The book you like most discussion

480 views
books that weren't as good as people made them out to be

Comments Showing 1-50 of 117 (117 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Ari (new)

Ari (arisxbooks) | 45 comments What's a book you picked up due to all the praise it was getting online and found that, it just wasn't that good?

You don't necessarily have to have hated it but just thought it was overrated.

My two picks are probably Binding 13 and Evelyn Hugo, I did enjoy both books but from the praise they got online I thought I was getting some life changing, amazing books instead B13 felt like a basic teen drama (fun, but it didn't stand out much from other similar books which left me wondering how it got so popular) and EH, I found the twist too obvious and felt like a bit more could have been done with the idea (taking out the unneeded twist, just focusing on the old hollywood aspect and celia which was why most people were reading it.)

what are your picks?


message 2: by Annika (new)

Annika | 79 comments shatter me series. I just don't get the Warner hype. And there was no world building.


message 3: by Sara (new)

Sara Walling | 4 comments haunting adaline...like i just didnt care about these people enough to bother...


message 4: by Lucy (new)

Lucy | 131 comments Amari and the Night Brothers and Keeper of the Lost Cities. why were these books even published 😭


message 5: by Teju (new)

Teju  A (madephat) | 16 comments Divine rivals..... pls dont kill me 🫣
It was just okay....


message 6: by Susan (new)

Susan Stimmel (suzestimmel) | 29 comments Where the Crawfish sing....I started reading it and I tried to watch the movie...both were boring to me.


message 7: by Sam (new)

Sam | 45 comments Animal farm🫠


message 8: by Christine (new)

Christine Mathieu | 948 comments I don't remember the title, but a few years ago everybody recommended it. The author was German, the book took place in St. Malo, France, during WW II, but I couldn't get into it.

The same with "Secret History" by Donna Tartt...so boring!


message 9: by Christine (new)

Christine Mathieu | 948 comments Susan wrote: "Where the Crawfish sing....I started reading it and I tried to watch the movie...both were boring to me."

Same here!


message 10: by Lynn (new)

Lynn (officerripley) | 281 comments The Silent Patient and Where the Crawdads Sing; Crawdads was so boring I couldn't finish it; Silent Patient I did finish and am sorry I did.


message 12: by Krista (new)

Krista | 2 comments Fourth Wing Series


message 13: by Lady Grace (new)

Lady Grace | 82 comments Fourth Wing for sure! I like storyline/concept, and I'll probably finish the series, but the writing itself was subpar. it felt juvenile and not very well thought-out.


Clara 𐙚 🇵🇸 (clara17) | 272 comments The Spanish love deception


literally no one's here you moron | 43 comments The Maze Runner


message 16: by huma ✩ (new)

huma ✩ | 1 comments You’ve reached Sam for sure. The concept was interesting but it could’ve been executed better imo because it felt repetitive and boring.


message 17: by Athena (new)

Athena Rupas (athenamaerupas) | 20 comments Salma wrote: "I have said this before and I'll say it again IT ENDS WITH US AND IT STARTS WITH US ARE NOT WORTH THE HYPE"

Agreed


message 18: by Ash (new)

Ash Blomer (ashslibraryx) | 12 comments twisted love was just not it ,it was so cringe


message 19: by Renato (new)

Renato Oselame (renatooselame) Krista wrote: "Fourth Wing Series"

Yes, a thousand times yes.


message 20: by Renato (new)

Renato Oselame (renatooselame) Also: Shades of Magic.

I only read the first book, to be honest, but it had huge plot holes. I am still hesitant to continue with the other ones.


message 21: by Krista (last edited Jan 22, 2024 05:17AM) (new)

Krista | 2 comments Salma wrote: "I have said this before and I'll say it again IT ENDS WITH US AND IT STARTS WITH US ARE NOT WORTH THE HYPE"
Colleen Hoover is not worth the hype!! I dislike all of her books.


message 22: by Dee (last edited Jan 21, 2024 01:16PM) (new)

Dee Turner | 17 comments Piranesi. Just. Ugh. And thousands loved it! I don't see why. Sure, it had a lot of literary references, but the bare--and highly derivative--kidnap plot was endlessly held in abeyance (as though the author knew to be ashamed of such a threadbare conveyance) as we wandered around in the poor protagonist's confused and broken mind. On the other hand Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell was absolutely BRILLIANT. Go figure.

The Burning Witch. I wrote a review in Goodreads, hope you'll read it, comments always welcome.


message 23: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Canela Normal People. What I heard the most was that the writing and the story were so amazing, and to be honest, the writing just felt too "and then, and then, and then" sometimes, and the story could have gone interesting places but it felt too on the surface.


jennie⋆ ˚。⋆୨୧˚ (semi-hiatus) (jenniesbookhaven) | 1 comments it ends with us, spanish love deception, ugly love, caraval -- idk i went into them thinking i'd love them since everyone seems to but they were all kinda meh for me


message 25: by Shawna (new)

Shawna Finnigan (sugoishawn) | 120 comments I have a ton that I could put for this, but the biggest ones for me were The Deal and A Court of Thorns and Roses. Both of them are super loved online, but I found that I hated all the characters from both of the books


message 26: by Holly (new)

Holly Gonzales | 2 comments Divine Rivals


message 27: by Marg (new)

Marg Casey (margcasey) | 3 comments Melissa wrote: "Normal People. What I heard the most was that the writing and the story were so amazing, and to be honest, the writing just felt too "and then, and then, and then" sometimes, and the story could ha..."

Rooney is a super divisive writer. Don't get her but I know people who LOVE her work


message 28: by sarah (new)

sarah | 289 comments The Red Tent was highly recommended but I absolutely hated it. Stuart Little also recommended and did not care for that either.


message 29: by Aideen (new)

Aideen | 18 comments Shatter me and Fourth Wing really, and I liked ACOTAR but it's not as good as people say it is


Artemis~Ebonie (Inactive) | 65 comments Please no one kill me but Maze Runner and Harry Potter


message 31: by Cam (new)

Cam | 17 comments a court of thorns and roses and evelyn hugo, i started reading ACOTAR and for the life of me i couldn’t get past the first 100 pages, maybe it just wasnt for me but the writing style was just not it for me. and evelyn hugo, dont get me
wrong, i really enjoyed the book, i love the author and i liked the way it was written, its just… it wasn’t as earth shattering as people make it out to be


literally no one's here you moron | 43 comments Artemis~Ebonie wrote: "Please no one kill me but Maze Runner and Harry Potter"

ugh maze runner was AWFUL


message 33: by Christine (new)

Christine Mathieu | 948 comments I didn't care for Harry Potter, Little Women, Little House on the Prairie (I love the TV series though), Nils Holgersson, The Little Prince by Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, Nancy Drew, Hardy Boys, Dr. Zhivago by Boris Pasternak, anything by Charles Dickens, Guenter Grass, Donna Tartt, Where the Crawdads sang, Daniele Steel (her movies are nice), Elizabeth George (tried to start reading her first crime novel three times, but gave up), Outlander and too many more to list.


message 34: by Anjalijpk (new)

Anjalijpk | 59 comments shatter me series! I didn't like the way she dumped Adam. She could wait else what is the meaning of real love. To dump one & find another. And I don't get why people are obsessed with Warner. I stopped the series with 3rd book.


message 35: by Jaze Danelver (new)

Jaze Danelver (jazesedgwick) | 8 comments Dreamland Billionaires series was the absolute pits for me 👎👎👎


message 36: by Casey (new)

Casey Local Woman Missing and The Midnight Library. It took me roughly a month to read both books (separate months). I didn't understand the hype surrounding both. LWM was predictable and not thrilling at all. I read an article about TML and how it was the author's portrayal of his experience with attempting to harm himself, and it's not realistic, which I realize is the purpose of a fictitious novel, but he was talking about mental health...


message 37: by Jana (new)

Jana Noble | 5 comments im sorry but these twisted bonds


message 38: by Cortney (new)

Cortney Guysinger-Demint (cortneylgd) | 33 comments The Last Thing He Told Me by Laura Dave


message 39: by mar (new)

mar  | 12 comments To be completely honest, The Picture of Dorian Gray. I heard and read a lot of good reviews about the book, plus the plot sounded interesting, usually people said that the reflections in the book made them question themselves, etc.
Well, the "reflections" in the book are quite simple, and it is literally very easy to disagree with them, because they were indeed somewhat absurd. I don't take away from the importance of the impact the book had at the time, or the beautiful writing, among other things, but really, for me, it's not an amazing book at all,


message 40: by Cortney (new)

Cortney Guysinger-Demint (cortneylgd) | 33 comments I'm also not a fan of Colleen Hoover. she was recommended to me so many times, but the three books I've read from her just didn't grab me like other books I've read.


message 41: by sophia (new)

sophia | 5 comments probably iron flame. fourth wing was nice, i liked reading it, it was action packed and interesting. iron flame just didnt pull me in. it was so hard to start, i dont think ill pick it back up.


message 42: by Morgan (new)

Morgan Rose | 89 comments Tomorrow, and Tomorrow and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin.


message 43: by Sarah Lehman (new)

Sarah Lehman (sdelgado8404) | 116 comments Most stuff by Colleen Hoover


message 44: by Shani (new)

Shani Meyer | 2 comments Where the Crawdads Sing... interesting ending, I had to discuss it with someone. But overall I did not get the hype.


message 45: by Katy (new)

Katy Lovejoy | 76 comments handmaid's tale


message 46: by Katherine (new)

Katherine Munoz A fourth of thorns and roses (book 1)


message 47: by *jayla* (new)

*jayla* (mynameisjaylaa) | 1 comments divine rivals

it honestly disappointed me so much. like don’t get me wrong the romance and the story were good but i just didn’t really connect to the love between roman and iris like i thought i would. it just felt lacking somehow, i was more interested in the war than in their romance


message 48: by Rori (new)

Rori | 99 comments A Head Full Of Ghosts I've seen a lot of reviews on TikTok I've bought I've read it I've hated it.


message 49: by Christine (new)

Christine Mathieu | 948 comments A Secret Story by Donna Tartt. What a disappointment!


Apple˚✧ (ia-study) its the Twisted series for me I read the first two books and DNFed the rest series


« previous 1 3
back to top