Hunger Games Trilogy discussion
The Hunger Games Books
>
Twilight Saga or Hunger Games Trilogy?
How?... Twilight can not compete with Hunger Games way to different from eachother. Especially since Hunger Games has real romance when it's focused more on action while Twilight isn't even romantic. Seriously how is parental love considered romantic?
The Hunger Games... duh.
Evelyn wrote: "I haven't read Twilight yet but can someone explain to me why it has hype! I sort of have some background knowledge but stereotypical ones. I wanna know why people(girls) are crazy about it! I stil..."it has hype with 11 year old girls. It really is not good at all. No plot, just about a girl who can't live without her sparkly vampire (yes... a vampire that SPARKLES in the sunlight) boyfriend.
I read the Twilight series for my wife and while I have to admit they were well written and actually held my interest, there is no comparison. Hunger Games was an action packed emotional nuclear bomb that I haven't seen equaled in a long time.
The Hunger Games and Twilight are 2 very different book series. One focuses on Vampires and Werewolf's while the other on a game where killing is done to survive. I for one prefer The Hunger Games for both better movie and book series. Twilight isn't that bad though ;)
The love triangle isn't the same as Twilight's.Bella was always gonna end up with Edward, but Katniss was completely confused. She wouldn't accept her feelings for Peeta because Gale was always there. And she didn't want to hurt anyone.
twilight? r u kidding? definitely hunger games!!! i think the characters in HG were easier to relate to. in twilight, everything and everyone was to fake. Also, practically every page in twilight was like this: Bella: sigh. Bella: I love you. Edward: I love you too. Bella: sigh. But you could see that Katniss had a real crisis and she had to make a lot of choices that can influence everyone
Hunger Games FOR SURE!! I HATE Twilight :/
April*procrastinator and proud* wrote: "Evelyn wrote: "I haven't read Twilight yet but can someone explain to me why it has hype! I sort of have some background knowledge but stereotypical ones. I wanna know why people(girls) are crazy a..." Hmm...thanks. That is what I thought but I didn't want to make assumptions.
i love the hunger games but i really don't think you can compare them to twilight. they were both different yet the same romance triangle. katniss,gale, and peeta and bella,jacob, and edward. all guys are suffering and both katniss and bella can't choose. but with the hunger games there is the whole futeristic thing and it's a little more complicated in a good way.twilight has the whole vampires chasing bella thing they play with. my personal prefference is hunger games though.
Nina wrote: "i love the hunger games but i really don't think you can compare them to twilight. they were both different yet the same romance triangle. katniss,gale, and peeta and bella,jacob, and edward. all g..."I totally agree
The Hunger Games...although Twilight might get a chance if someone else played Edward in the movie.
Definately The Hunger Games! Twilight was an empty romance that had no depth behind it what so ever. On the other hand, The Hunger Games had so much depth behind it regarding government, materialism, individuality and so much more. Collins uses 'romance' in this trilogy to portray how we all throw on our different masks depending on what crowd we are with. Katniss throws on a show for survival. Without that lie, that though it eventually turned into somethimg, Katniss would have never made it.
Yousra wrote: "Definately The Hunger Games! Twilight was an empty romance that had no depth behind it what so ever. On the other hand, The Hunger Games had so much depth behind it regarding government, materialis..."Amen
I liked twilight but the hunger games by a landslide. There was way more action and better romance.
I tried giving Twilight another chance over spring break.
I opened the first book randomly, read ONE SENTENCE, and immediately closed it.
Hunger Games all the way.
I opened the first book randomly, read ONE SENTENCE, and immediately closed it.
Hunger Games all the way.
I have read the entire series of the Hunger games and found it thrilling, but for Twilight, I tried to read the first book and was unsuccessful- I was bored before I was half way through the first chapter. The Hunger Games is better than Twilight, hands down. I hope to write a book that's nearly as great as the Hunger Games one day... but I bet I won't be able to write something as amazing as the Hunger Games.
I haven't read Twilight, but I can't imagine that it would be better than Hunger Games :)
Honestly the books are too different to compare, there both amazing in their own ways. :)
Hunger Games is a trillion times better than Twilight... sorry Robert step aside, You're in my view of Josh
hehehehehehehe!!! x3
hehehehehehehe!!! x3
i think the the hunger games because the book got action,love,and epic on it
Did anyone else hear Robert Paterson might be cast for Finnick . Pls tell me its not true v.v
Karla wrote: "Did anyone else hear Robert Paterson might be cast for Finnick . Pls tell me its not true v.v"WAIT WHAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? ROBERT PATTERSON WILL NOT BE FINNICK!!!!!!!!!!!!11 HE IS AS UGLY AS A ZOMBIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
♫ נєηη - ѕσυℓ σƒ ѕσυη∂ ♫ wrote: "Ooh.Search "Edward Cullen" on Unencyclopedia.
It's hilarious."
omg that was great!!! XD who ever made that was a genius.
Hey you guys, I'm having a hunger games role play for the 100 annual hunger games! Get ready for the quarter quell!! (The capitol and District 13 are in it also!)http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/9...
definetely the hungergames. no question.
Is it really neccessary to ask this question? The Hunger Games, without a doubt.
The Hunger Games. Period. Okay, so not period. I really hate it when people "accuse," per say, Collins of bringing back Twilight. Now, I know there are love triangles in both books. But really? Twilight is a book about a teenage girl moving to a rainy town and falls in love with a sparkly vampire. Then, she meets a were-wolf. This is practically the main plotline. The Hunger Games is about a televised fight-to-the-death, in which another teenage girl participates. Her hunting partner fell in love with her, and, in what was originally supposed to get sponsers, her District partner in the Games falls in love with her, too. But that's not even close to the main plot. So, I choose The Hunger Games.
Sorry if this is just really late, and if my explaination was confusing :P
Well....difficult question but both! Yes, the answer is both. They are two totally different books and I don't think that we could compare them. I love them both for different reasons!! :)
Mieley wrote: "Haha is this a joke? definitely the Hunger Games."word.
Hunger Games of course.
Easily Hunger Games! Although I would much rather be a Twilight vampire than anyone/thing in the Hunger Games.
Well Hunger Games all the way, Twilight, well no, never Read them, they were okay, but i wouldn't recommend anyone to read them, but thats just me. i loved the Hunger Games, I couldn't put the books down.
uhhhhh hunger games their is no need for a poll for this lol
THE HUNGER GAMES!!! Because there is a concept full of suffering and so deep it makes you think in another way, actually I like twilight but comparing it to THG, it's a confused girl can't choose between a vampire and a werewolf, to a girl led a revolution and lost a lot so again the hunger games is way better :)
I did read both, Hunger Games and Twilight and I think there is no way to compare both, the stories are completely different, I dont know why people keep comparing this books.Anyway I liked The Hunger Games best, but not comparing the stories, just what I enjoied the most.
:)
Hunger Games Trilogy
Books mentioned in this topic
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (other topics)A Mango-Shaped Space (other topics)
The Lightning Thief (other topics)
And Then There Were None (other topics)
-gasp- someone actually like -gasps again- TWILIGHT??!!
man that series is awful
its horrible
and stupid
and ugh
twilight disgusts me-_-