this topic tells who sophie's dad is so if you don't want to know don't look!

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

Sophie's dad is Elwin.
I know because someone I know has a friend who was on a zoom call with shannon messenger. Shannon swore to tell the truth and someone asked who sophie's dad was and she said Elwin.
then the friend told the person I know and the person I know told me

happy/sad/letdown? what's your reaction?
me mostly disbelief... but it makes sense

[Isla]

Yass i knew it!

[lydia ‧ ia, the Neverseen fear my level of fangirlism 😚🔪]

this doesn't sound very legit. No hate but idk if Shannon is even allowed to reveal stuff like that lol

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

EXACTLY MY REACTION
i just kind of sat back and tried to take it in
i know it makes sense, but i never really guessed

[lydia ‧ ia, the Neverseen fear my level of fangirlism 😚🔪]

yeah

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

i know i think it's weird too that she just shares that
i don't really care if you're suspicious of me, i get enough suspicion from my brothers every day just because. it makes sense that it's him but not that she'd share it...

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

it would make sense for it to be him but I just honestly don't think she'd share it either

[Izzy]

I did hear my friends say this as a theory before I read this thing

[Jillian B. (School Hiatus)]

I KNEW IT WAS ELWIN! (Sorry for yelling🫣)

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

it's okay i was trying very hard not to scream when she told me

[Audrey]

I mean..I dont know if that infos true (no hate) but I always thought he was her dad except for one reason: mr forkle said that her mom and dad don’t know each other but Oralie and Elwin definitely know each other right??

[Izzy]

I mean he also made it sound like they've never heard of each other (at least to me) and you can't not have heard of Oralie (I mean you probably can) also we don't know Elwin personally knew any or all of the councilors when Mr. Forkle was working on Project Moonlark

[lydia ‧ ia, the Neverseen fear my level of fangirlism 😚🔪]

I think he said they don't know each others identities but they might still know each other as acquaintances

[Izzy]

Hmm maybe we need to study these details more 🧐

[♡ Naisha ♡ ♫]

OMG I knew it!!! I always knew it would be elwin. He is already such a dad figure to sophie.

[Cari]

I'm a little sus...we'll see when book 10 comes out
if it's Elwin tho, rip Sophie

[lydia ‧ ia, the Neverseen fear my level of fangirlism 😚🔪]

IKR like I honestly hope it’s not bc Sophie will act all bratty ruin the relationship 😭😭

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

yeahhhhh....

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

⭑ Audrey ⭑ wrote: "I mean..I dont know if that infos true (no hate) but I always thought he was her dad except for one reason: mr forkle said that her mom and dad don’t know each other but Oralie and Elwin definitely..."

that was a confusing bit to me because, everyone knows Oralie bc shes a councillor right? i'm pretty sure the thing is that they don't know the other is the parent.

also did you guys catch in neverseen? she used to think oralie was her mom, and then Mr. Forkle said something and she ruled it out

[Cari]

WOAAH

[lydia ‧ ia, the Neverseen fear my level of fangirlism 😚🔪]

MR. FORKLE HAS BEEN OFFICALLLY LABELED A LIARRRRRRRRRRRR

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

SHE RULED OUT THE WRONG PARENT THOUGH
It was like: A new thought emerged- far more heartbreaking than any of her other theories.
Mr Forkle sighed. I can tell you're still pondering possibilities. So I will add: your genetic parents had no connection to each other. There was no unrequited love. At the time they gave their DNA, they weren't even friends. I did that purposely, because I couldn't allow them to know who the other parent was.
But they do know I'm their daughter? Sophie verified.
Yes. And that truly is the last i can say.
HIs voice went silent in her mind, leaving her reeling from her new theory. What he told her ruled out half of it (YOU SEE SHE JUST RULED OUT ORALIE!!!!) but not the most heartbreaking part.
Her father could still be... she couldn't bear to think the name. But he was a Telepath. And he was so kind to her And it would explain why he'd given her his cache

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

"Okay, you guys are doing that staring into each others eyes thing again," Keefe said, "and it's a lot creepier when it's Sophorkle."

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

yes Keefe I agree completely, Sophorkle is creepy

[Cari]

KEEFE SPEAKS FOR THE FANDOM

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

sameeeeee

[[deleted user]]

yeah

[⭑⋆｡ katya, I'm Batman, so I could be your hero any day <3]

yea, that's just soooo wrong

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

SOKEEFE 4 LIFE

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

YEEEEEEE!!!

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

TEAM FOSTER-KEEFE WILL ALWAYS BE COOLER!

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

I HAVE THAT QUOTE AT THE BOTTOM OF MY INFO IN MY PROFILE

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

I KNOWWW! YOUR PROFILE IS AMAZING BTW!!
MY MOM GOT ME A SHIRT THAT SAYS IT FOR MY BIRTHDAY!! ITS AN AMAZING QUOTE!!!

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

OH MY GOSH SO JEALOUS!!! I'VE BEEN PETITIONING FOR A SWEATSHIRT THAT SAYS THAT!!!!

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

ITS AMAZINGGGGGG!! I VERY MUCH LOVE IT ITS THE BEST!!

[Cari]

OFF TOPIC AGAIN

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

OF COURSEEEEEE

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

IT'S KEEFE HONESTLY WHO CARES

[⭑⋆｡ katya, I'm Batman, so I could be your hero any day <3]

Ellie wrote: "OH MY GOSH SO JEALOUS!!! I'VE BEEN PETITIONING FOR A SWEATSHIRT THAT SAYS THAT!!!!"

I DESPERATELY NEED A SOKEEFE RELATED SWEATSHIRT

[Ellie, Keefe's (not-so-) secret admirer]

WHAT ABOUT HAPPY SHADOW THOUGHTS

[⭑⋆｡ katya, I'm Batman, so I could be your hero any day <3]

THAT TOO I WANT ALL SORTS OF KEEPER GEAR

[⭑⋆｡ katya, I'm Batman, so I could be your hero any day <3]

EXCEPT FOR F*TZ STUFF BECAUSE ABSOLUTELY NOT

[Kaylee, Obsessed with Keefe Sencen]

YEEEE!!
WHENEVER I GET MORE KOTLC MERCH THE NEXT THING ON MY LIST IS A TEAM FOSTER-KEEFE SWEATSHIRT/HOODIE!!!

[✨da amazing and brilliant ZZ✨]

It makes sense. Oralie and Elwin never really knew each other. And Elwin was always so nice to Sophie.

[Sheryl]

I'm actually doing facial comparisons so we will see if you are right.

[Sheryl]

Ok they both according to APIs have rectangular faces otherwise I don't see any simlarites other then a sharp jawline.

[book obsessed]

If it is Elwin and their awesome relationship gets ruined I’m going to cry. I love the relationship between Elwin and Sophie (I kinda feel like it’s a fun/protective uncle relationship) and if Shannon ruins that I don’t know if I can forgive her.

[Molly]

I cant believe this, like I don't belie it

[[deleted user]]

ok so honestly ive been reading kotlc for years, and I suspected it. i believe elwin is her dad, but no offense that's kindaaaaa sketchy. you gotta remind yourself that this is shannon messenger: ultimate cliffhanger and secret-er. no way would she reveal this.

[b o o k s]

I really hope that if this does end up being true that it doesn’t ruin Sophie and Elwin’s relationship because I swear I will die