Kids/Teens Book Club discussion
Page-to-screen
>
The Hunger Games!
message 1001:
by
Ayunda
(new)
Jul 03, 2011 07:20AM

reply
|
flag

TYPE W/O SPACES:
< spoiler > SUBJECT HERE < / spoiler >

Seeeee....
(view spoiler)

Alex Pettyfer should be Peeta.
and Drew Roy should be Gale. They're perfect!! :)

2. I think they messed them up too.
3. I'm still way tooo excited about Danny Elfman.
They used Liam frigging Hemsworth as Gale! I am NOT HAPPY!
I agree that Gale sucks, though Alex Pettyfer would be a much worse Peeta. Just because hes blonde and a pretty boy, doesnt mean he needs to play every blonde character. We ranted on about this ages ago..

I do, however, approve of the girl who is playing Katniss.

Except for Cinna. That one still irks me.



Alex Pettyfer should be Peeta.
and Drew Roy should be Gale. They're perfect!! :)"
They are! When I watched Beastly the first thing I said was, "PEETA"

Actually, there is surprisingly little gore for a novel with that-it really isnt a bloodbath, except for a scene here and there. I hope they dont chicken out though. I still want SOME violence.
Gosh, they should have let Quentin Tarantino direct.
^ I am kidding. Maybe.
Gosh, they should have let Quentin Tarantino direct.
^ I am kidding. Maybe.


(view spoiler) ["br"]>["br"]>

I'm not very happy with how they look. Peeta's fine, if not a little bulky, but I have issues with Gale.
But if they act their parts in the movie on an Oscar winning level (which they won't) then all is forgiven.
Guitar Chick wrote: "Gale looks like a body builder who goes to the gym everday for two hours. Not. Cool.
I'm not very happy with how they look. Peeta's fine, if not a little bulky, but I have issues with Gale.
But i..."
Jennifer Lawrence was at Oscar nomination level last year. She'll make up for it.
(In my humble opinion, she was robbed of the Oscar for Best Leading Actress)
aaaaaaaaaaaaand...PEETA LOOKS WAY TO OLD AND BULKY.
In my imagination he was a cute-not hot-boy with bright blonde hair, babyish features and was the tinniest bit chubby.
I'm not very happy with how they look. Peeta's fine, if not a little bulky, but I have issues with Gale.
But i..."
Jennifer Lawrence was at Oscar nomination level last year. She'll make up for it.
(In my humble opinion, she was robbed of the Oscar for Best Leading Actress)
aaaaaaaaaaaaand...PEETA LOOKS WAY TO OLD AND BULKY.
In my imagination he was a cute-not hot-boy with bright blonde hair, babyish features and was the tinniest bit chubby.


(view spoiler) ["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>


The first one was too photoshopped. Im ignoring it.
Jennifer Lawrence: I love her. This casting is near perfection. Both in acting and looks. She does seem a little pretty for Katniss, but Im sure it'll be okay when shes covered in mud and blood.
Liam Hemsworth: Firstly, I hated him. I mean, I was on the verge of tears hating him. But that second picture actually looks pretty good. I imagined Gale a little younger & slimmer, but it could definitely work. Considering he wont be in it so much, I approve.
Josh Hutcherson: Im on the rocks. He looked way too bulky in the first pic, but hopefully he wont be flexing those muscles too often. His hair isnt blonde enough in the second, but thats due to the lighting, I suppose. Im on the rocks about him as well.
Jennifer Lawrence: I love her. This casting is near perfection. Both in acting and looks. She does seem a little pretty for Katniss, but Im sure it'll be okay when shes covered in mud and blood.
Liam Hemsworth: Firstly, I hated him. I mean, I was on the verge of tears hating him. But that second picture actually looks pretty good. I imagined Gale a little younger & slimmer, but it could definitely work. Considering he wont be in it so much, I approve.
Josh Hutcherson: Im on the rocks. He looked way too bulky in the first pic, but hopefully he wont be flexing those muscles too often. His hair isnt blonde enough in the second, but thats due to the lighting, I suppose. Im on the rocks about him as well.


The actors both look better as their characters. As long as they do the movie right (or right in my mind) then I will be happy. But that also extends to the director, writers, etc.



They are definitely allowed to make changes, as long as they dont effect the story line and are in nature with the book: ie, cutting Madge's character is fine, where as making Gale sneak into the Capitol to be with Katniss is definitely not. (Im not sure if thats happening. It appeared in one version of the script, but I think they changed it.)
I cant wait for a Haymitch picture!
I cant wait for a Haymitch picture!

He is.

I seriously hope they changed the Gale sneaking in thing. Like, it would be horrible if he snuck in.

I'm not very happy with how they look. Peeta's fine, if not a little bulky, but I have issu..."
I know :) I really like Jen as Katniss. I'm comfortable with that. She's one of the best talents out on the field right now.

MUCH better. You much much much better. They don't look as Twilight right there.
No!
That makes me so mad, when people try to 'tweet' themselves into the role, like Max Adler did for Cato. I hope he doesnt-and dont think he will-get the role.
I know Finnick was supposed to be around 24 in the book, but Jennifer Lawrence & Josh Hutcherson will be that age by the time we get Catching Fire! Plus, I always imagined Finnick as a little older, but still attractive. It needs to look like he has experience in the games.
Get Ian Sommerhalder, no exceptions. He is Finnick.
Actually, I would settle for Jude Law as well :)
That makes me so mad, when people try to 'tweet' themselves into the role, like Max Adler did for Cato. I hope he doesnt-and dont think he will-get the role.
I know Finnick was supposed to be around 24 in the book, but Jennifer Lawrence & Josh Hutcherson will be that age by the time we get Catching Fire! Plus, I always imagined Finnick as a little older, but still attractive. It needs to look like he has experience in the games.
Get Ian Sommerhalder, no exceptions. He is Finnick.
Actually, I would settle for Jude Law as well :)
Books mentioned in this topic
A Game of Thrones (other topics)Dead Heat (other topics)
Blockade Billy (other topics)
Dead Heat (other topics)
The Throne of Fire (other topics)
More...