The History Book Club discussion
ARCHIVE
>
ERICK'S 50 BOOKS READ IN 2010
date
newest »

message 51:
by
Bentley, Group Founder, Leader, Chief
(new)
Jul 20, 2010 08:54AM

reply
|
flag



Finish date: July 2010 "A" The end of the series is everything I could have hoped for. It is certainly with mixed feelings that I set this story aside.



Finish Date: August 2010 "A" A more amazing story than I expected and I can't think of anyone better to tell it than Ambrose.



Finish Date: August 2010 "A" A more amazing story than I expected and I can't think of..."
Great book!


Finish Date: August 2010 "B-" Not a very well written historical novel of Venice in the 14th century. Does provide some insight into Venetian history and politics.


Finish Date: August 2010 "B" A book about a personal struggle with PTSD. Would probably not be of much interest to someone who hasn't had their lives impacted by that situation.



Finish Date:August 2010 "A-" A well written book with a somewhat unique storyline. Predicable but still well done.
36.

Finish Date: August 2010 "A" It's Cornelius Ryan - is there anything that needs to be added?



Finish Date: September 2010 "A" A well written account of the invasion of North Africa by the Allies in WWII. Mr. Atkinson has a way of communicating the overall situation, the thoughts of the leaders and the experience of the individual soldiers that reminds me a lot of Cornelius Ryan


Finish Date: October 2010 "B-" I believe the book took on too much in trying to describe about seventy years of British history in about 200 pages. Also, there was too much discussion of interrelationships and lineage that is always confusing. The book is perhaps a good lead-in to a more in depth study of the period.
Erick, a good honest assessment of the work. Sometimes I think he was trying to just do too much.
Robin Neillands
Robin Neillands



Finish Date: October 2010 "B" Mysteries generally aren't my thing but I thought this one was well done.


Finish Date:October 2010 "A-" A well researched and written account. His style reminds me of Cornelius Ryanto a certain extent. How Cornelius Ryan mixes stories from the common soldier with stories about the leaders to make a much more interesting story. I am definitely going to be looking for more books by this author.

The author recently published a book on other assault landings in the Pacific during WW2 titled; "Storm Landings: Epic Amphibious Battles in the Central Pacific" which may well be worth while following up.



The author recently published a book on other assault landings in the Pacific d..."
Added!



Finish Date: October 2010 "B" The writing was well done but the book didn't have a compelling plot. I did learn some things about Alexander but the book didn't meet the expectations set by






Finish Date: June 2010 "A" I could not put this book down; baby not fed,dog not walked. It was a well ..."
It had the same effect on me! (read it quite a while ago - not this year).

I will say that




Finish Date: October 2010 "B" Very detailed account of the invasion of Sicily by the Allies in WWII. The only detraction was the "arm chair generaling" by the author.

I think it is going to be tight to hit the 50 books. I am reading


and it is going really slow for some reason. I am not going to rush through or pick smaller books to make the 50 but I will have to see how it works out.
Well I know I won't hit it this year; probably because I take care of this site too; but I plan to do better next year. And I like the idea of being able to go back and see what I read and how I felt about the books. You are in striking distance though.

That would be great Erick...I could use all the help I can get. :-)
And you are welcome. The assisting mods do a great job.
Thank you Michael.
And you are welcome. The assisting mods do a great job.
Thank you Michael.



Finish Date: March 2010 "C" Spent far too much time discussing Catherine's many lovers with only a passing mention of he..."
oh That's a shame it's not more detailed. There's an excellent chapter on her in




Finish Date: December 2010 "B+" Covered a very interesting topic that I knew nothing about. The book was pretty technical which made it a little hard to get through. Mr. Horne obviously has great depth of knowledge; I will certainly be reading more of his books.



Finish Date: December 2010 "B" Not one of his best but these are perfect books for me to listen to in the car.


Finish Date: December 2010 "B-" Lacked some of the "thrill" in thriller but didn't commit any egregious acts.



Finish Date: December 2010 "A" Perhaps even better than the first book


He is really a master at telling the story at all levels, strategic, tactical and personal. I am really looking forward to the third book in the series.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Day of Battle: The War in Sicily and Italy, 1943-1944 (other topics)An Army at Dawn: The War in North Africa, 1942-1943 (other topics)
Pandora's Legion (other topics)
Jingo (other topics)
A Savage War of Peace: Algeria, 1954-1962 (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Rick Atkinson (other topics)Harold Coyle (other topics)
Terry Pratchett (other topics)
Alistair Horne (other topics)
Henri Troyat (other topics)
More...