Team Edward ~ Team Jacob discussion

41 views
The Books!! > breaking dawn

Comments Showing 51-91 of 91 (91 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by [deleted user] (new)

This is a disscussion about the book BD, right? Even as much as I hate anything narrarted by Bella after Chapter 4, I still really like Jacob's humor and loved the 2nd book because of Jacob's humor. So...it scores at #3


message 52: by [deleted user] (last edited Dec 12, 2010 02:42PM) (new)

Coral wrote: "This is a disscussion about the book BD, right? Even as much as I hate anything narrarted by Bella after Chapter 4, I still really like Jacob's humor and loved the 2nd book because of Jacob's humor..."

Team Eddie though I'm not one of those girls that will track you down and hurt you if you say he's stupid and you like Jacob.


message 53: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
Coral wrote: "This is a disscussion about the book BD, right? Even as much as I hate anything narrarted by Bella after Chapter 4, I still really like Jacob's humor and loved the 2nd book because of Jacob's humor..."


breaking dawns ma fave but i dont really like being in jakes mind cuz hes depressed so i like book three cuz even eddie isnt depressed and tlking bout killing himself in that part!!


message 54: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
Team Edward yayyyyyyy


message 55: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
yayayayayayayay!!!


message 56: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
and yeah ... In 3rd book Edward is a lot more happy and i like reading 2nd one also but the book do get a little depressed coz of Jake's pov but then it would have been horrible to read it from Bella's pov


message 57: by [deleted user] (new)

In Jacob's head is way funnier than Bella's. If you read carefully, in Eclipse and the beginning of BD, Bella is also depressed because of her love for jake...so they are both sad. Not to mention New Moon. If you think Jake was sad in BD, Bella's DEPRESSED in NM. So...I like Breaking Dawn a little better than New Moon


message 58: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
Shwetika wrote: "and yeah ... In 3rd book Edward is a lot more happy and i like reading 2nd one also but the book do get a little depressed coz of Jake's pov but then it would have been horrible to read it from Bel..."

yer and its hard listening to jacob cuz he knows he cant have her eventhough i dont like him its sad!! but i reckon its probably better hearing the birth scene in jakes head cuz it would be really sad and intense in eddies head!!! it would be torture for me cuz i luvz eddie!


message 59: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
yeah i know .. not only the birth scene but all the scenes b'4 birth from Edward's mind would have been very depressed coz he was really hurt ... and every time Bella's got hurt he was sooo sad......


message 60: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
yer but it would be aweful being inside edwards mind wen bellas heart stopped beating!!


message 61: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
yeah that's what i was saying and then 2nd part can also not be good from Bella POV(point of view ).. So I guess Jake pov was a good choice or the best one available to write 2nd part....


message 62: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
Shwetika wrote: "yeah that's what i was saying and then 2nd part can also not be good from Bella POV(point of view ).. So I guess Jake pov was a good choice or the best one available to write 2nd part...."


yer!! (you've read the mortal instruments right?? if you havemt then ignore this) did youu know that pretty much the whole of city of the fallen angels is in simons point of view!! i hope it atleast has him saying alot about jace and clary


message 63: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
have to read!!!


message 64: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
♫Mortal Instruments 4eva♫ wrote: "Shwetika wrote: "yeah that's what i was saying and then 2nd part can also not be good from Bella POV(point of view ).. So I guess Jake pov was a good choice or the best one available to write 2nd ..."

oh k !!! me too ... I have read them .... They are awesome !!!! :)))))


message 65: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
yer!!


message 66: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
BAHAHAHAHAHAH!!! anyways why do youu have to hide it from ur mom!!


message 67: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
Coraline wrote: "are they practically the same as Twilight? And I probably can't read them. My mom gets suspicious if I get Twilight books from the library. That's when I devised a plan to get the audiobooks and pu..."

seems like your mom is not a fan of twilight books....Why so ??? I means why doesn't she allow you to read them ??


message 68: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
yer??


message 69: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
hahahahhaha!!! wen your with your friends, do youu have to pretend to hate it??


message 70: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
Coraline wrote: "She allows- she just...is a blabbermouth. AND I have friends who absoluetly HATE Twilight AND my sister (9 yrs.) told my dad she was getting the movies on iTunes and he can't stop saying (verbatim)..."

okay .... I though she hate Twilight books ....


message 71: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
Coraline wrote: "Yeah, I have to pretend. It stinks."

ahahahaha all ma friends knoe i luv twilight sooo they tease me consistently but i just dont listen!!! would it be really bad if they found out!


message 72: by Neki (new)

Neki | 272 comments to Luna:You asked me to team i belong to,this is the only answer which I repeat over and over again.............



TEAM 'EDWARDANDJACOB'


I can't choose between them,so I always end up voting both!


message 73: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
kewlz!!!


message 74: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
aha okay then!!!


message 75: by Lindsay (new)

Lindsay (goodreadscombammy13) | 187 comments team jake
4ever


message 76: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
eddie


message 77: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
EDWARD !!!!!!!!


message 78: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
EDWARD ANTHONY CULLEN!!


message 79: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
<3 Eddi..... Eddi..... Eddi.... Eddi...<3


message 80: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
hahahah we should probs stop ahahah... no..... eddie eddie eddie eddie


message 81: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
hehe...(*^-^*)
EDWARD!!!!!!
He is awesome !!!


message 82: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
he is AMAZING!!!


message 83: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
he is epic and i <3 him


message 84: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
<3 him too....


message 85: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
<3 <3 <3


message 86: by Sophiee.†., forever... ~~~~<3 (new)

Sophiee.†. WaylandMellarkTallynCullen (BookLoversYeYe) | 1146 comments Mod
hahaha TEAM EDWARD


message 87: by Shwetika (new)

Shwetika | 818 comments Mod
yer ... Edward !!!


message 88: by Neki (new)

Neki | 272 comments And Jake has a good sense of humor too.If we had to listen to Bella during that period,all we'd get would be whining and pain...


message 89: by Neki (new)

Neki | 272 comments I LOVE that part!!!!


message 90: by Wishful Reader (new)

Wishful Reader | 130 comments even though im team edward , i have to admit hes jokes were funny!! :>


message 91: by [deleted user] (new)

This book is my favorite in the whole series. I loved every part of this book.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top