YA and Beyond discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
BOOKS TO DISCUSS
>
What are you currently reading?


Also finished my audio of

Finished my reread of

Finished

Started a reread of


I think so, yes. The plots themselves are geared for younger readers, but the humor is just solid. Plus, a lot of the stuff he talks about is pretty univeral, like, we all can probably relate enough to get a chuckle haha. Without spoiling anything, in one book he talks about liking Shel Silverstein but being frightened of his author picture on the backs of his books haha.
Tommy wrote: "Heidi (Yup. Still here.) wrote: "I have never read any of the Diary books Tommy. is the series good for all ages?"
I think so, yes. The plots themselves are geared for younger readers, but the hum..."
Ok thanks Tommy. I wonder if they are good on audio.
Good to know Jenny! I have that on hold at the library.
I think so, yes. The plots themselves are geared for younger readers, but the hum..."
Ok thanks Tommy. I wonder if they are good on audio.
Good to know Jenny! I have that on hold at the library.
Just a reminder that this months hidden gem group read was picked by our Moderator Bluemoon and it is 172 Hours on the Moon
. I am looking for it at my library :)

Tommy wrote: "Without spoiling anything, in one book he talks about liking Shel Silverstein but being frightened of his author picture on the backs of his books haha."
omg I saw a picture of that part on Tumblr and it made me laugh so hard. :D I need to get around to reading those; I've only read bits of them but they are very funny from what I've read. I also met Jeff Kinney at BookExpo a couple years ago, and he was really nice!
omg I saw a picture of that part on Tumblr and it made me laugh so hard. :D I need to get around to reading those; I've only read bits of them but they are very funny from what I've read. I also met Jeff Kinney at BookExpo a couple years ago, and he was really nice!


Thanks for the reminder! I've fallen behind on the group reads, but I do want to read this one!

omg I saw a picture of that ..."
My boys LOVED those books!

Good to know Jenny! I have that on hold at the library."
I don't know if they'd be good on audio just because the story is pretty reliant on pictures. It's a semi-graphic novel(or more accurately, it's like 10 of them haha).


I also started a biography

Yeahhh I heard Life and Death was literally just the exact same text as Twilight but just switching out the names/pronouns, lol. :D
Tommy wrote: "I heard that Beau(haha) described one of the girls as "so hot The Rock wouldn't smile at her" haha."
I threw up a little in my mouth just reading that line. *sigh* I am glad you got it from the library Jenny because the fact that people spent money on that book makes me sad/angry. I know. I know. I should focus on the fact that people are reading in the first place!
I threw up a little in my mouth just reading that line. *sigh* I am glad you got it from the library Jenny because the fact that people spent money on that book makes me sad/angry. I know. I know. I should focus on the fact that people are reading in the first place!

Thank you, Heidi! I loved the one Louise Penny book I read and think I would love all the Three Pines books! Don't know how many I'll get to read, because of time. We are on the next-to-the-last episode of season 4 of Longmire on Netflix. . . Kind of hate to watch the last one and then have to wait. It is our favorite show!


That is good to know; I wasn't sure I wanted to read it, because I didn't love those part of the book, but I love her writing so much, I should probably trust that it's gonna be great. Okay, so now I know I'm gonna read it? ;)

I'm reading a W..."
I saw Howl's Moving Castle, the movie, and loved it, even though I didn't understand it either! ;) I think I just remember being so entranced with the visuals.

Plus I think this banner looks better with the name"
It looks great, Bluemoon! Thank you!

I think so, yes. The plots themselves are geared for younger readers, but the hum..."
I am a retired teacher, and I remember how much my students LOVED those books! I love it when that happens! It was like that with HP; kids who hadn't loved to read suddenly did! :)


Dixie wrote: "Heidi (Yup. Still here.) wrote: "Dixie I love the Three Pines series! it is especially wonderful on audio book. I also like Longmire the TV show :)"
Thank you, Heidi! I loved the one Louise Penny ..."
Good to know Longmire is still good in season 4 - I am on season 3 :)
Just finishing Carry On today (I have less than 15 minutes of the audiobook left) and have loved nearly every minute of it. I am not 100% into this ending so far but Rainbow has a history with me of not nailing her endings and I forgive her each time. Maybe the last few minutes will be the game changer. Either way, I did not love those parts of Fangirl either and would not have gotten the book if my library had not had it but I am glad I did :) p.s. I highly recommend it on audio - I can't remember if you listen to audiobooks Dixie?
Thank you, Heidi! I loved the one Louise Penny ..."
Good to know Longmire is still good in season 4 - I am on season 3 :)
Just finishing Carry On today (I have less than 15 minutes of the audiobook left) and have loved nearly every minute of it. I am not 100% into this ending so far but Rainbow has a history with me of not nailing her endings and I forgive her each time. Maybe the last few minutes will be the game changer. Either way, I did not love those parts of Fangirl either and would not have gotten the book if my library had not had it but I am glad I did :) p.s. I highly recommend it on audio - I can't remember if you listen to audiobooks Dixie?




I don't know, I couldn't imagine changing something in a character without thinking "how would this change the story?". Keep the personality the same, but make Harry a girl, and try to imagine the desire to live up to his father, the way he interacted with Ron(or Ronda? haha), etc. etc. etc. One characteristic change should honestly change a lot, even if the plot takes you to the same place.

I think she should have just changed Bella and Edward, and left everyone else pretty much the same (this was only the first book, so Jacob could have still been a boy) but have some kind of fun plot twist. To do a really good retelling, there has to be a bit of a "twist" to make it work.
I honestly did like Edythe better than Edward. I think the girl vampire thing actually worked. I had trouble swallowing Beau as Bella, though. So it just all fell apart.
Bella was a Mary Sue character for me (especially in Twilight) so I don't know how that could translated into a male character successfully.

(view spoiler)

Thank you, Heidi! I loved the one..."
Heidi, I don't listen to audio books so far although I know I would enjoy them. :) I am glad to hear the recommendation of Carry On; I will have to read it; I'm such a fan. Hope you continue to enjoy Longmire! :)
Tommy wrote: "You'd think even just changing the genders, even while keeping the plot identical, would have changed things in a fairly significant way. Maybe woman-Carlisle had some struggles on her way to being..."
Yes, this! I feel like I would've been slightly more interested if she'd actually made some kind of effort in thinking about how the gender of the characters affects the story. Apparently she's claimed it's some kind of "statement" about sexism––and like, I kind of get that ... I get that people tend to be more quick to judge female characters (although in Bella's case, I think people's views of her are pretty justified, haha). But just swapping the names/pronouns and nothing else just seems like a lazy gimmick. And we all know she just did it to make some extra money. XD
Yes, this! I feel like I would've been slightly more interested if she'd actually made some kind of effort in thinking about how the gender of the characters affects the story. Apparently she's claimed it's some kind of "statement" about sexism––and like, I kind of get that ... I get that people tend to be more quick to judge female characters (although in Bella's case, I think people's views of her are pretty justified, haha). But just swapping the names/pronouns and nothing else just seems like a lazy gimmick. And we all know she just did it to make some extra money. XD
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Their Fractured Light (other topics)The Raven Boys (other topics)
A Darker Shade of Magic (other topics)
The Raven Boys (other topics)
Owl and the City of Angels (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Sarah Addison Allen (other topics)Sarah Addison Allen (other topics)
Markus Zusak (other topics)
Melina Marchetta (other topics)
Sawyer Bennett (other topics)
More...
I've been kinda reading