Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion

2893 views
2023 Challenge - Advanced > 45 - A Book That Started Out as Fan Fiction

Comments Showing 101-115 of 115 (115 new)    post a comment »
1 3 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 102: by Danielle (new)

Danielle (danielle_jhnsn) | 33 comments This article also confirms The Dead Romantics started as fanfic: https://ashleyposton.substack.com/p/i...


message 103: by Khalisti (new)

Khalisti | 24 comments Would you consider continuations after original authors' death here, like Poirot by Sophie Hannah or any that continue Holmes adventures here? I tentatively have 'The idea of you' here, but I'm not very excited about it plus it will be harder to get.


message 104: by Joanna G (new)

Joanna G (joanna_g) | 359 comments Khalisti wrote: "Would you consider continuations after original authors' death here, like Poirot by Sophie Hannah or any that continue Holmes adventures here? I tentatively have 'The idea of you' here, but I'm not..."

I know people have different interpretations of this prompt, but I absolutely would. I think when you're taking someone else's characters and continuing or changing their story, that's what fan fiction is!

I know some people are interpreting it as it was originally intended not to be published, but then reworked, so in that case it might depend on what you could find about the authors' intentions. However, I think those examples are fully within the spirit of the prompt.


message 105: by Sarah (last edited Nov 15, 2023 11:34AM) (new)

Sarah (sarahbythebook) | 2 comments Does anyone know if The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake started out as fanfic? I know she's written a lot, but I've never read her stuff and can't find anything definitive.


message 107: by Danielle (new)

Danielle (danielle_jhnsn) | 33 comments Britany wrote: "Finished The Dead Romantics The Dead Romantics by Ashley Poston by Ashley Poston

My Review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show..."


I also LOVED that book! It was not something I normally would have picked up but I'm so glad I did.


message 108: by Britany (new)

Britany | 1714 comments I feel the same way! Ended up being in my top 10 of the year I think.


The Pampered Librarian | 165 comments Britany wrote: "Finished The Dead Romantics The Dead Romantics by Ashley Poston by Ashley Poston

My Review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show..."


What is this fan fic of? I still haven't figured out this prompt and probably won't at this point...


message 110: by Jen W. (new)

Jen W. (piratenami) | 520 comments Laura wrote: "What is this fan fic of? I still haven't figured out this prompt and probably won't at this point..."

There's a link elsewhere in this thread where the author says it started life as a fanfic.

My guess is it was a Reylo (Star Wars) AU, just because the male lead is an Adam Driver lookalike with two other Star Wars names (Ben Andor).


message 111: by Tara (new)

Tara (norcalnobody) Sarah wrote: "Does anyone know if The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake started out as fanfic? I know she's written a lot, but I've never read her stuff and can't find anything definitive."

Google says probably, a Draco/Hermione one. There's no direct link I can find a la Hazelwood but considering she was a big fic writer for that pairing and a bunch of people have been like "oh the main two in The Atlas Six feel like Dramione" you can probably use it.


message 112: by Britany (new)

Britany | 1714 comments Hi Laura- it started as a Star Wars FanFict and morphed into this.


message 113: by Anshita (new)

Anshita (_book_freak) | 273 comments I was initially going to read The Chosen and the Beautiful, but now I have switched to The Call of the Wild by Jack London.


message 114: by Louise (last edited Dec 28, 2023 03:36PM) (new)

Louise | 39 comments In case anyone is still looking just finished Notorious Sorcerer and in the end of book author interview the author does state the book started out as fanfiction (no indication of what of though).


message 115: by Aquaria (new)

Aquaria | 53 comments John Scalzi's Redshirts is Star Trek fanfic (the red shirt characters had a habit of being the death of the week, LOL).

Starter Villain might as well be James Bond fanfic.


1 3 next »
back to top