SciFi and Fantasy Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
What Else Are You Reading?
>
What Else Are You Reading in 2023?
date
newest »


I must have read The Black Company six or seven times.


Beginning Tim Blanning's biography of Frederick the Great.


3 of 5 stars
Starting Generation Ship based on the many recommendations here. 30 pages in and already hooked!


DNFed The Mountain in the Sea



Anyhoo, back to sci-fi, now starting Gregory Benford's Timescape.


That's a great collection of books!


Old Man's War
Project Hail Mary

My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This is a good, character-driven work. The first 80% is excellent. Lots of attention paid to the problems of running a ship for more than two centuries and doing so with near-future technology. At that point it is at least 4-star book. The ending seems a bit rushed and could have been fleshed-out more.
But the thing that cost the fourth star happened 16 cycles after arrival in an Eddie Dannin chapter. Without spoiling it, the problem is a clear violation of physics. With all the care paid to science and physics early on, this event was jarring.
Next up is The Three-Body Problem. I want to keep writing reviews next year. How many books should I set up for next year's challenge?

My rating: 3 of 5 stars
This is a good, character-driven work. The first 80% is excellent. Lots of attention paid to the problems of running a ship ..."
I hate that when some small detail throws you out of suspension of disbelief. Happened to me recently as well ...

He talks of university politics some, which I'm sure he has first had knowledge of, since he was a physicist teaching at UC Irvine.
Highly recommended! Now, moving to Octavia Butler's sequel, Parable of the Talents. Loved Parable of the Sower!


Now rereading an old fav, Chindi.
Marc, I remember reading and liking Timescape some time ago but can remember little about it. I might try a reread.

Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead by Olga Tokarczuk, which is not SFF but more of a mystery. Unreliable narrators are normally not my thing, but I found this one to be incredibly interesting - an older woman who is very observant.
I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman. I imagine a lot of people would find this story bleak, but I found it to be just right for where I am right now, and I’m glad it will be my final book completed in 2023. The narrator is a young woman who has no memory of her time before the main events in the book begin, and so she approaches the world in a very different way than those around her. You have to be okay with not having all (or even many) of your questions answered with this book, though.



(For Hank)
I recently finished Hogfather which completes the full discworld series for me (a goal for this year). Hank requested my opinion on the various parts of the series, so here it is ...
Favorite Overall Book:
1st- Night Watch, Perfect blend of literary significance, character growth, and satire. Ironically this is the first Watch book I read.
2nd- Small Gods, Because religion *is* funny when you think about it. It can be read as a stand alone without being immersed in the series and let you know if Pratchett will be for you or not. I find him delightful (obviously).
Least Favorite Overall: The Last Continent, I just didn't get the humor in this one perhaps because I don't have opinions about Australia.
Favorite Sub-Series:
(If you don't know discworld has several characters the books can focus on which provides sever sub-series within the series. It makes sense when you start reading the books.)
1st- City Watch books: strong diversity themes, always a mystery/crime to solve, lovable characters
2nd- Industrial Revolution: defining progress and who gets to benefits from it, but in funny anachronistic ways
3rd- Tiffany Aching: because I'm a sucker for coming-of-age tales and for clever winning the day
Least Favorite Sub-Series:
*Rincewind/University
*Witches
I think I just don't like these characters.
Discworld list of books: https://www.discworldemporium.com/rea...
I recently finished Hogfather which completes the full discworld series for me (a goal for this year). Hank requested my opinion on the various parts of the series, so here it is ...
Favorite Overall Book:
1st- Night Watch, Perfect blend of literary significance, character growth, and satire. Ironically this is the first Watch book I read.
2nd- Small Gods, Because religion *is* funny when you think about it. It can be read as a stand alone without being immersed in the series and let you know if Pratchett will be for you or not. I find him delightful (obviously).
Least Favorite Overall: The Last Continent, I just didn't get the humor in this one perhaps because I don't have opinions about Australia.
Favorite Sub-Series:
(If you don't know discworld has several characters the books can focus on which provides sever sub-series within the series. It makes sense when you start reading the books.)
1st- City Watch books: strong diversity themes, always a mystery/crime to solve, lovable characters
2nd- Industrial Revolution: defining progress and who gets to benefits from it, but in funny anachronistic ways
3rd- Tiffany Aching: because I'm a sucker for coming-of-age tales and for clever winning the day
Least Favorite Sub-Series:
*Rincewind/University
*Witches
I think I just don't like these characters.
Discworld list of books: https://www.discworldemporium.com/rea...

gonna now briefly leave scifi, reading 'the genius of birds' by Jennifer Ackerman. mainly because I briefly lost parable and started reading it instead!

I really loved it, too - I can't stop thinking about it.
Oleksandr, whether or not you love it, I think it will make for an excellent discussion book.

I recently finished Hogfather which completes the full discworld series for me (a goal for this year). Hank requested my opinion on the various parts of the series, so he..."
Thanks Melanie! I love hearing summary opinions. Pratchet is usually a miss for me but I hear consistantly good things about Night Watch
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Hogfather (other topics)Night Watch (other topics)
Small Gods (other topics)
Hogfather (other topics)
The Last Continent (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
T. Kingfisher (other topics)Robin Hobb (other topics)
Robert Jordan (other topics)
Lois McMaster Bujold (other topics)
Martha Wells (other topics)
More...
figure I'll have to!