Doctor Who: The Library of Carsus discussion
The Greatest Show Discussion
>
Rogue
date
newest »
newest »
Fun romp.Loved the pokes at the genre and Bridgerton particularly.
Didn't love the romance, as I nearly always hate romance involving the Doctor, and this guy just pales in comparison to other attempts at this kind of character.
This guy was no Alex Kingston or John Barrowman.
Curious, if there's been 100s of other Doctors, that the scanner only detected the TV ones...
… or did it only have time to show the most recent ones?
Rick wrote: "… or did it only have time to show the most recent ones?"So, is Ruth recent?
Because I love that she was included, but it doesn't simplify things. It raises questions.
Maybe she is. Maybe she’s the one just preceding the Hartnell Doctor.
I’m actually surprised you didn’t comment on the one people aren’t quite able to identify. Some suggestions are David Warner and other are offering Richard E Grant.
Rick wrote: "Maybe she is. Maybe she’s the one just preceding the Hartnell Doctor.
I’m actually surprised you didn’t comment on the one people aren’t quite able to identify. Some suggestions are David Warner..."
Didn't catch it actually.
a couple of the images were little wonky, and then I got distracted by being happy they included the War and Ruth Doctors.
The faces do go by rather quickly. And it’s subtle.
Apparently, a big fan theory is the 'other doctor', is Richard E Grant's Shalka Doctor.I'm happy with that.
My other thought:
What's with the Doctor hitting on Rogue...?
he might still be a married man.
Technically he saw River Song “die” in the library. But … we still know absolutely zero about the Doctor’s earlier family that resulted in their granddaughter Susan. Maybe their incurable infidelity is what drive him away from Gallifrey to begin with. And for that matter why are you layering 20th century western morality on an alien raised in a culture completely different than either British or American?
We saw her die before they got married Which does not help simplify the matter
Only with conventional concepts of temporality.
Mod
The only doctor romance I’ve liked was 13 and YazSo this one was cute but I don’t care if we ever see rogue again
Is it just me or that the hottest kiss in the history Doctor Who? Probably just me.
Rick wrote: "Is it just me or that the hottest kiss in the history Doctor Who? Probably just me."Yeah, I can't argue that one.
I’m going to try and rewatch this tonight. But I’m still dealing with the onset of a gluten intolerance (allergy?) and I’m having trouble concentrating on anything or watch anything or eat anything.
I did rewatch it. And I still think it’s the best episode of the season.
Rick wrote: "I did rewatch it. And I still think it’s the best episode of the season."I don;'t think I'd say 'best', but it is definitely the most fun episode of the season.
The only thing missing is a reference to Captain Jack! 😺😸😻
❤️🧡💛💚💙💜