Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

31 views
Twilight vs Harry Potter > Severus Snape vs Carlisle Cullen

Comments Showing 1-50 of 146 (146 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Andy (new)

Andy [image error]





message 2: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments I don't know what to say to this one...
I'd like to say Carlisle, but he's like a passifist or something, so Snape would be the only one fighting...


message 3: by Andy (new)

Andy But if Carlisle was in trouble he'd fight, and win.


message 4: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments CARLISLE


message 5: by Andy (new)

Andy *** SPOILER FROM DEATHLY HALLOWS ***

Ya, if a snake bite can kill snape, imagine what a vampire bite can do!


message 6: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments KILL youuuu and anyone else that sucks :P


message 7: by Andy (new)

Andy Or nothing seeing as its impossible


message 8: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments ya if they suck all your blood your effed


message 9: by Andy (new)

Andy no but vampires dont exist


message 10: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Yes they do Im a vampire...in my dreams


message 11: by Andy (new)

Andy oh ya?


message 12: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments ya im emmetts


message 13: by Andy (new)

Andy oh.... kay?


message 14: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments yup and you can e with...............Leah


message 15: by Andy (new)

Andy e?


message 16: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments **be


message 17: by Andy (new)

Andy no thanks


message 18: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments why not


message 19: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Andy wrote: "no but vampires dont exist"

Neither to witches or wizards andy.


message 20: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments very true :)


message 21: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Again it would be a very cool fight to watch, but Carlise wouldn't fight unless he really needed to.


message 22: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments ya he sooo could win if he had to


message 23: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments (that was weird the internet was messed up, was it for you too Becca? or Andy if your on here?)


message 24: by Andy (new)

Andy BECCA! STOP SAYING THAT! THE POINT OF THE DISCUSSION IS THE FACT THAT THEY DOOOOO FIGHT!


message 25: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Haha CARLISLE!! (did your internet mess up Andy?)


message 26: by Andy (new)

Andy no...


message 27: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments (well everyone in my classes did for like 5 minutes)


message 28: by Andy (new)

Andy mine didn't.


message 29: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments well mine did!! CARLISLE kicks butt!


message 30: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Mine didn't either. Sorry Andy. I'm just thinking of what the characters would actually do!!


message 31: by Andy (new)

Andy i know


message 32: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Yes, you do!!


message 33: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Snape. there is no question, he is the inventor of several spells and potions that could kill Carlisle.


message 34: by Andy (new)

Andy i think Snape would have a huge advantage, yes.


message 35: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Yeah. His main advantage being that he is willing to fight.


message 36: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Carlisle is a prat.


message 37: by Andy (new)

Andy why is everyone from twilight a prat to you?


message 38: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Yeah! Carlisle isn't a prat either. He is amazing, and I totally share his point of view.


message 39: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Because they are. Twilight it's self is just a big prat. and i mean that in the nicest way possible.


message 40: by Andy (new)

Andy Define prat


message 41: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy i don't really have a definition for it, i just use it to describe people who annoy me greatly.


message 42: by Andy (new)

Andy why do they annoy you? because they aren't in harry potter? If alice was in harry potter you would say "She's so deep, i love her background, and the fact that she doesn't know it, and i love her appearance and her power, and her personality, and her awesomeness, and she's nothing like someone from twilight, the prats." so just seriously...


message 43: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy ummm, no i don't like Alice because she is much to bubbly and her character was never greatly explored. I have reasons for not liking characters, not just because they are not in Harry Potter.


message 44: by Andy (new)

Andy Her character was greatly explored througout the storym and even better, it wasn't just thrown in using the smart character, Meyer found a way to put it in without using Hermione, so.... ya.


message 45: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy *story

...what? that part about smart characters and Hermione made no sense...


message 46: by Andy (new)

Andy yes it did, everytime Rowling needed to put something in she just used Hermione. When Meyer had creative ways to do it.


message 47: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Yeah. Alice is so deep and amazing and has a totally cool back story. Actually all of them have pretty cool backstories. I love that about Twilight.


message 48: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy i didn't get anything get any of that. sadly, Hermione is not just the informational one and i thought the stories were a bit boring.


message 49: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments eep... this ones a tie for me


message 50: by Jesah (new)

Jesah Me too.


« previous 1 3
back to top