Beyond Reality discussion
Previous BotM--DISCUSSIONS
>
2011-03 THE NAME OF THE WIND: roll call and initial impressions (NO SPOILERS)
I have been a member of the group for quite a while, but this is my first time jumping in and reading a book with everyone. I picked it up on my Kindle last night and started reading it. I only read the first chapter, but so far it looks pretty good. I like that Rothfuss starts out with something interesting rather then tons of 'get to know the characters' dialog. So, chapter one has me hooked, let's see if it stays that way.
This is another that is in the TBR Pile. One of the associates at a book store I frequent loves it. I bought it on her recommendation. She actually gave me a dirty look when I told her I haven't read it yet. I don't think I am going to make it this month.I plan on this year though, looking at late fall.
Mod
I don't know. I read this when it 1st came out, really liked it, remember a bit. I would want to re-read it before reading Day 2 which came yesterday.OTOH, I am feeling a need to start Grand Conspiracy
What to do...
Read Name of the Wind when it came out. I will comment in the spoiler area - nice for anyone starting now that the second book is available. My favorite part so far was the opening chapter, which was brilliant.
Already read it, found it a fair read but don't plan to read it again. I may join in the discussion later, once spoilers are "okay". Errr...or on the other thread where spoilers are acceptable (LOL).
I initially read this a couple of years ago and enjoyed it quite a lot. I've been trying to do a reread to refresh my memory for the discussion, but I've only managed to get about 5 chapters in so far.Janny, I have to agree. I love the first few paragraphs. They created a mood for me that drew me in and made me want to know where things would lead.
I read this last month and will probably post from time to time.I thought there were some flashes of brilliance. I was expecting to either love this or hate this; surprisingly, I did neither. (If anyone wants to read my rambling but non-spoilery review, it's here. Note that there is a minor contextless spoiler in the status updates at the bottom. But they're mostly just me griping about spelling, proofreading, and usage.)
I've finished the first chapter of The Name of the Wind. So far so good. And, I'm happy that I've finally got organized enough to read the group's BOTM during that month!!!
I've read it a few times over the years, so I won't be re-reading it with the group.
However, I think I can recall enough of it that I can join in on some discussions.
However, I think I can recall enough of it that I can join in on some discussions.
I've read it once, and plan on re-reading a little later this month before I move on to WMF. I'm kind of afraid I won't love it as much the second time around as I did the first.. I'm really hoping that doesn't happen!
I have a copy of this book staring right at me from a shelf just off my left shoulder, but I just can't do it--too big a book to get through in a month with so many pressing work priorities and other books in progress. But I will read it--eventually--I promise!
Not going to read the book, hate the book, the main character, his actions are not justified enough for me. To me the whole book is based on the the character's action.
To me the whole book is based on the the character's action.I'm curious what you mean by that, Kevin. Aren't most books?
Snail in Danger (Nikki) wrote: "To me the whole book is based on the the character's action.I'm curious what you mean by that, Kevin. Aren't most books?"
Sorry, I meant the whole book is decided on Kvothe's action, which if a person like me don't like him, then the whole book is gone, there is no other character to hang on to like in most books.
I liked Bast and Auri, and kind of wished they got more screen time. And some of the other characters gave the impression of having depths, even if we didn't see much of them.I agree the book is K-centric. I wasn't terribly fond of him either, but I think him being that way is sort of the point, or part of the story. Almost anyone who has dealt with the stuff he has (being vague to avoid spoilers) would have, um, adjustment problems.
Snail in Danger (Nikki) wrote: "I liked Bast and Auri, and kind of wished they got more screen time. And some of the other characters gave the impression of having depths, even if we didn't see much of them.I agree the book is..."
Good point, but how come some can while other just can't overcome problems like his.
I've just started it. It's been on my list for a long time, but I am always wary of beginning a series, so I've procrastinated. I'm hopeful, though, and I'm really liking the style and voice so far.
Read it a few years back. Been slowly listening to it on audio as a re-read. Love the book, looking forward to discussion. =)
I really can't wait to start reading. Going to the library today, I've already put it in my hold list.
I've made it through the first 6 chapters and I'm intrigued as to where it is going. Or in Kvothe's case where it came from.
Its been sitting on my TBR shelf forever. Its nice to get a chance to read it starting this weekend.
I read it a few years ago when it first came out in paperback. It was a great read. May have to go back and skim though because I've ordered the second one in hardback. I just hope it won't take him as long to finish the 3rd book.
I have to reread it ready for part 2 as well!
Mod
Argh! I just realized I need to read this this month! Ok, ok, I'll put it in my current month list!
about two thirds of the way into the audiobook. i loved the opening - the set up in the inn and the events immediately following - and there have been flashes of true brilliance in the main body (i've laughed out loud and possibly punched the air in joy), but a lot of it has dragged, too. i'm wondering if a lot fo this should have been left as back story, referred to rather than told in such detail.difficult to say as i'm not at the end, but i can't see myself continuing with the series if it carries on being Kvothe telling his tale rather than getting up-to-date by the end of the first volume.
Sherri wrote: "Ok, I am paused right where the frame goes into the flashback, and...I can't work up interest enough to pick it up again. What IS wrong with me?"Nothing?
Colleen ~blackrose~ wrote: "Sherri wrote: "Ok, I am paused right where the frame goes into the flashback, and...I can't work up interest enough to pick it up again. What IS wrong with me?"
Nothing?"
What she said.
Nothing?"
What she said.
"Readers are not sheep, and not every pen tempts them." (I'm not afraid to steal other people's lines.)
Nothing wrong with light and fluffy once in a while. Sometimes you're just not in the right headspace for something serious...
Sometimes I feel a bit sad that I don't seem to like a lot of popular books. I feel like I'm missing something and, yes, even that there's something wrong with me sometimes.But, ya know, you like what you like - nothing you can do about it.
And maybe it is just a mood thing. Why not read some light and fluffy things and then come back to this later and see if you get into it more?
(Good quote there, Danger Snail.) :)
Nothing wrong with weird.But, if it helps, it's not all that depressing. At least I didn't think so. Parts were, yes, but I was more bored than anything. (That probably doesn't help. Maybe I should let someone else should gear you up for it. LOL)
I say let Kevin talk her into reading it
LOL!That would be perfect.
Um. Let's see. Bast is a rockin' sidekick.
In all honesty, once you get past Tarbean, it stops being depressing. But his suffering to, and in, Tarbean help to set his character.
When you get past that is when it gets fun.
When you get past that is when it gets fun.
Ala wrote: "In all honesty, once you get past Tarbean, it stops being depressing."True true.
If you get to the University portion and still find it lacking, I'd say that'd be a good point to just toss the book ;)
I'm re-reading this before going on to the sequel. I read it from the library when it first came out, and spent many nights up past my bedtime reading "just one more chapter." Looking forward to reading the next book soon :) I just bought both of them in hardcover I liked the first so much!
I'm re-reading this before going on to the sequel. I read it from the library when it first came out, and spent many nights up past my bedtime reading "just one more chapter." Looking forward to reading the next book soon :) I just bought both of them in hardcover I liked the first so much!
So far, I am thoroughly enjoying the story. I. Haven't gotten much far because of late night work and a cousin that seems to call everytime I open my book. Tonight I am dedicating 2 hours and a cup of frozen yogurt to this extremely well written story. I took the hardcover copy out of the library because I wanted the flow to be easier.
I am impressed and I am on the edge of my seat wanting to know more and devour more pages. It is refreshing to read a story that finally respects the reader and applies intelligence.
Kara wrote: "Read it a few years back. Been slowly listening to it on audio as a re-read. Love the book, looking forward to discussion. =)"I'm doing the same. I am really loving the audiobook. I got it in audio because I'm planning on listening to The Wise Man's Fear because that was the least expensive way to get it. The ebook is $12.99 vs. $11.50 for my Audible credit. The narrator is fantastic and I'm picking up a lot of stuff I missed when I read it the first time.
I read it & loved it. I may skim through it again to refresh my memory for discussion and to prepare to read the sequel.
Sandi wrote: "Kara wrote: "Read it a few years back. Been slowly listening to it on audio as a re-read. Love the book, looking forward to discussion. =)"I'm doing the same. I am really loving the audioboo..."
Hmmm. Maybe I'll listen to #2 if I like this one. Am only two chapters in, but am loving the writing. And am engaged so far.
I picked this up based upon a friend's recommendation. I'm currently about 200 pages in and really enjoying the story.
I read this ages ago... and seem to remember loving it. Hope this really was the case as I've now got #2 and just "rebought" NOTW in hardback. Bit OCD about all my series being of the same format!Anyhoo looking forward to reading it again, before starting #2, but have a few reviews owed on other books first. Hopefully before end of March.
Theresa wrote: "Started it late last week, and am about 1/4 of the way through it, roughly. Can't seem to put it down, but have to read it slowly as it might get too heavy for me :-) Loving the characterizations..."The characterization is the least favorite part of The Name of the Wind, but characterization is usually my favorite part of a book.
Just started my re-read on the bus home and had forgotton how much I liked the opening with the different silences. PS Totally have dangermouse theme in my head!
Beyond Reality
Books mentioned in this topic
The Wise Man's Fear (other topics)The Name of the Wind (other topics)
Grand Conspiracy (other topics)
The Name of the Wind (other topics)
Authors mentioned in this topic
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)Patrick Rothfuss (other topics)
No spoilers in this thread please!