Doctor Who: The Library of Carsus discussion

18 views

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments I have been embarking in a read through of all the DW novels in order by series. So far I am up to The Roundheads in the PDAs, just finished Kursaal in the EDAs and Winner Takes All in the NSAs. I am also on the virgin ones but have stalled about a quarter of the way through the last Timewyrm book as I have no idea what is happening.


message 2: by Lori S. (new)

Lori S. (fuzzipueo) | 843 comments Mod
Ambitious. Good luck!

RE: Timewyrm is a confusing book.


message 3: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2623 comments Yikes.
That should keep you busy for awhile.

Yeah, Timewyrm gets credit for starting the new adventures series, but it's not a great story.


message 4: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments currently reading Option Lock


message 5: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2623 comments Tim wrote: "currently reading Option Lock"

Think that's one of the ones I'm missing.
Keep wanting to catch up on the 7th and the 8th Doctor books, but both are so daunting.


message 6: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments now finished Option Lock. may read a pda next. the next would be The Face of tge Enemy, a third doctor adventure


message 7: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2623 comments Tim wrote: "now finished Option Lock. may read a pda next. the next would be The Face of tge Enemy, a third doctor adventure"

Like that one alot.
Was hoping it would lead to a UNIT series.


message 8: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments About 40% of the way through The Face of the Enemy. Actually finding it a bit slow.. and no sign of the doctor yet either which isnt helping.


message 9: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Didnt really enjoy The Face of The Enemy. Now starting a NSA next The Deviant Strain


message 10: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2623 comments Tim wrote: "Didnt really enjoy The Face of The Enemy. Now starting a NSA next The Deviant Strain"

Just got the Deviant Strain at a book sale.
Have to let me know if it's worth moving higher up my to be read pile.

The lack of Doctor is what made 'Face of the enemy' appeal to me.
I like seeing stories about what UNIT and companions do to handle things when he's not around.


message 11: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Finished Only Human which was great. Now reading PDA 8 Eye of Heaven.

Current progress NSA read 5
PDA read 7
VNA still on number 4
VMA none yet
EDA read 8


message 12: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Finished Eye of Heaven which i enjoyed. Will probably be a EDA next.


message 13: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Finished Longest Day, which doesnt seem to have the greatest reputation but I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Havent quite decided what i am reading next. But i usually alternate between EDAs and PDAs.


message 14: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Been really enjoying the EDA's recently and am currenly on Dreamstone Moon


message 15: by Tim (new)

Tim (mick745) | 10 comments Doctor Who: Dreamstone Moon by Paul Leonard — 7/10

An imaginative, ambitious and occasionally frustrating journey into the darker side of the universe.

Dreamstone Moon is an Eighth Doctor Adventure that attempts to be considerably more than a straightforward science-fiction adventure. Paul Leonard brings together environmental exploitation, prejudice, alien life, political conflict and questions about the nature of consciousness in a story whose ideas are often more compelling than its execution. The result is an intriguing, if uneven, addition to the Doctor Who novel range.

At the centre of the story is dreamstone, a valuable substance associated with the moon on which much of the action takes place. What initially appears to be a familiar science-fiction scenario involving the extraction of a desirable resource gradually acquires more unsettling implications. The relationship between the mineral and the moon itself raises questions about the distinction between an inert commodity and a living system. What happens when a civilisation exploits something without properly understanding what it is, or what consequences its actions might have?

This is fertile territory for Doctor Who. The series has always been at its best when an apparently straightforward adventure develops into something morally or philosophically complicated. Here, the mining operation becomes a vehicle for exploring humanity's tendency to assume that the universe exists for its benefit. The possibility that the moon is more than simply a convenient source of valuable material challenges the confidence with which its exploiters approach it.

There is an obvious environmental dimension to this, but the novel's concerns extend beyond the familiar message that destroying nature is wrong. Its more interesting implication is that exploitation often begins with a failure of imagination. If we cannot recognise the independent existence and significance of something beyond ourselves, we are unlikely to treat it with appropriate consideration. The problem is not merely greed, but the assumption that whatever can be used must be ours to use.

This connects neatly with the novel's exploration of prejudice against alien life. The setting contains a variety of species, while the attitudes of the human authorities reveal how easily technological sophistication can coexist with moral backwardness. Humanity may have developed the means to travel among the stars, but that does not necessarily mean it has outgrown its provincial assumptions about its own importance.

The parallel between exploiting the moon and mistreating alien beings is particularly effective. In both cases, something outside the dominant group's immediate interests is denied proper consideration. The moon becomes a resource rather than something deserving respect in its own right; aliens risk being treated as inferior beings rather than individuals with their own experiences and interests. The novel's science-fiction setting allows Leonard to explore familiar human failings from an unfamiliar perspective.

Sam Jones provides an important emotional counterpoint to these larger ideas. Separated from the Doctor, she must navigate an unfamiliar and potentially hostile environment without the reassurance of her usual travelling companion. This gives Leonard an opportunity to explore her independence and maturity, as well as the difficulties involved in developing one's own judgement.

Sam's relationship with the Doctor is central to understanding her predicament. He has been a source of guidance and moral direction, but growing up requires more than trying to imitate him. She must learn to make decisions for herself, including decisions that might prove mistaken. There is something poignant about a young person being forced to become independent before she is necessarily ready for it.

However, the prolonged separation of the Doctor and Sam can become frustrating. Their individual experiences do not always combine into a narrative as satisfying as the underlying premise promises. Nevertheless, Sam's struggle gives the novel a personal dimension that prevents its philosophical concerns from becoming entirely abstract.

The Doctor's own difficulties reinforce a familiar Doctor Who theme: intelligence and moral certainty do not automatically confer the power to change the world. He can recognise injustice and understand that something is wrong, but he cannot simply compel everyone around him to behave rationally or compassionately. Institutions have their own priorities, individuals cling to their assumptions, and even the most intelligent person can find himself operating with incomplete information.

I also found the novel's treatment of activism interesting. Opposition to an exploitative system might initially seem an uncomplicated moral choice, but the story raises questions about whether a just cause necessarily justifies every action taken in its name. Recognising an injustice is one thing; deciding how best to confront it is another. It is a worthwhile complication, even if the novel does not explore every implication as thoroughly as it might.

One character who particularly appealed to me was Anton. His hopelessness has a darkly comic quality that I found both amusing and endearing. There is something wonderfully appealing about a character who seems to have reached the point where optimism is no longer a realistic option and resignation has become almost a philosophy of life. He offers a contrast to the conventional heroism and determination often expected in science fiction. Not everyone can meet the dangers of the universe with the Doctor's resourcefulness or Sam's attempts to find a way forward. Sometimes all that remains is a weary acceptance of how thoroughly things can go wrong.

I found this aspect of Anton's character especially memorable. His hopelessness is not simply tragic; there is something funny in the apparent futility of it all. His appeal lies in the way he makes resignation entertaining without necessarily making it admirable. In a novel populated by competing interests, alien species and complicated plot threads, he provides a distinctive character whose outlook struck a particular chord with me.

Leonard's imagination is undoubtedly one of the book's strengths. The combination of unusual alien life, unfamiliar environments and the strange properties of dreamstone gives the story a distinctive atmosphere. The title itself is evocative. Dreams suggest memory, fear, desire and the mysterious workings of consciousness, while the idea of a substance connected with this private inner world introduces an unsettling element into what might otherwise have been a conventional mining adventure.

Unfortunately, imaginative richness does not always produce narrative clarity. The accumulation of alien species, scientific details and competing plot threads can make the story difficult to follow. At times, I felt that the ideas were more interesting than the mechanisms through which the plot attempted to realise them. There is a difference between a story being intellectually demanding and a story making it unnecessarily difficult for the reader to understand what is happening. Dreamstone Moon occasionally approaches the latter.

This is not to say that every detail needs to be explained or that science fiction should avoid complexity. Mystery is essential to the genre, particularly when dealing with alien life and phenomena beyond ordinary human experience. The challenge is to maintain a balance between mystery and confusion, and Leonard does not always get that balance right.

Ultimately, Dreamstone Moon is a novel I admire more than I love. Its ecological and ethical concerns give it substance, its imagination is frequently impressive, and Sam's struggle for independence provides an engaging emotional dimension. Anton's darkly comic hopelessness is an additional pleasure. Yet the plotting and character development do not consistently match the ambition of the ideas.

For me, this is a solid rather than outstanding Eighth Doctor Adventure: a book with plenty to think about, even if the reading experience is occasionally less satisfying than its underlying concepts deserve.

Rating: 7/10. An ambitious and thought-provoking Doctor Who novel that explores the consequences of treating the unfamiliar as something to be exploited, with a memorable streak of dark humour in Anton, but whose execution is not quite as accomplished as its ideas.


back to top