Hunger Games Trilogy discussion
The Hunger Games Books
>
Twilight Saga or Hunger Games Trilogy?
message 551:
by
Megan
(new)
Nov 16, 2011 07:57PM
i think the twilight movies are way to over dramatic
reply
|
flag
The books are just melodramatic in themselves...
OMG MY BOYFRIEND LEFT SO I MUST BECOME SUICIDAL!
Really?
Really?
Megan wrote: "lol i no right.... its like ummm.... did i really pay to see this?"You went and saw it?!
I like Twilight, but I have to admit that the Hunger Games is a so, so, so much better book. I love the action, the romance, the agony, the incredible story line....
I have a friend that would kill you for those first three words. She just read over my shoulder.
Just saying...watch out.
Just saying...watch out.
Riah wrote: "Megan wrote: "lol i no right.... its like ummm.... did i really pay to see this?"You went and saw it?!"
lol no i was talking about twilight :)
How could ANYONE hate THG! That's like impossible. But THG totally wins..On all levels..In Twilight, Jacob and Edward FIGHT over Bella..But why? I think it's a bit immature, if you ask me.
Lea (Peeta's #1 Fangirl!) wrote: "How could ANYONE hate THG! That's like impossible. But THG totally wins..On all levels..In Twilight, Jacob and Edward FIGHT over Bella..But why? I think it's a bit immature, if you ask me."when did edward and jacob fight?
In the movies, I believe. Didn't they? If not physical, then by words or motions...Its been a while since I read them.
oh, I'm not sure about the movies...but in the books they never really fought, it was actually quite similar to how gale and peeta felt about each other, except jacob and edward did eventually sorta like each other. in fact, remember the whispered conversation gale and peeta had about katniss while they thought she was sleeping? eclipse had almost that exact same scene...
Kirby wrote: "oh, I'm not sure about the movies...but in the books they never really fought, it was actually quite similar to how gale and peeta felt about each other, except jacob and edward did eventually sort..."I think Peeta and Gale coulda been friends if Gale would have stuck around.
Riah wrote: "Kirby wrote: "oh, I'm not sure about the movies...but in the books they never really fought, it was actually quite similar to how gale and peeta felt about each other, except jacob and edward did e..."yeah, they probably could have...
I wish he would have stayed around. Then Gale fans wouldn't say Katniss didn't have a choice. She had to pick Peeta. That kinda annoys me for two reasons. #1 She could have just dumped Peeta... #2 Of course she had no choice, she is a character in a book, the author picks. DUH!
the hunger games are so much better. (: twilight was okay but i couldn't put the hunger games down until i finished them. twilight just isn't like that
Grace wrote: "the hunger games are so much better. (: twilight was okay but i couldn't put the hunger games down until i finished them. twilight just isn't like that"SAME here
Riah wrote: "I wish he would have stayed around. Then Gale fans wouldn't say Katniss didn't have a choice. She had to pick Peeta. That kinda annoys me for two reasons. #1 She could have just dumped Peeta... #2 ..."Actually, the character has a mind of their own. S.C. made her chose who she would of. I think J.K.R. mentioned that her characters have a mind of their own.
Lea (Peeta's #1 Fangirl!) wrote: "Riah wrote: "I wish he would have stayed around. Then Gale fans wouldn't say Katniss didn't have a choice. She had to pick Peeta. That kinda annoys me for two reasons. #1 She could have just dumped..."Oh yes. My characters do whatever they please... They boss me around all the time and end up saying and doing things I never wanted/expected them to say and do.
hehe..I've only had failed attempts at writing stories..But that was 3 years ago! I should try again :)
Yeah...stories I wrote three years ago were about cowboys and unicorns. Try again, you'll be better too.
Those are cool! What theories do you have on time travel? Like me, I think that whatever you do to get into the past, you can't change it, but if you travel to the future it will be a future where you vanished in the past...does that make sense?
Oh. I think the exact opposite of that...
Different Opinions..In the "book" I wrote they didn't ACTUALLY travel in time..I think they were going to, but I gave up on the idea
i love the hunger game books more than twilight books but.......... i do like the twilight books and movies!!! GO PEETA!!!!!!!!
I used to like Twilight, but I've realized that there are better books than it. The only reason that I'd go see Breaking Dawn is just to say that I've seen it. I'd pick Hunger Games over Twilight any day.
The Hunger Games..1.it taught me lessons, unlike Twilight
2. had an amazing heroine...(could list more reasons)
Snickerdoodle wrote: "Those are cool! What theories do you have on time travel? Like me, I think that whatever you do to get into the past, you can't change it, but if you travel to the future it will be a future where ..."i think this makes aton of sense!!
Peeta is cute and beautiful..And yes, Katniss did mention him being beautiful and handsome. Never hot.
The Hunger Games all the way, there is more action and less lovey- dovey stuff which is not my type of book at all
Books mentioned in this topic
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (other topics)A Mango-Shaped Space (other topics)
The Lightning Thief (other topics)
And Then There Were None (other topics)







