Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?

Hi Mike,
That is interesting, and I can totally see that.
Is it age or perspective? :)
Tanya,
I remember loving Anna Karenina, but I was 12 at the time and very into the melodrama of life...and love...
Suzanne

Also, I think it's fair to note that Margaret Mitchell wrote the book in 1937, over 60 years after the Civil War. Can you imagine someone writing a much-lauded novel today about how wonderful Jim Crow laws were?
(And this is not to say that a book or an author has to share all my politics in order for me to think it's worthwhile. I love Dickens, even though I cringe at characters like Fagin.)


I had never really looked at Gone with the Wind as a... apology for slavery, perhaps? I limited myself to think about it as the story of a woman that defies sterotypes and southern society standars, but in the way it did end up glorifying slavery and treating black people as dumb and careless children. I wonder if Margaret Mitchell actually thought like that, or merely felt that the South felt in such a way about their slaves. Either way, your comment is making me consider other aspects of this book as I continue to read it, so thank you very much :D

Just started The Book Thief"
I'm working from all three lists. I don't have The Book Thief on it. Am I missing it? Is it on one of the lists?"
The Book Thief is not on my 3 lists either.


It's a great movie, mostly faithful to the book. However, Mary Astor is miscast as Brigitte.

Amanda, it's supposed to be ''unpleasant'' -- that's Flannery O'Connor: all of her stories are religiously (Catholically) symbolistic and downright rough. She was living/writing in her faith. This is Flannery O'Connor. It's supposed to be cathartic.

Now, I picked up Joyce's Ulysses....Man! Do I punish myself? This is got to be the toughest, if not one of the toughest reads I've ever picked up. Having to use two exegetical text-helpers. This guy was DEEP.



by Bret Easton Ellis - ick, ick, icky, icky, ick. Not sure why my life would not be complete if I died before reading this book. I've wanted to read this book for many years, and very disappointed.
Can someone more literary explain what the purpose of the music review chapters? IMO, schlocky music from the '80s - maybe that was the point to write about the albums as if they were symphonies, giving more evidence of Bateman's complete lack of personhood.

You are my hero! I read the whole thing and felt like someone had played a very cruel joke on me. Oh, the horror...the horror! :)


I came across a great quote by Alcott the other day, when I was looking for quotes on reading for my blog: "She is too fond of reading, and it has turned her brain" (from Work: A Story of Experience).
Ex Lit Prof
www.the-reading-list.com

I agree that Mary Astor is miscast in the role (she's too innocent, in my view). Barbara Stanwyck would have been better. She is the femme fatale par excellence - particularly in Double Indemnity.
My review of the film (plus a family anecdote) can be read at:
http://shimosreadinglist.blogspot.com...



I gave Silk 5 stars!

I did not even know it was on the list to after I finished it .... was reading it as it was recommended on a detective fiction list (feels like a bous point..!)
Good British mystery ... I loved the dialogue and the wordplay in the advertising agency ...

Thanks Christine .... I'm going to try and read Nine Tailors next.

This book really had an affect on me. I know I'll find myself thinking about it in days to come. When I was first reading it, I thought "..."
Christine: I, too, was disturbed by "the sex" - (if he had been a teenage girl, we'd call it rape) and I couldn't get beyond it to appreciate the story. I read this book several years ago, so I'll try it again and see if my opinion changes.

...and how did hou like W.G. Sebald? I finished his ''Emigrants" a couple of months ago, and I am curious what you thought about him and his story, ''Vertigo'' ???

Like you, Mike, I loved Catch22 when I first read it and when I returned to enjoy it again I couldn't finish it.

...and how did hou like W.G. Sebald? I finished his ''Emigrants" a couple of months ag..."
BTW -- perhaps I should have said something about ''Emigrants'', one word: Haunting.
More? Okay: Four stories, told in an unusual genre would would call, I guess, Docu-fiction. a very, very different medium. Some may like it, some may not; but it is different -- a different style of story-telling.
Anyway, I'm still interested to hear from Asa, 'how did you like Vertigo?'



by Bret Easton Ellis - ick, ick, icky, icky, ick. Not sure why my life would not be complete if I died before reading this book. I've wanted to read this book for many years, and v..."
i agree. interesting in its own way, but in my opinion, incredibly overrated. but then i think that of bret easton ellis in general. to me, he is more of a symptom of the late 80s-early 90s and that time period's issues...rather than one of that period's great authors.
although i suppose i sort of liked Rules of Attraction. in a guilty kind of way.

Thank you for understanding that the sex was just a vehicle to connect the two German generations. His connection to this woman made him feel her actions on a personal basis and also gave him information to discover that she couldn't read.
Plus the author made him unable to have a good relationship during his life, thus showing the sex as damaging.
The reviewers say the book is about the younger generation living with the actions of their parents during WWII.
Debbie
>Christine wrote: "The Reader by Bernhard Schlink
This book really had an affect on me. I know I'll find myself thinking about it in days to come. When I was first reading it, I thought "..."

Lovecraft is supposedly the king of fantasy horror, and this is his best known novella. It's shocking, to say the least; but that is exactly the point, isn't it! Good read! Lots of science, real and imagined.

I think the fact that it was written in 1937 is what also makes it so interesting - that this book came out - where the North is pretty much blamed for "ruining" the South - and yet it, and the movie, were insanely popular. And really, isn't the sort of idea of the ruined South - and almost a yearning for the old South - still popularized through the continued use of the Confederate flag? I lived in Georgia for a semester and you see the Confederate flag everywhere. How much of an influence does a book like GWTW have on that continued conception/desire - by bringing that kind of desire to return to the past to the forefront in Southern culture.

"I repented having tried this second entrance, and was almost inclined to slip away before he finished cursing, but ere I could execute that intention, he ordered me in, and shut and re-fastened the door."
Doesn't that sound cool? I very much enjoyed this book. I believe the book is basicaly a love story, if you can believe that Heathcliff could ever love. He is one unsavory person. From the beginning to the end, his actions most certainly will get him into "perdition". I really could hardly put this book down. I continuosly wanted to read on to see what was coming in the next chapter. Aside from the story, I enjoyed reading this book slowly in order to enjoy the english prose.

...and how did hou like W.G. Sebald? I finished his ''Emigrants" a..."
I didn't enjoy Vertigo as much as I did The rings of Saturn that I read two years ago. I found it to be too meandering and pointless, and everyone's stories were so hopeless, without the interesting facts and the walking tour of The rings of Saturn.

This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...
One of my most favorite books of all time.