Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion
Twilight vs Harry Potter
>
Severus Snape vs Carlisle Cullen
I'm pretty sure that Snape would win. Do I have any logical argument for this? Not really. Snape is just dominant, in my humble opinion (DEFINITELY my favourite character in both series' combined ;-)
Andy wrote: "Kimathy, the stories were only boring if you made them boring, you have to use your imagination.Adam, and Jesah, it would be interesting to watch because of the awesomeness of both characters."
the stories were boring because nothing really happened it was really slow.
You mean the back stories? Jasper, Rosalie, Emmett, Alice, Edward, Esme, and Carlisle all had awesome backstories that explained their thoughts and personalities, and what happened. It was amazing.
Yes it was. Way more interesting than Harry's. I mean, oh he's an orphan! So interesting...not. The vamps can't remember their human life. It makes for a more interesting story, and a more difficult.
Andy wrote: "You mean the back stories? Jasper, Rosalie, Emmett, Alice, Edward, Esme, and Carlisle all had awesome backstories that explained their thoughts and personalities, and what happened. It was amazing."no, i mean the books.
ok the books themselves are pretty boring at parts...
Andy wrote: "AMEN!"your the one everyone is agreeing with and then you agree with someone on the opposite side?...strange.
Yes, he's definately strange. I don't find Twilight that boring at all. I don't like the books as much as I do HP, but I still really like the series and most of the characters.I LOVE Carlise. He's amazing. Snape is too. I don't really know who would win this fight.
well, the Twilight books dont get decent until about page 200, and for New Moon its about 300
that again is a matter of opinion. I didn't like Twilight straight through. but new moon and the others were good from the beffinning.
I thought it was the best. I dislike Edward.
yeah she whined a TON and I agree Jesah, cyberfive
i dont remember what happened in the books uz i read them a while ago. but i think snape is better
well thats just my opinion. you dont have to agree with me
yup. so who do YOU think is better? i didnt feel like reading the comments from before so idk
Yes, I personally think that Eclipse is the best. It's my fav of the four too.
Thats kewl Becca, have you read the short second life of Bree Tanner?
I have! It is so good!!!! I never thought I'd feel sorry for a blood thirsty new born that feeds in seattle and was trying to kill Jasper, but I did.
The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner is sooooo much better than Twilight!
Laurena wrote: "I have! It is so good!!!! I never thought I'd feel sorry for a blood thirsty new born that feeds in seattle and was trying to kill Jasper, but I did."I know I loved it too!! I couldn't believe Diego was gone... :( They were cute ! holdin hands while huntin and stuff :)
the one that lives in that house and goes to that place?
Carlisle was played by actor..Peter Facinelli
I haven't read it yeat Laurena. But I'm going to soon.
i tried reading it, i got to page 18 and i think I'm going to give up, i can't get through it.
It is so good. And it invites you in. The first chapter of HP didn't do that. So I have to pick the other one...Bree Tanner over HP!
the first chaper of HP invited me in, but i guess only it did for me, i thought it was a genius way to start it. however the rambling of a teenage vampire didn't draw me in at all.
the first harry potter book was good, until i read the rest, now its not really that good
Adam, and Jesah, it would be interesting to watch because of the awesomeness of both characters.