hot girls read books discussion
if he had been with me
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Bojana
(new)
Apr 23, 2024 03:04AM
Everyone who read ‘if he had been with me’ by laura nowlin, i wanna hear your thoughts :)
reply
|
flag
i finished this book maybe around a week ago and i have no idea how anyone gave it 5 stars
I read it last summer. Autumn just isn’t a very likable character, but I guess it fits since no one really is when they’re a teenager. I think the plot twist just felt out of place for the book, like it didn’t really add much to the book aside from ruin it. I would recommend reading it. It has some nice perspectives and thoughts, but don’t expect too much from it.
i don’t like autumn’s character. or how finn is literally cheating on sylvie. but somehow i kept reading. i tried starting if only i had told her, but i cant do it rn 😭 i could just be a hater but it definitely wasn’t my favorite book.
honestly i didnt really like it… i couldnt connect with any ofe the characters and i kinda knew what would happen at the end… still cried like a baby tho
I love this book because she had i life I always wanted but was never able to have. And I like that it was kinda like a diary of her life…the ending broke me. Honestly the whole book broke me
Just finished it, and I’m heartbroken. It was an amazing and beautiful story to follow and I will be thinking about it every single day. I gave it 4⭐️. Through out the whole book I constantly thought I would give it 5, but the end changed my mind.
Not because of Finny death (yes it was sad, but it is literally the story), but more of how late it was in the story that we’re back at the point where he died. I wanted to know more about how it would go with Autumn over the year(s), how she would recover and live.
Also I didn’t like the pregnancy thing. I know it’s about having a piece of Finny with Autumn for the rest of her life, but I’m just not a fan of anything pregnant related to a book.
Further it is an amazing book, I’m left in pieces and when I’m a little more recovered I’m gonna read the second one.❤️🩹😔
