autumn leaves bookclub discussion

It Starts with Us (It Ends with Us, #2)
This topic is about It Starts with Us
33 views
buddy reads > it starts with us- isabelle&shell

Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
heyyy!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments hiii!!


message 3: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "hiii!!"

i've reached ch 10!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments YAYYYYY


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments okiee now I can share some of my thoughts: WHY IS ATLAS SO ADORABLE. like this man is so so much more respectful and sweeter than ryle in every way possible. speaking of ryle, I can kinda see why other people were frustrated with lily still letting him into her life (especially with that apartment key scene ugh), but I think it's pretty accurate to life: she can't leave completely because Emerson, and she's still friends with his sister. it'd be impossible to completely cut him off.


message 6: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "okiee now I can share some of my thoughts: WHY IS ATLAS SO ADORABLE. like this man is so so much more respectful and sweeter than ryle in every way possible. speaking of ryle, I can kinda see why o..."

I KNOW RIGHT??! I WANT TO EAT HIS FACE OFF. yeah that was weird like give her the keys back already. i agree but she needs to stop saying "but what would ryle think if i did this or that" just because he is the father of her child. but again it's ryle we're talking about so it's inevitable that he'll put on a show again and make everything worse.


message 7: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
so are we reading until chapter 20 now? i love how it doesn't even feel like im reading the book. it just flows like a river ahh and i've missed atlas and lily so muchhh. can't wait to read about their date hehe :)


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments honestly you're right; even if she can't cut him off she doesn't need to live her life by the "what would ryle say?" at some point, she does need to be independent.
also random side note: i know technically this book was a cash grab since the first was released in 2016, but does it just not feel that way to you? for me it lowkey feels effortless and that everyone really needed a sequel (especially atlas 😍)


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments yes yes ch 20!! and i 100% agree, it so does not like feel like i'm actually reading and that is the most glorious feeling. lily and atlas forever omigosh 😭


message 10: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "honestly you're right; even if she can't cut him off she doesn't need to live her life by the "what would ryle say?" at some point, she does need to be independent.
also random side note: i know t..."


yess! but it is also known as a fact that this book wouldn't exist if there weren't any obstacles to prevent atlas and lily from getting back together so im done complaining lol


message 11: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "honestly you're right; even if she can't cut him off she doesn't need to live her life by the "what would ryle say?" at some point, she does need to be independent.
also random side note: i know t..."


i knoww! it ends with us got very popular on booktok so people obviously asked for a sequel, but the author's note in the beginning kind of convinced me that this was written for those fans and not for money. yes she will still earn money but i don't think that she needed to sit down and write a whole book to earn it, from what i see, she already seems to be wealthy. YES #litlasforeva or whatever their ship name is 😭


message 12: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
heyy! just finished ch 20 and im ready to chat whenever you are :)


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments shell wrote: "heyy! just finished ch 20 and im ready to chat whenever you are :)"

omigosh I just finished and HOLYYYYY


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments that was so good. I lowkey just want to give Josh the best hug ever and ship Ryle off to the furtherest island because how dare he scare her like that?? That would've terrified me, standing alone on a balcony with a violent abuser 😭


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "honestly you're right; even if she can't cut him off she doesn't need to live her life by the "what would ryle say?" at some point, she does need to be independent.
also random si..."


lol I totally missed that author's note, I now 100% agree with you about the money part bahaha. also Litlas is the most perfect ship name, I nominate ✋


message 16: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "that was so good. I lowkey just want to give Josh the best hug ever and ship Ryle off to the furtherest island because how dare he scare her like that?? That would've terrified me, standing alone o..."

I KNOW RIGHT. I LOVE THEO SO MUCH BTW HE IS HILARIOUS. ugh so would i. YES #litlas it is. cause they're so lit ;) meet you at chapter 30!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "that was so good. I lowkey just want to give Josh the best hug ever and ship Ryle off to the furtherest island because how dare he scare her like that?? That would've terrified me,..."

bahahaha you're amazing and OMIGOSH I AGREE THEO IS THE MAN AND ATLAS & LILY ARE LIT. see you at 30! 🥳


message 18: by ophélie, admin (last edited Oct 25, 2022 08:36AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "that was so good. I lowkey just want to give Josh the best hug ever and ship Ryle off to the furtherest island because how dare he scare her like that?? That would've..."

so are you hehe! (ch 24 spoilers) (view spoiler)


message 19: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
just finished ch 30!! can’t wait to discuss it with you :) after this we have 5 chapters left if im not wrong (it might be seven though) and im LOVING it so far it’s so easy to read ugh


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments ahh I’m at school and can’t read atm, but I’m so excited!!


message 21: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "ahh I’m at school and can’t read atm, but I’m so excited!!"

good luck at school!!


message 22: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "ahh I’m at school and can’t read atm, but I’m so excited!!"

good luck at school!!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "ahh I’m at school and can’t read atm, but I’m so excited!!"

good luck at school!!"


thank you!!


message 24: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
omg i've reached ch 30 but im waiting for you i promise!!!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments girl i'm so sorry imm holding you up, i'm at ch 25 and going fast 💕


message 26: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "girl i'm so sorry imm holding you up, i'm at ch 25 and going fast 💕"

no no it's okay! i'm sorry i couldn't stop reading hahah <3


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments omigosh i just finished ch 30 this is so fricking gooooood 😭😭


message 28: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "omigosh i just finished ch 30 this is so fricking gooooood 😭😭"

omg yess. 7 chapters to go let's do this!!


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments let's do this!!!


message 30: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
OKAY WELL IM CRYING RIGHT NOW.


message 31: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "shell wrote: "Isabelle wrote: "that was so good. I lowkey just want to give Josh the best hug ever and ship Ryle off to the furtherest island because how dare he scare her like tha..."

btw have you seen my opinions? we forgot to talk about the book lol all we did was swoon over atlas😭 (im not complaining though😏)


message 32: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
AHH JUST FINISHED READING IT!!!! I LOVE ITTT CANT WAIT TO CHAT WITH YOU <3


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments shell wrote: "AHH JUST FINISHED READING IT!!!! I LOVE ITTT CANT WAIT TO CHAT WITH YOU <3"

GIRL I JUST FINISHED IT TOO IT WAS ABSOLUTELY SO AMAZING YESSSS LETS CHAT WHEN YOU SEE THIS LOL

(also I haven't seen your opinions yet haha we really have to discuss things non-atlas related 😂)


message 34: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "shell wrote: "AHH JUST FINISHED READING IT!!!! I LOVE ITTT CANT WAIT TO CHAT WITH YOU

GIRL I JUST FINISHED IT TOO IT WAS ABSOLUTELY SO AMAZING YESSSS LETS CHAT WHEN YOU SEE THIS LOL

(also I have..."


YESS


Isabelle Reads (theisabellereads) | 30 comments ok hey so I'm like trying to compile my thoughts into a review and this is freaking hard. like idk what to say that hasn't already been said for the last book 😭 any ideassss


message 36: by ophélie, admin (new) - rated it 5 stars

ophélie (poemsforophelia) | 179 comments Mod
Isabelle wrote: "ok hey so I'm like trying to compile my thoughts into a review and this is freaking hard. like idk what to say that hasn't already been said for the last book 😭 any ideassss"

hii omg ikr?? i guess im in a review writing slump. i’ll try to find something once i get back from school i’ll lyk <3


back to top