Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?

Oh cool - this one is on my to read list (and to buy list). Will maybe make it my next buy then ... :)



Yes! You really have to. I just found out the Wachowski..."
Thanks Riona and Max - will do!!!

Honestly, I wasn't trying to challenge you or anything, I was just curious whether there was a unifying theme to those who dislike it. But apparently it's very individual. Some people think Thomas Hardy is the most amazing writer ever, while I find him only just readable.


I'm such an Austenophile that it amazes me to hear people say the..."
I definitely thought parts of it were funny - when Austen is describing the characters she doesn't take seriously like Collins. However, I got extremely bored with the characters she does take seriously (Elizabeth, Darcy, Jane). I thought they were just as ridiculous as the rest of the characters, but Austen wasn't making fun of them. So I was bored out of my mind by the mundane details of Darcy and Elizabeth's relationship torments - I just didn't care to take their relationship seriously.
I don't think it's Austen's style I have a problem with. Like I said, I agree there are very funny moments, especially towards the beginning of the book. It's more the content that I didn't enjoy, along with Austen's tendency to detail the minutiae of everything when she is taking events/characters seriously.



I haven't read Cloud Atlas yet but managed to get ahold of his more recent Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet - which was really good, and made me more eager to read Cloud Atlas. I could imagine Thousand Autumns making it on to the list eventually.

I'm with you - I'm not a Jane Austen fan ... :)


Having just finished a re-read of Madame Bovary, I picked up this one. It was a perfect segue, sort of a combined biography of Flaubert and musings of the author on the human condition. I really enjoyed it, largely for all the tastey Flaubert quotes from his letters and other writings. But Barnes has a flair for the mot juste himself and the narrator, a retired doctor and amateur Flaubert detective, is entertaining too. Don't go into it expecting a plot and you will probably enjoy the ride. Four stars.

Those are great names. I've been meaning to get to Trollope, but I have a pile of borrowed books that I must plow through so that I can return them to their rightful homes.
What I do know about Trollope is his unique writing style. He awoke at 4am every morning and wrote for two hours before leaving for his day job. If in those two hours he happened to write "The End," he simply pulled that last page of the book out of his typewriter, rolled in the next page, and started a new book. That's dedication!

I can understand that. The abundant detail is not to everyone's taste--which is why I love The Lord of the Rings and reread it regularly, while my husband wouldn't reread it on a bet. I live for all that detail-y stuff. But it's not for everyone.


Just finished The Corrections. I thorougly enjoyed squirming through the entire novel. Franzen is truly masterful at allowing the truth of these character's shine through layers of self-deception, shame, and defensiveness. They are human, indeed. For my money, qualifies to be added to the pantheon of Great American Novels. Here is the link to The Corrections



I can understand that...."
I actually love abundant detail - Charles Dickens is a major favorite of mine, and I loved The Once and Future King. But what Dickens takes seriously and describes in detail, I also take seriously. And T.H. White describes in detail with whimsy that I also appreciate. Austen's detail bugs me because she takes seriously things like going over Elizabeth's conversation with Darcy in the garden, and I thought the whole convo was absurd.
Anyway, it's great to disagree about books - and debating is a wonderful way to make sure everyone is more entrenched in their own viewpoint! :) Thanks for having the conversation, Gini!


I can u..."
It's been interesting! I'm always fascinated by what makes a book loved by some and hated by others, but I can seldom find a "common denominator." Taste is just a really subtle thing. Thanks for taking the time to consider!


I felt the same way about Shields' two books on the list, Robin. So many people have praised "Unless" that I sometimes think I should re-read it because I must have missed some gravitas!


I felt the same way ..."
It hints at it. It's a Good Feminist Book, I'd say, but as a feminist in the 21st century, I need more than that. I loved the read, just wanted More.




by Mark Haddon"
What did you think of it?


Wow Robin! That is great...I need less work, more reading!

I think I should have read Catcher in the Rye in my teens but I really enjoyed The Elegance of the Hedgehog

Is this one on the list?

Is this one on the list?"
Added to the 2006 list.


Hi Deanne - I'm South African. What did you think of this book?

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...
http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...