Jewish Book Carnival discussion
What are you reading?
message 151:
by
Erika
(new)
Jan 01, 2013 06:16AM

reply
|
flag

Update 1/15/13
Wow, this community thing really works. I'm embarrassingly uninitiated at things like this. Great to hear from everyone.
Well, just finished Pigeon. That was a hurtful blow. Did not expect that bravely realistic ending with everything withering away. Just shows how contaminated I am by pat Hollywood-type endings (and I've been a lifelong reader). But it is more than that. There was something about the ending that made it very different than many American novels that end on a more buoyant note (even Moby Dick has Ishmael floating unhurt on the waves after the disaster, and my personal favorite Saul Bellow also has jaunty endings, for which he's been criticized).
This was different. Pigeon was drenched in an intelligent and wry sadness that was very moving and, as the Greeks understood about tragedy and death on stage, satisfying. The only character that did not quite work for me was Meshulam the builder. Felt Shalev was trying for a lovable and exaggerated Dickens-type character that was just a bit off for me, but that's minor. I enjoyed it.

Thanks for this title... I will check this out...

I loved THE LOST, too. Have been meaning to get to Shalev but haven't managed yet. Maybe I need more time away from the television, too!

Both books are excellent, and I have them in my personal collection. A Pigeon and a Boy is one of my favorite books, and so is The Lost.




Dave, this comment seems to appear in multiple threads. It really belongs only in one thread, which is provided for authors to announce there own books. Thanks for respecting the group's policies/practices.
http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...

You piqued my curiosity, so I looked it up. I'm not sure I'd be able to read it. Sort of makes me think of how I've never actually read MEIN KAMPF. http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10...





Erika wrote: "I was excited to find out that Ann Kirschner has a biography of Josephine Marcus Earp, Lady at the O.K. Corral: The True Story of Josephine Marcus Earp, coming in March, and even more excited to re..."

Elyse wrote: "I just joined this group this morning---(On my way to the JCC for a fitness class) ---
but I'm looking at looks people have read in here:
"To the End of the Land" by David Grossman was 'amazing'! ..."

I finished reading In Case We're Separated, by Alice Mattison and also recently finished The Provider, by Evelyn Marshall.

What did you think of "In Case We're Separated," Lorri?

The familial relationships over decades were detailed. The sestina pattern of the stories was unique.

Lorri wrote: "I thought that most of the stories were well written, and I liked the fact that they were connected, as opposed to individual stories without a relationship to each other. That is one of the thing..."


Same thing for me. :)




Meantime, I'm wondering if anyone else is familiar with Gerber's work. She's a past Ribalow prize winner and her publisher has also made her earlier titles available in digital versions (see http://www.dzancbooks.org/merrill-joa.... If you've read those earlier books, which do you recommend in particular?


Claude J. wrote: "I am actually reading in the original French version the autobiography "Le lièvre de Patagonie" by Claude Lanzmann who did the incredible documentary "Shoah" a few years ago. His book is very inter..."



Helen wrote: "I'm going through a Philip K. Dick phase. Last week, I read The Man in the High Castle, which is alternative-history science fiction. In it, Germany and Japan won World War II and divided America u..."


Helen wrote: "I'm going through a Philip K. Dick phase. Last week, I read The Man in the High Castle, which is..."
Oh, good, I hope you like it. I've liked movies based on his books; "Blade Runner" and "Minority Report" are the best of them--so I tried his short stories and was hooked.

Just liked it on Facebook. Interesting story!

Fascinating story, Erika.


Thank you again, David!

I have a knack for picking out books that end up having at the very least a Jewish character or subplot and of course I flock to pretty much anything that has a clearly Jewish or Israeli theme or title. Had a Lubavitcher rabbi in my home once who looked over my bookshelves and was impressed. Haha.
Anyway, I'm currently reading The Frozen Rabbi by Steve Stern. I know there's a lot of two or three star reviews but I'm loving it! Love the humor and satire and pseudo-historical Jewish story. I'm fond of Jewish mysticism and Jewish folklore (and half this book, though fiction, reads like traditional Jewish folklore in many ways) and its sense with Yiddish phrases and some wordy interesting English vocabulary choices. Its not often I pull out a dictionary when I read but I'm having fun both looking up Yiddish I don't know and learning a smattering of new English words even. I feel like this book was written for me! It just appeals to me and delights me on many levels. Very enjoyable read to me though it doesn't seem to be for everyone. Its kind of two stories in one- the tale of a tzaddik who became frozen in ice and several generations from Lodz to New York to Memphis who took care of the frozen rabbi and also half coming of age story of a very assimilated teenage boy who discovers Judaism and Jewish mysticism after the rabbi "unfreezes". I can kind of relate to the teenage boy in a lot of ways because it was my own teens that I became deeply involved and interested in Judaism beyond the once a year Yom Kippur shul going or being the kid who didn't celebrate Christmas. So it works for me. And its just plain a fun read.


I have a knack for picking out books that end up having a..."
Welcome, Tzipora.

Sounds like an interesting read. I was just at a class recently where the rabbi was talking a lot about Golems. And thanks to both you and Erika for the welcome! :)
The Frozen Rabbi disappointed me so, so much in the ending. Beyond disappointment, really. Ruined a good book. It was that bad. Otherwise it was a good read. I've just never had a good book end so terribly!
I'm starting in on Giving Up America by Pearl Abraham right now. I'm really wanting to get my hands on The Romance Reader but I found this book at a book sale this past weekend. Don't even know much about it and haven't started it yet.
I also just read (reread, I think. Pretty sure I read it in my childhood at some point) Judy Blume's Starring Sally J. Freedman As Herself. It was again a find at this book sale (sponsored by the local Jewish community so I scored tons of Judaica, both fiction and non) Interesting book. Takes place in 1947, so after the end of WWII. Sally is 10 and has a very active imagination. And pretty much everyone in her world is apparently Jewish. Because of her older's brother health issues, the family moves down to Florida so it's a new school and new friends. Sally's aunt and beautiful cousin who she aspires to be like were killed at Dachau and she copes with this in her own 10 year old sort of way and also becomes convinced Hitler is secretly hiding out in her town. It's kind of a slice of life novel, so the plot is kind of muddled and perhaps not even there. Not a bad read though, and an interesting perspective, especially for a children's book since there are scores of Holocaust themed children's books but this one isn't really, and is probably more relatable since it takes place in the US. While I'm almost positive I did read it probably in elementary school at some point, it's not a book that really stuck with me but worth picking up and a quick read.

Tzipora wrote: "Angela wrote: "Hi Tzipora I just finished "The Golem and the Jinni" you might like this one. It was a sweet and somewhat informative read, what would one put it under historical/mystical/fiction, I..."

The book I had mentioned previously "The Keeper of Secrets" by Julie Thomas is about a violin that was torn from the hands of its owner in Berlin during the rise of Hitler. The story follows the violin and all that have had it in its possession. If you recall a movie "The Red Violin" a bit like that. Dachau is part of the story. My Father and I went to Dachau back in 99, they make it out to be a "good" camp, compared to what, the "bad" camps.
Erika the "Golem and the Jinni" is also written up at "Tablet."

Angela wrote: "Your welcome Tzipora.
The book I had mentioned previously "The Keeper of Secrets" by Julie Thomas is about a violin that was torn from the hands of its owner in Berlin during the rise of Hitler. T..."

There is a beautiful indigo blue surrounding the edge of the pages of this book, a nice touch.
Books mentioned in this topic
Apeirogon (other topics)Call It Sleep (other topics)
In the Land of Armadillos: Stories (other topics)
In the Land of Armadillos: Stories (other topics)
In the Land of Armadillos: Stories (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Roy Isacowitz (other topics)Henry Roth (other topics)
Tara Lynn Masih (other topics)
Daniel Gordis (other topics)
Lawrence Bush (other topics)
More...