Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 3601:
by
Yrinsyde
(new)
Sep 14, 2010 01:23AM

reply
|
flag

what list is this book on...?

Liz wrote: "Bethany wrote: "Finished The Dud Avocado. Loved it! So glad I learned about it from this group."
what list is this book on...?"
My bad, somehow I thought it was on the list, but it's not. I could've sworn someone posted about it on this group. In any event, I highly recommend it.
what list is this book on...?"
My bad, somehow I thought it was on the list, but it's not. I could've sworn someone posted about it on this group. In any event, I highly recommend it.







A few people have been complaining in this forum about how Dickens is repetitious, "keeps on hammering" at things, etc. As a Dickens fan, I think it's important to point out that these books were originally printed in serialized form, so he did have to drop in reminders for people who had read the last chapter a full month previously, or even missed it. Kind of like how on soap operas, you'll always hear dialogue like, "But Lance, even though we made sweet love during the earthquake last week, we can't have a love affair, because you just found out that Jackson Farthingham is actually your long-lost sister, who had a sex change after coming out of the coma..."
Anyway, on topic, I just finished Justine. Kind of hated it, to be honest. I'm not big on aimless descriptions and philosophizing; I'm more of a meat and potatoes, character and pilot kind of gal.

You aren't alone in your Dickens loathing. I dislike him too, but I have yet to read Great Expectations.



I've been wondering why short stories made the list? Not that I'm not glad that there are some short easy ones on here, but since prose like the Iliad and the Odyssey were excluded I was surprised short stories were included.



I finished Black Dahlia. It was alright but not as good as I thought it would have been.


That was exactly what I thought about the movie.

About Dickens - I quite liked Great Expectations. But I think it has something to do with the style of book you enjoy as to whether you will enjoy Dickens. I feel like if you generally enjoy Jane Austen/Bronte, even to a small extent Hugo/Tolstoy (although they combine less "morality" as it where within their narrative) - ie - the very obvious, drawn out, sprawling, old fashioned novel, then you usually generally like Dickens. Whereas if you find those type of novels tedious and old fashioned, then I think Dickens generally is hard to bite. Whereas at least Austen has that trace of romance/society - to lure you in - or Tolstoy/Hugo have war - Dickens is pretty much a society/class only type tale, and I don't think everyone can associate with the repetition of one theme over and over.



Flora wrote: "Shardae wrote: "I finished Black Dahlia. It was alright but not as good as I thought it would have been."
That was exactly what I thought about the movie."
Yeah you were definitely right.
That was exactly what I thought about the movie."
Yeah you were definitely right.

Glad to hear it. I picked that one up on impulse at a used bookstore.


I wonder if it relates to his target audience, in comparison to Tolstoy/Bronte/Hugo/Austen. The serialized aspect means he was probably publishing for a lot wider (and perhaps less educated) population - in comparison to Bronte/Hugo/Austen - who were publishing for "sophisticated"/mature readers? And I think most people today, as a result of that quality, would direct a lot of Dicken's works to children (A Christmas Tale, David Copperfield, even Tale of Two Cities is usually a high school required read) while Tolstoy/Hugo are definitely something that wouldn't be be picked up till college (for the average person). Even Austen/Bronte wouldn't be touched on until at least late high school - and then only their seminal works would be hit.





Elise wrote: "Christine wrote: "Today I finished - at long last - Great Expectations by Charles Dickens. It's the first Dickens I've read as an adult. I gave it 2 starts. I never liked him as a kind, but I thoug..."
Lol I love your soap opera example.
Lol I love your soap opera example.

This was my first Wells book, and I loved it. It totally appealed to my n3rdcore and geekiness. A great fast read, highly recommended.

Flora
The BBC have just shown a version of Sherlock Holmes set in present day London, the first series of three is due to show in the US from the 24th of October.
Great programme which I enjoyed.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...