Severus Snape, The Prince, The Hero, The Best discussion

52 views
Debates! > Harry Potter vs. Twilight

Comments Showing 451-500 of 532 (532 new)    post a comment »

message 451: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
eww


message 452: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
i know!!!!


message 453: by Minh (new)

Minh (cassandrale179) | 743 comments Arti wrote: "yeah, we're in 7th grade, and she's crushing on this new 6th grader named Max. She's obbsessed"

oh... ! I never like anyone is younger than me... I mean, at least I feel like they are my little brothers!


message 454: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Exactly


message 455: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
ewww


message 456: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
icks


message 457: by anjali (new)

anjali Just Slytherin Along wrote: "HEY!! DIDNT WE JUST GET INTO AGREEMENT THAT SNAPE IS OKAY?!??!"

BUT JACOBS NOT!!!!!!!! TWILIGHT IS!! THE CHARACER JACOB HAS LOTS OF POTENTIAL!


message 458: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
AHH!!!!!! YOU LIKE AJCOB!!!!!!!


message 459: by anjali (new)

anjali YES. And proud!


message 460: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
+shudder+


message 461: by anjali (new)

anjali :(

Why are you a hater?


message 462: by [deleted user] (new)

Eh....

I tried Twilight and only got to the third book till the bile in my throat just....I couldnt take it anymore.
But, I must say, IN THE BOOKS NOT THE STUPID MOVIES I liked Jacob more than stupid Cullen Abercrombie Model Dude. At least Jacob wasnt angsty and weird...Sort of true to life, happier.
Now, I hate Jacob in the movie. All Taylor Lautner does is take off his shirt. Its like "Hi Bella-RAWARARRARARARRR!!!! EPIC DISPLAY OF THE RIPPING OF A SHIRT!!!!"
Or, at least it is to me.
But, hey...I liked some of the Cullen Characters...Such as Jasper and Alice....Jasper more than Alice, actually.
And I liked the dude at the school, you know....Eric I think is his name. He was cool.
But other than that....*points thumb down*


message 463: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
luhvBOOKS *~Colin Morgan/JD Forever~* wrote: ":(

Why are you a hater?"


Cause its a dumb idea. Vampires and Werewolves. Nothing as interesting as wizards and witches.


message 464: by anjali (new)

anjali Wow. Wow. I AM NOT COMPARING HP AND TWILIGHT. wow!! THATS LIKE, UNCOMPARABLE, K?

I'm only saying I like Jacob.


message 465: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Yeah, but I still dont like huim cause,
a. Lupin's a werewolf
b. Jacob's from Twilight


message 466: by anjali (new)

anjali Wait; do you like Lupin?


message 467: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Lupin beats Jacob as a werewolf anyday. I dont like Lupin and he's not in my top 10, but still HP werewolves beat Twilight Werewolves


message 468: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
even fenrir greyback


message 469: by [deleted user] (last edited Oct 25, 2011 04:47AM) (new)

I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The authors are talented and have equal status as great authors. However, Rowling pushed for hers to become a story. She worked day and night, as a single mother, writing the story of the boy wizard we love. Whereas Meyer just "dreamed" two forbidden lovers in a field. So, in my eyes, -my EYES. so don't hate me..- Rowling worked harder. She lived with a young daughter, where she had just left her husband, and she was alone, yet she was dedicated to write Harry's story. So I believe Rowling wanted it more. Hence, I vote Harry Potter.

-Brenne


message 470: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Just Slytherin Along wrote: "even fenrir greyback"

yeah


message 471: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The authors are talented and have equal status ..."


agreed!


message 472: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (last edited Oct 25, 2011 05:16PM) (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The authors are talented and have equal status ..."


I totally agree.

Confession Time:
Please!Please don't hate me... but at first *breathes deeply and shuts eyes* I was really into Twilight,at the beginning until New Moon...

But then, Harry Potter came and brought meaning to my life!!!I would rather drop dead that to say that at the present I love ...erm the Twilight books,just so you know.

Please put away your eggs and tomatoes and don't hit me*shakes in my Gryffindor striped socks*

On a more serious note Harry Potter actually had a meaning to it,the story, a story of a boy whose destiny that was decided when an evil wizard murdered his family,he grows up abused and neglected by his idiot Uncle,Aunt and brat cousin, in ignorance of his heritage and years later finds out his true identity and his place and his role in the entire Wizarding world!

The books each had a new thrilling story where Harry and his trusty friends risk their lives battling evil and it all leads up to something actually significant,the defeat of the most evil and merciless wizard in history...

...not ending with a cry-a-baby once upon a time human now vampire princess in all her sparkly glory.Yah.Meyer actually filled up four books of an icky love story, where Bella cried about how lame she is(but you've got to admire her honesty on that one there) and pale and unattractive she is.Really?Because she's got a handfull of guys who wanted to go out with her,eh.Oh how Edward deserved someone better than her and so on..

Poor Jacob,though.Arti perlease don't bite, but I like werewolves in general,well the stable ones, including Lupin because he's in my fav. top 10.

But that's my opinion yo.But overall Meyer had worked hard and apparently lots of people like her work, and I wouldn't want to call any author dumb or stupid or crack because they write what comes to them and it wouldn't be fair to hurt them,unless they're corrupt,biased jerks.My words may seem contradicting but they're really not.

I don't like Twilight that much any more but I appreciate all the effort Meyer had put into her work.

But as Brenne and Charlie! had mentioned earlier Mrs. Rowling had worked under much more demanding circumstances than Stef. Meyer and her work was just bloody brilliant!


message 473: by [deleted user] (last edited Oct 25, 2011 05:52PM) (new)

Devina wrote: "Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The authors are tal..."


Some one agrees with me? Is, um I am alive correct?
-Brenne


message 474: by [deleted user] (new)

Arti wrote: "Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The authors are tal..."


Again, I'm shocked. I've been agreed too!
-Brenne

(In your face Charlie!)


message 475: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
so...the conclusion is that Jacob sucks? :)?


message 476: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (last edited Oct 25, 2011 06:22PM) (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
The vampires suck,that one's for sure(pun definitely intended)!Jacob yeah,he sucks too because he fell for Bella in the first place THEN her Daughter,eh.


message 477: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "Arti wrote: "Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter are both amazing books. The au..."


lol!I had to agree because you made perfect sense:)


message 478: by [deleted user] (new)

Devina wrote: "Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "Arti wrote: "Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "I'll add my belly button. -my math teacher calls opinions belly buttons, since everyone has one.-

Twilight and Harry Potter ar..."


Yay(: Happy now!
-Brenne


message 479: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Devina wrote: "The vampires suck,that one's for sure(pun definitely intended)!Jacob yeah,he sucks too because he fell for Bella in the first place THEN her Daughter,eh."

he fell for her daughter? EW!


message 480: by [deleted user] (new)

Arti wrote: "Devina wrote: "The vampires suck,that one's for sure(pun definitely intended)!Jacob yeah,he sucks too because he fell for Bella in the first place THEN her Daughter,eh."

he fell for her daughter? EW!"


Yes. He did. It's just a bit weird.
-Brenne


message 481: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
Cradle-snatcher!


message 482: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
By the way,Happy Diwali everyone!
description


message 483: by anjali (new)

anjali Arti wrote: "Lupin beats Jacob as a werewolf anyday. I dont like Lupin and he's not in my top 10, but still HP werewolves beat Twilight Werewolves"

No way. Lupin turns into this ferocious half-man, half-beast.


message 484: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
But Jacob turns into an annoying stupid wimpy thing


message 485: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Devina wrote: "By the way,Happy Diwali everyone!
"


same to you!


message 486: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Just Slytherin Along wrote: "But Jacob turns into an annoying stupid wimpy thing"

xD


message 487: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
lol


message 488: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
I had so much fun lighting sparklers!


message 489: by [deleted user] (new)

Arti wrote: "I had so much fun lighting sparklers!"

Sparklers! <3
-Brenne


message 490: by Devina , ~The Auror~Gryffindors Rock~ (new)

Devina  (honeybdgr_reads) | 836 comments Mod
My Diwali was okay but I didn't get to light sparklers though or any firecrackers...my cousin did but I had to stay inside because of all the chaos outside and because I'm a fragile little flower that'll fly awayi in the wind;translation: I'm a wee girl.Yah.I HATE THAT!

BTW I forgot to tell you guys that today is my graduation!I didn't mention anything earlier because I thought that I wouldn't be going but now I am.If you people are up to it I tell you all about it when I get back:)

I'm all dressed up right now and my friend put war paint on me(make up) and they were all supprised because I NEVER volunteer to wear make up on.Ever.I'll see if I can post my pic when I get back!

Wish me luck,that I don't trip and rip my dress and break something, because then I'll be wearing a paperbag over my face for the rest of my life!


message 491: by [deleted user] (new)

Devina wrote: "My Diwali was okay but I didn't get to light sparklers though or any firecrackers...my cousin did but I had to stay inside because of all the chaos outside and because I'm a fragile little flower t..."

You're graduating? Cool(:
-Brenne


message 492: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
Devina wrote: "My Diwali was okay but I didn't get to light sparklers though or any firecrackers...my cousin did but I had to stay inside because of all the chaos outside and because I'm a fragile little flower t..."

awesome!! and whats Diwali?


message 493: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Brenne and Charlie! wrote: "Arti wrote: "I had so much fun lighting sparklers!"

Sparklers! <3
-Brenne"


ikr! me and my couz had a wizard duel


message 494: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
Just Slytherin Along wrote: "Devina wrote: "My Diwali was okay but I didn't get to light sparklers though or any firecrackers...my cousin did but I had to stay inside because of all the chaos outside and because I'm a fragile ..."

the most famous Indian holiday of all times


message 495: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
ohh.


message 496: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
yeah. do you have any friends that celebrate it?


message 497: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
no, i dont think so


message 498: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
oh, well it's the festival of lights so we light candles and play with LEGAL sparklers. I posted a pic of me and my cousin Arushi


message 499: by ~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~, Who cries (literally) when someone insults Snape (new)

~*Just Slytherin Along w/ The Creatures*~ (Patrick Swayze's lover) (thejsaway) | 7914 comments Mod
lol oh cool!


message 500: by Arti, who is obsessed with Hermione Granger and Emma Watson (new)

Arti (a3books4) | 6732 comments Mod
yeah. We a had a wizards duel. It was fun :)


back to top

43473

Severus Snape, The Prince, The Hero, The Best

unread topics | mark unread


Books mentioned in this topic

The Host (other topics)