Fantasy Buddy Reads discussion
This topic is about
Magic Tides & Magic Claims
Book Clubs!
>
IAAA - Ilona Andrews Addicts Anonymous: Kate Daniels: Wilmington Years & Other spinoffs (December 2024)
So the series has definitely picked up for me, in the last few days I read Magic Breaks, Magic Shifts and Magic Stars. I am almost caught up with the Kate Daniels part of this!
So how terrible would it be if I skipped Hugh's story and went right to book 10? I understand he is going through some things so can I just revisit later after I see how the main story ends?
I was gonna say you can skip Hugh's book, but you kinda can't...
Hugh's book is the start of a trilogy that hasn't been finished yet, but the first book which exists is actually super important to the finale of KD... the Hugh book introduces the lower level villains of the KD finale... the villain of the KD finale is the boss of the villain & underlings in Hugh's book...
The KD finale isn't Kate vs Roland, it's Kate & Roland vs a mutual enemy/threat, with the knowledge that betrayal is inevitable... and Kate still trying to find that solution she started seeking in book 8 with the djinn box...
Hugh's book is the start of a trilogy that hasn't been finished yet, but the first book which exists is actually super important to the finale of KD... the Hugh book introduces the lower level villains of the KD finale... the villain of the KD finale is the boss of the villain & underlings in Hugh's book...
The KD finale isn't Kate vs Roland, it's Kate & Roland vs a mutual enemy/threat, with the knowledge that betrayal is inevitable... and Kate still trying to find that solution she started seeking in book 8 with the djinn box...
Timelord Iain wrote: "I was gonna say you can skip Hugh's book, but you kinda can't...Hugh's book is the start of a trilogy that hasn't been finished yet, but the first book which exists is actually super important to..."
I do not think for a minute that Roland doesn't act like an asshat, he is the definition of untrustworthy. Also I knew you would say that lol Ugh that Michael R Miller book is a chonker, did not expect that, the next Stormlight Archives is staring me in the face, I may have to make some decisions, looking at you Michael R Miller lol
Ann-Marie wrote: "So how terrible would it be if I skipped Hugh's story and went right to book 10? I understand he is going through some things so can I just revisit later after I see how the main story ends?"Certain parts of the book play a role in the final Kate Daniels book. Sorry but it’s not skipable.
Diana Stormblessed wrote: "Ann-Marie wrote: "So how terrible would it be if I skipped Hugh's story and went right to book 10? I understand he is going through some things so can I just revisit later after I see how the main ..."I started it last night but I have been reading the ebooks the last few of these so it isn't as easy as audiobooks.
Ann-Marie wrote: "So the series has definitely picked up for me, in the last few days I read Magic Breaks, Magic Shifts and Magic Stars. I am almost caught up with the..."Ooh you've made excellent progress!
Ann-Marie wrote: "I started it last night but I have been reading the ebooks the last few of these so it isn't as easy as audiobooks..."What do you think of it so far? I really loved it but I do think they retconned Hugh a bit. (view spoiler)
Charlie wrote: "Ann-Marie wrote: "I started it last night but I have been reading the ebooks the last few of these so it isn't as easy as audiobooks..."What do you think of it so far? I really loved it but I do ..."
They tried to make him likable after spending many books making him unlikable. You had to basically forget all your prior thoughts about him and start from scratch.
Yea... most of his worst qualities were played off as kayfabe and/or Roland's manipulation... all a persona he put on to manipulate Kate/etc...
Charlie wrote: "Ann-Marie wrote: "I started it last night but I have been reading the ebooks the last few of these so it isn't as easy as audiobooks..."What do you think of it so far? I really loved it but I do ..."
I didn't get too far, I listened to some other books while doing house crap and now I am firmly in Cerulean Sea world but I'll be back soon :)
Timelord Iain wrote: "Is Hugh the stinky book from the other thread? :D"lol no, Defiant but it is probably my fault because I didn't love book 2 and I was unpleasantly surprised this one was like 900 pages long so I put it aside and will try again before I make the final decision to continue or tap out. As far as the Hugh book goes (view spoiler)
You're reading the Wilmington Years books?... everyone else was waiting for December for those...
If you read Blood Heir, which came out first (which you shouldn't... it's also being saved for December), you'd know (view spoiler)
If you read Blood Heir, which came out first (which you shouldn't... it's also being saved for December), you'd know (view spoiler)
Ann-Marie wrote: "So I finished this series yesterday.
Iron and Magic - [spoilers removed]
Magic Triumphs - [spoilers removed]"
I think people have ideas about Elara... and authors have said there are clues and some have figured it out... reads Eldritch to me, but I dunno... book 2 is coming very soon... they were gonna start writing it as early as this month, I think, but I dunno if timelines shifted a bit with the Big Publishing House contract for Maggie in 2026... I think they need to hit some editing deadlines and got covid over the summer, then they're free to write Hugh 2 and Innkeeper 6 during the year while Maggie is being edited, before they need to write Maggie 2 for 2027 release...
Iron and Magic - [spoilers removed]
Magic Triumphs - [spoilers removed]"
I think people have ideas about Elara... and authors have said there are clues and some have figured it out... reads Eldritch to me, but I dunno... book 2 is coming very soon... they were gonna start writing it as early as this month, I think, but I dunno if timelines shifted a bit with the Big Publishing House contract for Maggie in 2026... I think they need to hit some editing deadlines and got covid over the summer, then they're free to write Hugh 2 and Innkeeper 6 during the year while Maggie is being edited, before they need to write Maggie 2 for 2027 release...
Ann-Marie wrote: "So I finished this series yesterday.
Iron and Magic - [spoilers removed]
Magic Triumphs - [spoilers removed]"
Magic Triumphs: (view spoiler)
Iron and Magic - [spoilers removed]
Magic Triumphs - [spoilers removed]"
Magic Triumphs: (view spoiler)
So Julie 2 is to be released before Hugh 2? That is some bullshit, Hugh 1 was WAY before Julie 1.....
No... i dunno when Julie 2 is coming... Hugh 2 is coming super soon (see the previous comment before my Magic Triumphs comment, or after the Wilmington Years comment)...
I don't think the authors have concrete plans for things... they mostly write what gets the creative juices flowing... Wilmington Years was a surprise a year or 2 ago, with 2 novellas fast... Innkeeper Chronicles tends to get a bit of a priority as their first indie project before they went 90% indie... and they do fan votes on their website sometimes, to get a gauge for what series people are most interested in seeing next (but don't commit to picking the number 1 choice, just use it as a barometer and a bit of a ranked list to help them pick from options and possibilities)...
I dunno if Hugh 2-3 still takes place before KD 10... maybe it has to, to sort out the Hugh/Elara relationship, since they're sorted by KD 10... otherwise they could used it as a bridge bridge and just had Hugh 1 between 9-10, Hugh 2 between 10-Wilmington, and Hugh 3 between Wilmington-Julie...
I don't think the authors have concrete plans for things... they mostly write what gets the creative juices flowing... Wilmington Years was a surprise a year or 2 ago, with 2 novellas fast... Innkeeper Chronicles tends to get a bit of a priority as their first indie project before they went 90% indie... and they do fan votes on their website sometimes, to get a gauge for what series people are most interested in seeing next (but don't commit to picking the number 1 choice, just use it as a barometer and a bit of a ranked list to help them pick from options and possibilities)...
I dunno if Hugh 2-3 still takes place before KD 10... maybe it has to, to sort out the Hugh/Elara relationship, since they're sorted by KD 10... otherwise they could used it as a bridge bridge and just had Hugh 1 between 9-10, Hugh 2 between 10-Wilmington, and Hugh 3 between Wilmington-Julie...
Timelord Iain wrote: "No... i dunno when Julie 2 is coming... Hugh 2 is coming super soon (see the previous comment before my Magic Triumphs comment, or after the Wilmington Years comment)...I don't think the authors ..."
Yeah I missed your first post, sorry about that....About Hugh though, (view spoiler)
Ann-Marie wrote: "So I finished this series yesterday.Iron and Magic - [spoilers removed]
Magic Triumphs - [spoilers removed]"
Regarding Hugh (view spoiler)
Magic triumphs - (view spoiler)
I give the Roland plot some leeway... the original plan was to deal with Roland in book 7, after all... and then they realized that woulda been even more rushed, after basically building him up offscreen for 6 books... 8-10 let him breath a bit, but it was also an almost impossible problem to solve, in general... without just going scorched earth, damn the consequences to future storytelling possibilities...
Timelord Iain wrote: "I give the Roland plot some leeway... the original plan was to deal with Roland in book 7, after all... and then they realized that woulda been even more rushed, after basically building him up off..."Yeah I do see that, (view spoiler)
I was satisfied with the end of this series until I got some hints about how the next books play out and I am not so sure about that....
Charlie wrote: "Timelord Iain wrote: "I give the Roland plot some leeway... the original plan was to deal with Roland in book 7, after all... and then they realized that woulda been even more rushed, after basical..."(view spoiler)
The Sanctuary audiobook is $3 on Chirp for 4 more days... part of a $15 bundle that includes Small Magics, Magic Tides & Claims, and Sweep of the Heart, if you need those too...
Hit pause on Osten Ard at work today, and returned to my first love... Ilona Andrews...
I think my reading order for the month is:
Magic Tides
Magic Claims
Blood Heir
Sanctuary
As far as I know, that's chronological order... publication order would put Blood Heir 1st...
Zerged through Magic Tides at work and started Magic Claims... Magic Tides is super short, only 1/3 of the audiobook omnibus... 4hrs or so...
I love getting back to Kate, but am not enamored with the final confrontation... I like the 2nd book more and am looking forward to finishing it...
I think my reading order for the month is:
Magic Tides
Magic Claims
Blood Heir
Sanctuary
As far as I know, that's chronological order... publication order would put Blood Heir 1st...
Zerged through Magic Tides at work and started Magic Claims... Magic Tides is super short, only 1/3 of the audiobook omnibus... 4hrs or so...
I love getting back to Kate, but am not enamored with the final confrontation... I like the 2nd book more and am looking forward to finishing it...
I finished Magic Tides and agree that the ending isn't great. I like the setting and really could get a feel for the area.
Actually, the more I read Blood Heir today, the more it hits different when you know what Kate/Curran have been doing the previous year in Wilmington (view spoiler)
Wait I thought Blood Heir was supposed to be first! I am halfway through, dammit! Oh well I guess lol
It's fine... Blood Heir was published first... you're experiencing the Julie Timeline ;)
Not the Kate/Curran // Omniscient Timeline :D
Wilmington Years was written to setup things that were needed for Blood Heir #2 in the future...
I shuffled the reading order on my own prerogative, since I'm not worried about ruining BR points right now...
Not the Kate/Curran // Omniscient Timeline :D
Wilmington Years was written to setup things that were needed for Blood Heir #2 in the future...
I shuffled the reading order on my own prerogative, since I'm not worried about ruining BR points right now...
I finished Magic Claims this morning and I love how Kate and Curran always get the bad guys. I gave myself a mental slap to the head in chapter 12 when the leader was revealed. (view spoiler)I am going to work on Blood Heir next.
The 2 Wilmington books added a bunch of new characters and layers to the lore of The Pack & The People/Roland, and Alpha Strain Shifters like Curran... alot of great stuff... and then the potential of the tools provided, going into Blood Heir and the conflict brewing in that series... I'm really starting to look forward to Blood Heir 2-3...
Not really, no... I feel like we're gonna get a 3rd Wilmington book first, but that's not official... I know we're getting Hugh 2 and maybe Roman 2... that and/or the next Innkeeper Chronicles book are the promised books other than Maggie 1-2...
Maggie 1 rewrites have been taking longer than they'd hoped, because it sounds like Ilona needed her gallbladder removed earlier this year, among other things... they only have next year to write the non-Maggie books before they need to get on to writing Maggie 2 for release in 2027, I think... Maggie 1 comes out early 2026...
Maggie 1 rewrites have been taking longer than they'd hoped, because it sounds like Ilona needed her gallbladder removed earlier this year, among other things... they only have next year to write the non-Maggie books before they need to get on to writing Maggie 2 for release in 2027, I think... Maggie 1 comes out early 2026...
Was going to start Aurelia #1 Blood Heir but saw Iain's notes and think I'll do the same--start with Wilmington Years.And I am having the hardest time remembering who Aurelia is. Someone give me a summary?
It's Julie & Derek, but everyone is using fake identities... Julie is Aurelia Ryder... Aurelia = gold, and being a temporary Knight of the Order of Merciful Aid makes her Knight Ryder ;)
And Derek is Darren Argent, and Argent = Silver...
Gold & Silver...
Lots of stuff going on, and a new armageddon level threat to worry about, basically...
It's like 8 years after Magic Triumphs & 1 year after Magic Tides/Claims... Conlan is 9, and I think he's 8 in Magic Tides...
And Derek is Darren Argent, and Argent = Silver...
Gold & Silver...
Lots of stuff going on, and a new armageddon level threat to worry about, basically...
It's like 8 years after Magic Triumphs & 1 year after Magic Tides/Claims... Conlan is 9, and I think he's 8 in Magic Tides...
Ah, good to know, ty! I'm not sure I would have figured that out. Definitely starting Wilmington first...
Agreed... whether or not I love the villain of a story, I love all the character moments in Ilona Andrews books, basically...
LOL For all the violence, I'd say her books fit my personal definition of cozy...Read Blood Heir and really enjoyed it. One of the things I liked the most was just how much worldbuilding was packed in, especially (view spoiler)
Books mentioned in this topic
Magic Claims (other topics)Magic Tides (other topics)
Sanctuary (other topics)
Blood Heir (other topics)
Magic Tides (other topics)
More...




With the Maggie announcement, I think we'll get Iron & Magic 2, Innkeeper Chronicle 6, Blood Heir / Aureli..."
re Arabella (view spoiler)[when they had her do math and she was like seriously? I was like same, girl, SAME lol (hide spoiler)]