The Rory Gilmore Book Club discussion
Rory Book Discussions
>
Me Talk Pretty One Day - Deux
date
newest »

message 1:
by
whichwaydidshego, the sage of sass
(new)
May 31, 2008 10:44PM

reply
|
flag

I'm halfway through part two and expect to finish this today. I agree with Emily, the language part is funny. I took a French class in high school so I understand his frustration. Why in the world would anyone want to assign genders to inanimate objects anyway? LOL.
SPOILERS (just in case)
I enjoyed the chapters about language: "See You Again Yesterday", "Me Talk Pretty One Day", "Make That a Double". It's absurdly funny to me how he chose to memorize nouns that have nothing to do with daily conversation (exorcism, facial swelling, sea monster). But the funniest chapter for me (not just in the second part, but in the whole book) is "Jesus Shaves". I'm not Christian, but I do know a few things about Easter, and the way they tried to describe it is just hilarious. I also like how Sedaris equates religious faith with the faith of the students that someday they'll master the French language.
"21 Down" has a special meaning for me cause it reminds me of my mom, who's a crossword puzzle enthusiast. Like Sedaris, she keeps an atlas and reference books that are usually read by junior high school children. Every time she stumbles upon a question, she asks me to find the answer on the library or the internet. Thanks to Google, I was able to give my mom lists of the entire Latin alphabet and chemical symbols.
I enjoyed the chapters about language: "See You Again Yesterday", "Me Talk Pretty One Day", "Make That a Double". It's absurdly funny to me how he chose to memorize nouns that have nothing to do with daily conversation (exorcism, facial swelling, sea monster). But the funniest chapter for me (not just in the second part, but in the whole book) is "Jesus Shaves". I'm not Christian, but I do know a few things about Easter, and the way they tried to describe it is just hilarious. I also like how Sedaris equates religious faith with the faith of the students that someday they'll master the French language.
"21 Down" has a special meaning for me cause it reminds me of my mom, who's a crossword puzzle enthusiast. Like Sedaris, she keeps an atlas and reference books that are usually read by junior high school children. Every time she stumbles upon a question, she asks me to find the answer on the library or the internet. Thanks to Google, I was able to give my mom lists of the entire Latin alphabet and chemical symbols.

I majored in Spanish in college and in one class my freshman year my teacher was having us talk about something we hoped would happen. I wanted to say I hoped I got a package in the mail but I didn't know the word so I was trying to say that I hoped I got a gift "regalo" in the mail but I wound up saying "reloj" which is clock. My teacher looked at me and trying to catch me in my mistake said you hope you get a clock? Realizing my mistake I said "yes, mine is broken, I need a new one." Spanish also has masculine and feminine nouns but the plurals are also masculine or feminine so David's trick wouldn't have worked unless you always just said you wanted two of whatever-still it was amusing to read about his struggles.
The part about his father eating part of his hat and leaving food to rot all around the house was hysterical. The friend's response was priceless.
All in all I really liked this one, glad we read it.



The French class was awesome, ordering plural everything totally captured my imagination, especially when combined with his first story about another effort to avoid what's difficult in speaking -- using words with no "s"s to avoid working on his lisp.
I am a little bit in love with Hugh, myself. I found myself wondering for much of the book, how did David hook this guy and what is keeping him around?
Jesus Shaves was just made of AWESOME. :)

Hahahaha! Deb, that's hilarious!!
I've just realized I haven't added my comments here! Gah! What was I thinking?? I totally have things to say! Okay I will, but not tonight as it's nearly two and I had been planning on getting to bed early! (Okay, I admit... this IS early for me, but I meant something-akin-to-normal-sort-of-early.)
I've just realized I haven't added my comments here! Gah! What was I thinking?? I totally have things to say! Okay I will, but not tonight as it's nearly two and I had been planning on getting to bed early! (Okay, I admit... this IS early for me, but I meant something-akin-to-normal-sort-of-early.)


I would not read another one of his books though. Not really my style. I am guessing all his books are like this. I guess maybe I wasn't in the mood for this book either. It just was about a lot of depressing stuff and maybe I just needed something lighter?
We read his Holidays on Ice last December as a group. For me that book was worth it for the first story alone. I nearly peed my pants... in the middle seat on an airplane... I was laughing so hard.