Q&A with Josh Lanyon discussion

623 views
Book of the Month Club > Candidates for Next Month's Read

Comments Showing 2,551-2,600 of 3,043 (3043 new)    post a comment »

message 2551: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Teal wrote: "It's a hard choice!"

I know! There are several on here I'd like to read!

But hey, if folks are in agreement, whatever comes in second place could be our next read. That'll save on having to nominate and vote again at least for a little while. As well as the fact that there are so many good choices on this list!


message 2552: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments It was such a hard choice that I ended up going back and changing my vote. 😂


message 2553: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
LOL


message 2554: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hi everyone!

Mr. Loverman will be our July 2020 BOM read! Can't wait!


message 2555: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments A book I nominated got picked? Has that ever happened before? 😱😂😂

I just noticed that it's available on Hoopla, so if anyone here doesn't want to buy it but has a library with Hoopla access, that's one way to get it. Also I see that one of my libraries has it on Overdrive -- probably because the author won the Booker Prize (for a different book) last year. So maybe check your library too?


message 2556: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Teal wrote: "A book I nominated got picked? Has that ever happened before? 😱😂😂

I just noticed that it's available on Hoopla, so if anyone here doesn't want to buy it but has a library with Hoopla access, that'..."


LOL!

And thank you for mentioning Hoopla! I had seen that and meant to mention it and completely forgot. YES, it's on Hoopla!!!


message 2557: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments I had voted for it, and now I bought it. Which doesn't mean I'll be able to read it and to participate to the discussion ;-), but it's a first step...


message 2558: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Every journey starts somewhere!


message 2559: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

We start our new BOM thread today!


message 2560: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Jordan wrote: "https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

We start our new BOM thread today!"


Yay! Thanks, Jordan. :)


message 2561: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hey everyone, Josh’s Spring release date just got moved back to late August according to Amazon so we need to choose a new book for next month! I hope you don’t mind, but I took the liberty of choosing the two books that tied for second place in our last poll and made a new poll with them:

https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/2...

Voting ends Thursday!


message 2562: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Also, what if for the next poll I mine past polls for books that didn’t get chosen to eliminate a nomination round once or twice? Is that acceptable? Or would you rather we nominate as usual?


message 2563: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments I like your idea, Jordan. A lot of potentially interesting books were also-rans.


message 2564: by WMD (new)

WMD | 251 comments I agree!


message 2565: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Thanks for your feedback!


message 2566: by SamSpayedPI (new)

SamSpayedPI | 596 comments Jordan wrote: "Also, what if for the next poll I mine past polls for books that didn’t get chosen to eliminate a nomination round once or twice? Is that acceptable? Or would you rather we nominate as usual?"

Second place is the first loser.


message 2567: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Lol!


message 2568: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments Jordan wrote: "Also, what if for the next poll I mine past polls for books that didn’t get chosen to eliminate a nomination round once or twice? Is that acceptable? Or would you rather we nominate as usual?"

It is a good idea, and in fact it is something we mumbled about for a while, but then no one ever remembered to do, because new, shiny books come out ;-).


message 2569: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments SamSpayedPI wrote: "Second place is the first loser."

;-)


message 2570: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Yeah, anyone can renominate something at any time. I’m just going to be deliberate about it. That said, if there’s anything specific anyone wants to vote on again, let me know!


message 2571: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments Mymymble wrote: "Only Ije and I seem to have been reading Mr Loverman so far so I'm a bit sad - I thought it really good."

I've read it, and I loved it.

I just wanted to contribute with a bit more than: «I loved it», that's why I didn't say anything ;-).


message 2572: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Mymymble wrote: "Only Ije and I seem to have been reading Mr Loverman so far so I'm a bit sad - I thought it really good. Not as sad as I'd have been if it had only been me though, natch."

I'm hoping to start it very soon. Maybe even today. :)


message 2573: by SamSpayedPI (last edited Jul 20, 2020 11:45AM) (new)

SamSpayedPI | 596 comments Me too. That is, I can never think of anything nice to say about a book, either, beyond "I loved it" and five stars. Poor Josh; she needs us to write good reviews, and I'm just stuck.

I haven't read Mr. Loverman yet; I've actually been having trouble "getting into" any books, recently. I read the first few pages and they don't grab my interest. Same with 11:59 and If It Bleeds and Devoted and lots of books of all kinds (also Bloodlands but only because it's so terribly disturbing; I've tried to read it several times but just can't get through it.)

Five months of isolation and even I managed to OD on reading.


message 2574: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
I had planned on reading this other book that I've had for awhile this month, so I'm working to finish that one first. I feel kinda bad because the author, Lou Harper, even signed it for me and I've had it sitting on a shelf forever. So, I'm making sure I read it. :-) So, either tomorrow or the next day (cross your fingers) I will be starting Mr. Loverman! Can't wait!


message 2575: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
I think it's tough. If you really liked something, you often have less to say about it, than if you hated it. lol.


message 2576: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments Jordan wrote: "I think it's tough. If you really liked something, you often have less to say about it, than if you hated it. lol."

When I first started to write reviews I thought that to give a book 5 stars was kind of self-explanatory. Now I try to make an effort if I like and also if I dislike it.


message 2577: by SamSpayedPI (last edited Jul 20, 2020 07:53PM) (new)

SamSpayedPI | 596 comments Jordan wrote: "I think it's tough. If you really liked something, you often have less to say about it, than if you hated it. lol."

I see I have written four reviews on Goodreads. Two are pans (one-star); and one is an "OK but please read the original version (Dark Carnival) instead of the revised (The October Country)". I have one five-star review, which I originally wrote for a newsletter to describe that month's book club activity, so I figured I might as well use it. No other reviews at all, beyond stars.


message 2578: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
American Dreamer is our BOM poll winner!


message 2579: by Teal (last edited Jul 25, 2020 11:04AM) (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Jordan wrote: "American Dreamer is our BOM poll winner!"

Ugh, I totally missed that poll. I'd like to blame it on how GR isn't reliably sending me notifications, but honestly I think my brain just isn't pulling its weight nowadays. 🤨 I won't be joining you for that one -- I read the sample and passed on it. But I hope it's a keeper for the rest of the team!


message 2580: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Here is our discussion thread for American Dreamer! https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...


message 2581: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hi Everyone,

I have gone through our poll results from 2019 and back into 2018, and I chose four titles for us to vote on for our September read. you can see the poll here: https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/2... The poll will be up until next Thursday.


message 2582: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Wow, I have read (or DNF'd) three of those, and own the fourth! So I would have no excuse for not participating. 😂


message 2583: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
LOL. They were chosen kind of randomly. Next month might be based on what’s left from this poll or might be culled from other past polls again. I think there were a few books in the past that had a somewhat healthy three votes. Lol.


message 2584: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
I’ve not been reading much lately, I can’t seem to get motivated, or to find the time. I end up reading about a page or two before I’m falling asleep at night. And two pages a day isn’t going to get me very far. Lol.


message 2585: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments I'm having a terrible time reading too. If it wasn't for the fact that I'm in the middle of a multi-book buddy read right now, I'd probably be averaging two pages a day myself.


message 2586: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Looks like Red, White, and Royal Blue is our winner for September. :-)


message 2587: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments Jordan wrote: "Looks like Red, White, and Royal Blue is our winner for September. :-)"

Thank you for organising the poll.


message 2588: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Here is our new BOM thread for September! https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...


message 2589: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hi everyone,

I have two polls for you this month in an effort to get us back to voting ahead so that folks can borrow titles from their library or request that titles be purchased by their library.

The first poll is for October 2020: https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/2...

The second poll is for November 2020: https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/2...

Keep in mind that should Josh publish something these poll results will get pushed back.

I have pulled these titles from previous polls throughout 2019 and 2020. These at one time or another had votes. But after these two, we will definitely need to take nominations again, unless there are enough votes for second titles from these two polls.

Let me know if you have any questions or thoughts!


message 2590: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Thank you, Jordan. I'm delighted to see The Cobbler's Boy make a reappearance. Historical fiction about Christopher Marlowe at 15...! I can't believe I haven't read it yet, but I've been saving it like a special treat.


message 2591: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Teal wrote: "Thank you, Jordan. I'm delighted to see The Cobbler's Boy make a reappearance. Historical fiction about Christopher Marlowe at 15...! I can't believe I haven't read it yet, but I've..."

Yay! Yeah, some of these still look really good. I just finally voted myself, but it was a really hard call. I think I'd be up for keeping some of these titles around for awhile. lol.


message 2592: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hi everyone,

I just wanted to thank those of you who took the time to vote on our two polls and to announce our poll winners for our upcoming BOMs!!!

Our October read will be: Catalysts: The Scientific Method

Our November read will be: Two Man Station

Please keep in mind that if Josh publishes something else, these will get bumped in favor of anything from Josh!

Also, as we had good voting for some of the other books on both polls, I will very likely use those in one more poll where we take the top two choices and run with them.


message 2593: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Thanks, Jordan!


message 2594: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Teal wrote: "Thanks, Jordan!"

You're welcome!


message 2595: by Teal (new)

Teal (howiebing) | 1943 comments Jordan wrote: "Looks like Red, White, and Royal Blue is our winner for September. :-)"

I see that RW&RB has been added to Kindle Unlimited. Normally it's an expensive ebook, so it's nice to see it made available to folks who subscribe to KU. If that applies to anyone here, it's not too late to join the BOM discussion currently underway.


message 2596: by SamSpayedPI (new)

SamSpayedPI | 596 comments Teal wrote: "I see that RW&RB has been added to Kindle Unlimited. Normally it's an expensive ebook, so it's nice to see it..."

Thanks! I got it out from the library and I'm about to lose it, and there's a waiting list. So now I can finish it, in time for the discussion even!

It was a DNF for me the first time around. Actually, more of a DNS: I read the first page, was not in the mood for a silly NA romance, put it down and didn't pick it up again until yesterday.

I'm really enjoying it now, but I have classwork and my internship so I'm pretty sure my loan will expire before I can finish it.


message 2597: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Oh, that is good news, Antonella! Thanks for letting us know!

I bought my copy when it was on sale awhile back. I'm hoping to start it this week. my other book group discussion is tomorrow night so I should be able to start this one tomorrow or the day after. :-) I think I need a light read right about now so I'm looking forward to it!


message 2598: by Antonella (new)

Antonella | 11568 comments Jordan wrote: "Oh, that is good news, Antonella! Thanks for letting us know!"

I suspect that you meant to thank Teal ;-).


message 2599: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Antonella wrote: "Jordan wrote: "Oh, that is good news, Antonella! Thanks for letting us know!"

I suspect that you meant to thank Teal ;-)."


Oh! You're right! I must have seen the sorta similar blues of your profile pics and thought it was you.

Thank you TEAL!!!!!


message 2600: by Jordan (new)

Jordan Lombard (jslombard) | 15348 comments Mod
Hi everyone,

I have a quick question for you. As we've been having very short conversations about the BOM titles we're reading, I'm wondering if we change our model it might help drive more conversation. Feel free to say no, this is really just a suggestion, but would you want to choose a specific day and time to have a conversation here about each title? So we could say something like the 4th Saturday of every month at some prearranged time, or maybe just take the entire day to accommodate all the time differences? Rather than have this take the whole month?

Let me know your thoughts and if you want, I can put up a poll.

Thanks!


back to top