Kids/Teens Book Club discussion
Page-to-screen
>
The Hunger Games!
For me, Ian Sommerhalder is the perfect Finnick:
[image error]
[image error]
And I think ROBERT DOWNEY JUNIOR would be a great Haymitch
[image error]

[image error]
[image error]

And I think ROBERT DOWNEY JUNIOR would be a great Haymitch
[image error]



Moving on... :)
Someone on a Hunger Games site mentioned it, and I agree completely. Hugh Laurie could totally pull off Haymitch (he never would, though).
Other than that, I don't really have any preference. Saying no is easier. :P
Like, for instance, there are rumors that Chloe Moretz from Kick-*** is interested in the role of Katniss. No.



http://mockingjay.net/2010/09/07/the-...
Yeah, Kaya Scodelario has come up a lot in discussions. I think she'd work. More than Chloe Moretz, at least...
ANDREW ADAMSON!
CHRONICLES OF NARNIA!
I THINK HE SHOULD DIRECT IT!!!!!!!!!!
Scodelario.....yeah, maybe. That could work. As long as she gets rid of the English accent.
CHRONICLES OF NARNIA!
I THINK HE SHOULD DIRECT IT!!!!!!!!!!
Scodelario.....yeah, maybe. That could work. As long as she gets rid of the English accent.

I really don't know who I would cast, but I agree with RDJ as Haymitch.


hmm.....maybe AnnaSophia Robb as someone? A Carreer maybe?
hm...I disagree.
I wouldnt want well known actors being cast for the heck of it.
All the teenagers should be small names, or making their debut in the film.
The adults...some of them should be big names (RDJ) but not all.
I wouldnt want well known actors being cast for the heck of it.
All the teenagers should be small names, or making their debut in the film.
The adults...some of them should be big names (RDJ) but not all.

If *anyone* from TWILIGHT appears in this, I will actually cry :)
Okay-This just popped into my head:
Michael Urie as Cinna.
Im not sure if it would work, but im just throwing it out there:

[image error]
[image error]
Dunno, just came to mind.
He plays that fasion designer in Ugly Betty
Okay-This just popped into my head:
Michael Urie as Cinna.
Im not sure if it would work, but im just throwing it out there:

[image error]
[image error]
Dunno, just came to mind.
He plays that fasion designer in Ugly Betty
Yeah, looking at the second photo I think he could really do a solid job :)
May cast so far:
Robert Downey Jnr..............Haymitch Abernathy
Ian Sommerhalder...............Finnick Odair
Michael Urie......................Cinna
May cast so far:
Robert Downey Jnr..............Haymitch Abernathy
Ian Sommerhalder...............Finnick Odair
Michael Urie......................Cinna

And can we cast this with ANYONE? Not just American actors?
What do you mean not just American?
Of course anyone could have a role. They would just need to not have a thick accent.
Of course anyone could have a role. They would just need to not have a thick accent.

In that case, I almost want to cast Emma Thompson as Effie. I know she's a bigger name, but she seems to be able to pull off any role that's thrown at her quite well, and for some reason that's how I always pictured Effie.
hmmmm.....Maybe.
Im not sure about that one.
She is a terrific actor, no doubt, but im not sure about that.
I am not disagreeing, but im not agreeing either.
I always imagined Effie looking a bit like Umbrige, but with pink hair.
But i wouldnt like her cast as Effie.
Im not sure about that one.
She is a terrific actor, no doubt, but im not sure about that.
I am not disagreeing, but im not agreeing either.
I always imagined Effie looking a bit like Umbrige, but with pink hair.
But i wouldnt like her cast as Effie.

I am not sure about Thompson, either... Just a thought. I sort of pictured Effie as older, trying to look young.
Ive only seen Staunton in a few films myself.
I dont think she would be good for the role, but when imagining Effie she did come to mind.
I dont think she would be good for the role, but when imagining Effie she did come to mind.

She also seems to have this ditzy blonde quality to her... Or at least, that's Katniss' perception of her.

[image error]

Hmm but I don't get the whole Alex Pettyfer as Peeta thing.. Has everybody seen photos of him lately? He just doesn't have the... roundness, or boyishness that Peeta has, (but that's just my opinion I guess). Hunter Parrish as Peeta yes yes yes yes yes please :)
Kaya as Katniss definitely!

HUGH LAURIE for Haymitch all the way!
RDJ doesn't look sallow-faced and binge-drinker enough (now) for Haymitch. Hugh Laurie, based on his mannerisms from HOUSE, just looks like a drunk. Lol.
I'd like to have an unknown as Katniss, someone who could give an original performance without being compared to her other work. I also always imagined Katniss and Gale as blonde and Peeta as dark-haired, but I'm probably the odd one out on that one :P

YES, YES, YES. Amelia, that's a perfect description. And hilarious, too.


That's what my sister said!


It's all about the angles of the face.. and his height. Pettyfer is too manly and old-looking to be Peeta.


i agree!!

Amelia (Imagination in Focus) wrote: "eww NO for Alex Pettyfer being Peeta. Alex is the one that everyone wants to be Jace, which I think is a better casting. Peeta's supposed to be innocent and sweet and stuff, and Alex kinda has that..."
Amelia, I toatlly agree with the Alex Pettyfer thing.
But I also think that Kaya is perfect for Katniss (Ive never heard of her before) and that RDJ is an exceptional choice for Haymitch.
Amelia, I toatlly agree with the Alex Pettyfer thing.
But I also think that Kaya is perfect for Katniss (Ive never heard of her before) and that RDJ is an exceptional choice for Haymitch.
Books mentioned in this topic
A Game of Thrones (other topics)Dead Heat (other topics)
Blockade Billy (other topics)
Dead Heat (other topics)
The Throne of Fire (other topics)
More...
Now put yourself in the shoes of the Casting Agents.
Who would you choose to play each character?
Why? Why not?
Discuss choices here.