Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just finish?
message 5251:
by
Yrinsyde
(new)
Oct 20, 2011 01:37AM

reply
|
flag







Haven't read Of Love and Shadows, but what I've read of her, she is always writing of her native Peru. As in House of the Spirits, she was writing about the overthrow of her uncle Salvador Allende.

I'm glad that it seems to be a good book,
because I just brought myself a copy of it the other day.


Agreed!


It was great, wasn't it? I have been looking for good used copies of anything else he wrote ever since and have never been lucky enough to find any. This one is one of my favorites of all the ones on the lists.

Why? Can you elaborate? I'm trying to decide if I want to keep it on my wish list.

I read a collection of short stories of his earlier this year, which I hated. I won't be reading any Calvino. Too many other books.

Why? Can you elaborate? I'm trying to decide if I want to keep it on my wish list."
Being neither an academic nor intellectual I don't have training on the merits of her writing style so must rely on simply being an avid reader. If there was a plot it eluded me. It seemed simply to be a study on the lives of "proper" English girls at a boarding club for young women during the last stages of WW2. Personally, I need a well developed plot in a work of fiction, or at least an obvious reason for the book to have been written, to keep my interest. This is most likely a deficiency on my part and will willingly accept any enlightenment.

Why? Can you elaborate? I'm trying to decide if I want to keep it on my wish ..."
Mikela wrote: "Judith wrote: "Mikela wrote: "Just finished The Girls of Slender Means and I'm afraid it left me cold."
Why? Can you elaborate? I'm trying to decide if I want to keep it on my wish ..."
Mikela, I understand. Your comments give me quite enough to go on. And I prefer the same kind of books you describe!

No deficiency on your part. Some of us like mostly plot, some mostly characterization, some a balance between the two. Thankfully, this is so; it gives such a variety to the reading materials available. I prefer characterization, so would likely find this a good read, but that doesn't mean I don't want a good plot driven thriller thrown in for good measure occasionally.

I guess I fall into the balanced camp.

I definetly fall into the middle/balanced camp here. I am unable to get into a book if either is missing. :D


Agreed! I absolutely adore Hardy, but given my experiences reading "Tess of the D'Urbervilles" (one of my fave books) and "Jude the Obscure," I started "Far from the Madding Crowd" prepared for a misery fest. It was interesting to see him take a more moderate course--but I have to admit that I thought it lacked some of the depth of "Tess," for example. But maybe I'm just a misery monger! ;)

Lauli and Kristi
Love Hardy, and do find some of his books tragic, Tess wasn't my favourite, but I loved Return of the Native, The Mayor of Castorbridge and The Hand of Ethelberta was almost happy.


I thought it was an interesting take on post WW2 survival & the resourcefulness of the girls. The ending was sad though.



Way to go Lisa!! I may have to try this one!! =)

Ms. Smith had a lot to say in this novel...it's going to take me a while to ponder her various messages. I think the only character worth liking is Carl, the boy from Roxbury...he's probably the only truthful and real person in the entire book.
Has anyone else read this one? If so, what do you think?
Thankful for this list as I never would have picked this book up on my own.




The book is long but thoroughly absorbing. I listened to the version narrated by Juliet Stevenson. She may be my favorite female audiobook narrator.

Bea! You've got to watch the mini series now! It is wonderful!


I read this but haven't really written a review yet. It isn't on the 2010 list anymore though ... and that is the one I'm working from. She did have a lot to say but I'm not sure about this book ...


The book gets a big five stars from me. I would vote for the main character to be President of the USA if I could. It's a heartwarming and inspirational story but not corny or sentimental.

The book gets a big five stars from me. I would vote ..."
Couldn't you just feel the dust in the back of your throat and the sweat running down your spine?

The book gets a big five stars from me. I would vote ..."
Glad to find someone who liked it as much as I did.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Troubles (other topics)This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen (other topics)
Sister Carrie (other topics)
Life of a Good-for-nothing (other topics)
The Singapore Grip (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jorge Luis Borges (other topics)Juan Carlos Onetti (other topics)
Flann O'Brien (other topics)
Clarice Lispector (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
More...