swifties who also read discussion

96 views
Once upon a broken heart

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Currently, I am reading Once Upon a Broken Heart by Stephanie Garber and I am losing my mind! Please no spoilers but I NEED to talk about this with someone who has read it! So if you are available let me know and we can have it out because JACKS! Ugh!


message 2: by megan ୨୧ (new)

megan ୨୧ (pipfitzamobi) | 50 comments I LOVE ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART!!


message 3: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments WARNING THIS CONTAINS SPOILERS.

Oh my gosh! Ok! So I am right at the part where Jacks just showed up at the dinner party that Evangeline is at for Apollo.


message 4: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments At *for* Apollo


message 5: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments And he just “made her interesting” by pretending to kiss her or kind of pretending to chase after her so that Apollo will be jealous.


message 6: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments “I told you I would kiss three people that you chose, not you.”
“Then why aren’t your pulling away?”
“I can’t fight you-your a fate.”
“Lies. I am not hurting you or kissing you.”


legendofthe3divas  | 998 comments ouabh is my fav Stephanie Garber duology (soon to be trilogy) and YES JACKS IS JUST SO PERFECT AHHHHHHHHHHH


message 8: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments I KNOW! And this is like the first time that I have fallen for a “villain.”


message 9: by raven (new)

raven (ryujinsgf) | 174 comments omg I've seen people talking about this book everywhere and idk if I should read it since I don't like caraval series T_T


message 10: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments It is NOTHING LIKE CARAVAL. Besides it being in the same world. It is way better!!


hansika 🫶 (hansikataylorsversion) | 172 comments i was so shocked when i read it bc it was so different from caraval (in the best way possible tho) and i fully believe that it is also like a trillion times better than caraval!


hansika 🫶 (hansikataylorsversion) | 172 comments also jacks >>>>


message 13: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Agreed


Erin (Rhys’s Version) | 80 comments Ok FOR ALL OF YOU WHO HAVE READ BALLAD OF NEVER AFTER WHAT WAS YOUR OPINION ON THE END BECAUSE I WANT TO THROW MYSELF OFF A CLIFF NOW


message 15: by megan ୨୧ (new)

megan ୨୧ (pipfitzamobi) | 50 comments ★ E̶r̶i̶n̶.̶R̶ ★ wrote: "Ok FOR ALL OF YOU WHO HAVE READ BALLAD OF NEVER AFTER WHAT WAS YOUR OPINION ON THE END BECAUSE I WANT TO THROW MYSELF OFF A CLIFF NOW"

ME TOO!! I have high hopes for a curse for true love though, she better make up for what she did at the end of the ballad of never after!


message 16: by samantha (new)

samantha aly | 307 comments ughh i hate Apollo sm


message 17: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments I think it is so funny that I don’t really know why you hate him so much because I literally just meet him. Like Evangeline just kissed him.


message 18: by samantha (new)

samantha aly | 307 comments Kenna wrote: "I think it is so funny that I don’t really know why you hate him so much because I literally just meet him. Like Evangeline just kissed him."

you have such a ride ahead of you. enjoy!!


message 19: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Thank you! If y’all don’t mind I will continue to update you! Cause I have no one else to talk to about this stuff and it is so good!


message 20: by samantha (new)

samantha aly | 307 comments Kenna wrote: "Thank you! If y’all don’t mind I will continue to update you! Cause I have no one else to talk to about this stuff and it is so good!"

def!! i LOVE talking about this series!


message 21: by Ava ✿ (ia) (new)

Ava ✿ (ia) | 146 comments ★ E̶r̶i̶n̶.̶R̶ ★ wrote: "Ok FOR ALL OF YOU WHO HAVE READ BALLAD OF NEVER AFTER WHAT WAS YOUR OPINION ON THE END BECAUSE I WANT TO THROW MYSELF OFF A CLIFF NOW"

MEEEEE TOO IM BARELY HANGING ON UNTIL THE NEXT ONE COMES OUT 🤧🤧🤧


message 22: by Ava ✿ (ia) (new)

Ava ✿ (ia) | 146 comments samantha wrote: "ughh i hate Apollo sm"

he needs to die asap 😩


message 23: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments OMG! I’m dying! APOLLO PROPOSED. AND SHE SAID YES! NOOOO! This is horrible. Because she does not like him he just likes the idea of a happy ending and he does not like her he is just under a spell!


message 24: by megan ୨୧ (new)

megan ୨୧ (pipfitzamobi) | 50 comments Kenna wrote: "OMG! I’m dying! APOLLO PROPOSED. AND SHE SAID YES! NOOOO! This is horrible. Because she does not like him he just likes the idea of a happy ending and he does not like her he is just under a spell!"

ughh apollo is the worst!! good luck!! he is honestly unbearable! but eva and jacks only get better <3


message 25: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments I know! Apollo is so annoying! Ugh. But Jacks is so perfect even though he is Loki the bad guy, I really don’t care because just the way that he acts and the things that he says and his attitude 😘


message 26: by hannah (new)

hannah bradley I SAW OUABH AND RAN HERE


message 27: by hannah (new)

hannah bradley Daddy Jacks > 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻 literally so perfect


message 28: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments FRFR


legendofthe3divas  | 998 comments "Daddy Jacks" tell me why I almost died laughing at this


message 30: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Nah me too! Because it is so real!


message 31: by Olive Lynn (new)

Olive Lynn | 7 comments definitely so good BUT the ballad of never after reigns supreme


message 32: by samantha (new)

samantha aly | 307 comments i'm rereading and annotating it, and ughh the foreshadowing and amazing quotes


message 33: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments OMG. Ok, quick WARNING: THIS CONTAINS SPOILERS FOR ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART.

I am losing my mind! I am literally rolling on the floor. I am not ok. FREAKING JACKS. She was about to get bit by freaking Luc (I HATE HIM) and Jacks (on INSTINCT) jumped in front of her so that she would not be bit and literally saves her life. Also all of this after he sat in a chair for a whole day just holding her in his lap because that was what would save her. And like I know that he “needs” her to open the Valory Arch but that is the stupidest thing I have ever heard. He is falling in love with her!!!!


message 34: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments “Evangeline-stop looking at me like that. Your making this much more difficult.” AHHHHH. IM CRYING. HE IS LITERALLY INFECTED WITH VAMPIRE VENOM


message 35: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Wait, Im so sorry but this is literally killing me, like every page just crushes my soul more. He is all like “you should go” and she DOES NOT. And he is like “why aren’t you going” and she says, “I’m not leaving you like this” UGH ITS KILLING ME. SHE LITERALLY SAYS “if she ever saw luc again, she would use a sword.”


hansika &#x1faf6; (hansikataylorsversion) | 172 comments IT JUST GETS BETTER AND BETTER


message 37: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments Sooooo, I FINISHED ONCE UPON A BROKEN HEART LAST NIGHT! 5 stars! I LOVED IT. I’m going to start The Ballad of Never After tonight! But also….WHY IN THE WORLD DID APOLLO STILL HAVE TO BE ALIVE. We do not need him for the story.


legendofthe3divas  | 998 comments @Kenna Jayne 100%. We need a separate chat that's basically Apollo slander


message 39: by Makenna (new)

Makenna | 97 comments WE DO


back to top