sophisticated work force. Its artisans produced the Mediterranean world's most elegant silks, carved ivories and gold enamels. Its engineers constructed the immense walls that kept all enemies out of Constantinople until 1204. The recent excavations of the harbor of Theodosius (today Yenikapi) have yielded more than 30 boats and their cargoes and shown how the capital attracted traders and craftsmen from across the Mediterranean. Venice, Genoa and Pisa established quarters within the city, while Syrian and Russian merchants stayed in particular residences when they came to trade. In the 1090s, as the western forces of the First Crusade arrived at Constantinople, they were overcome with awe at the wealth and sophistication of the eastern capital, the like of which they had not even imagined. The city was larger than any in Western Europe, with a population of about 500,000— a level not attained by Paris until the 17th century.
Byzantine innovations began attracting the interest of modern historians between the wars. Among the most notable was Robert Byron, whose discovery of the neglected empire produced the highly romantic and alluring views of "The Byzantine Achievement" (1929). In contrast, Jack Lindsay, in "Byzantium Into Europe" (1952), emphasized how Byzantium acted as a buffer between Islam and Europe. Steven Runciman's well-researched and elegantly phrased books established a sympathetic appreciation of Greek Orthodoxy, particularly notable in "The Fall of Constantinople, 1453" (1965) and "The Great Church in Captivity" (1968). (It also permeates his great three-volume "History of the Crusades," an eminently readable account now criticized precisely for its fluency.) Runciman's "Byzantine Civilization" (1933) remains a short, accessible account that still repays reading after 75 years. Such historians established, half a century ago, how difficult Byzantium's position was between aggressive states east and west.
Academic authors have been less skilled at presenting their research in accessible ways—though I hope that my "Byzantium: The Surprising Life of a Medieval Empire" (2007) is an exception. But the contemporary interest in east-west conflict and how empires collapse has brought new readers to major reassessments of Byzantium's historical significance and helped to extend the study of the "barbarian" forces that sought to bring down empires. Both Peter Heather's "Empires and Barbarians " (2009), although it only treats the first millennium A.D., and John Darwin's "After Tamerlane: The Rise and Fall of Global Empires, 1400-2000 " (2007) consider Byzantium in such a comparative perspective.
It was the rise of Islam that ultimately undermined the dominion of Christian Byzantium. The empire checked the first great wave of Muslim expansion in the 630s, and by 740 a more secure border with the caliphate in Damascus was established at the Taurus mountains in southeastern Turkey. The empire had lost the rich provinces of Egypt, Palestine and Syria but over the years restored imperial control in areas of Armenia and northern Syria. Challenged by the Bulgars in the west, Byzantium also fought many campaigns in the Balkans; it always had to balance the two very distant fronts with the immense lines of communication and logistical support extending from the Caucasus to the Adriatic.
The last phase of Byzantine power, from 1261 to 1453, was marked by military failure and shrinking control but also by a great cultural explosion. Architects and painters constructed and decorated churches and monasteries with brilliant mosaics and frescoes in all parts of the empire: the Chora monastery in Constantinople and those of Mount Athos, churches at Trebizond on the Black Sea and Mistras in the Morea (in southern Greece). Icon painters, silversmiths and manuscript illuminators produced exquisite liturgical objects (for example, the manuscripts commissioned by Emperor John VI Kantakouzenos in the 1350s).
In intellectual pursuits, Byzantine scholars learned Latin and translated works of Augustine and Aquinas, leading to greater knowledge of western theology; they also copied and added to the Byzantine repertoire of epigrams, scientific writings and collections of letters. Jonathan Harris's new study, "The End of Byzantium" (Yale University Press, 298 pages, $40), shows expert knowledge of the Greeks in the west and of cultural trends in humanistic thought and explains the attraction of Latin theology for many Byzantine intellectuals. Mr. Harris provides a sympathetic reading of the civil wars and conflicts engendered by the empire's fundamental problem in this era: how to balance Byzantine traditions with the need for military aid from the West in order to confront the Ottoman Turks.
Although emperors continued to look west for help, in 1453 the Byzantines faced vastly superior forces (armed with the latest in cannon technology) supported by only a few loyal Venetians resident in the city and a body of archers recruited by Isidore of Kiev and Bishop Leonard of Chios.
message 12:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Oct 31, 2011 10:40PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
It was a very unequal battle. In the end the Byzantines had to chose between east or west. While many aristocratic families fled to Venice, the peasants, who could not move, accepted Ottoman rule. It has been argued that their lives did not change much with the arrival of Mehmet the Conqueror.
We can celebrate today a great civilization that stretched from Novgorod to southern Egypt, and from Spain to the Euphrates. The millennium of Byzantine civilization profoundly influenced our modern world. Its achievements resonate and become clearer with every new excavation and major exhibition and historical analysis sympathetic to its surprising and lively character.
Ms. Herrin is professor of late antique and Byzantine studies at King's College London and the author of "Byzantium: The Surprising Life of a Medieval Empire" (Princeton).
Judith Herrin
by Jonathan Harris
I just received the e-mail to RSVP for this, but when I clicked on it, it said the RSVP was closed. Is this happening? Is it too late to get in?
message 15:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Oct 31, 2011 11:06PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
I am looking forward to reading this book, so much to learn.
Mod
Syllabus? This starts right after Thanksgiving, and after 'the' dinner; more convenient for me.
message 19:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Nov 04, 2011 12:16PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
How does that free download work? I've tried it, but cannot seem to figure it out.Is that so you are able to read from your PC?
I do not have a Kindle, Nook, etc...but I have downloaded books to my PC before.
Mod
Thanks a bunch!I do have Kindle for PC, and also Adobe Reader. I will look more closely into the link!
Mod
Mod
Have my copy. Second hand. Someone has put corrections at various points with pencil on the text! Curious ones that look right too! I will post any that are interesting as we proceed. Great choice, this. It's going to make for a stunning winter read!
Mod
Okay, I am new to all this but I will have the book in a week or so and am looking forward to the discussions.
Hi, this will be my first online book club discussion. I have the book, we used in a class I took in college but I never read it. But I always wanted to read it. I am excited to try this. Do I need to do anything besides post here that I am interested?
Mod
I'm looking forward to this! I think it will be a nice complement to A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century
Barbara W. Tuchman
message 32:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Nov 15, 2011 06:43PM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
by
Barbara W. TuchmanDon't forget the book cover when citing the book.
My book just arrived - looking forward to reading it!
Mod
I just started reading the book earlier this week. Love it so far. Just a little irreverent remark: I can't stop giggling over that song by They Might Be Giants "Istanbul (not Constantinople)". Funny what gets stuck in your brain.
Mod
Mod
I just received my book and am looking forward to reading it with the group.
Mod
Just got the book and ready to start reading!
Mod
Mine should arrive on Dec 8. I hit a patch where Amazon and B&N was out of stock, so I had to buy elsewhere. I see now Amazon has them in stock.I hope to join in.
Byzantium seems to be one of those spots in history that has a strange fog of amnesia surrounding it as it is drifting in the backwaters of the shining glory of the Roman Empire. Is this because Western Europe traditionally covered Greeks and Romans in the classical education system? I am so glad that the group is covering the era. It certainly will fill some gaps in my own education! Great choice by the group! Got a nice used hardback beckoning to me from my way too crowded bookshelf.
Mod
I hope to join in."
Great to have you Bryan.
Mod
We welcome you Haaze to the discussion and this was a selection that was voted for by the group. I think it is a great choice as well.
I look forward to reading your posts.
Thanks, Bentley, for the ePub download link. After a few clicks and a strong cup of coffee, it is now on my PC in the Calibre E-Book management software I found on About.com. Still trying to figure out how to get it on the Kindle, but for now, this works great!Also, am I just lacking enough coffee, but is there a reading syllabus that I'm missing? I see the chapters but not the reading plan! Thanks
message 48:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(last edited Nov 28, 2011 05:30AM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Mod
I got the ePub as well. So excited I started reading already and am 3 chapters in. Looking forward to the discussion!
Just picked up the book from the library and am ready to go!
The History Book Club
Books mentioned in this topic
Western Europe in the Middle Ages: 300-1475 (other topics)Byzantium: The Early Centuries (other topics)
A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century (other topics)
A Distant Mirror: The Calamitous 14th Century (other topics)
The End of Byzantium (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Brian Tierney (other topics)John Julius Norwich (other topics)
Barbara W. Tuchman (other topics)
Barbara W. Tuchman (other topics)
Judith Herrin (other topics)
More...
This book begins its discussion on December 4, 2011.