Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

This topic is about
Icebound
Questions (from Librarians only)
>
I need clarification!
date
newest »


https://help.goodreads.com/s/article/...
I don't know much about audiobooks so my opinion on the second question wouldn't be of any use.

Abridged audiobooks should be combined with the unabridged editions.

Abridged audiobooks should be combined with ..."
But they are not the same book. You are losing 3/4 of the book. When I saw just how much of a difference there was I was flabbergasted. I would be ticked off to purchase an audiobook expecting it to be a telling of the 400 page tome and instead having it be a 100 page novelette.

https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...


Thanks Martin! So even if the title changes, the author still stays as the original publishing?

Abridged audiobooks should be combined with ..."
Thanks Arenda!

Abridged audiobooks should be..."
Tawnya, I know! that's what I was thinking too. But I guess as long as it is marked as unabridged, you know it's basically the same story.

Gem, I agree, that's why I am confused sometimes! My guess is that it is because the adaptation is usually by a different author, but abridgments are by the same author as the original?

It was my understanding that dramatized adaptations are meant to be separate editions because they could modify/remove parts of the original text. For example, instead of the narrator reading a line like "the rain drummed on the roof," the adaptation might remove that line and replace it with audio of rainfall.
But it seems that same logic of removing content does not apply to abridged/unabridged. However, it's entirely possible that I'm wrong on why adaptations are meant to be different editions.
Books mentioned in this topic
Icebound (other topics)Prison of Ice (other topics)
One other question: Would an abridged audio version be combined with the unabridged editions or should it be separated since the text would not be the same?
Thanks so much for your support!
~Donna