Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

Unfinished Tales
This topic is about Unfinished Tales
181 views
[Closed] Added Books/Editions > [Done] New translation/edition of Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth

Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by محمدحسین (last edited Nov 19, 2022 11:02PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments Hi, there is a new Persian translation of this original title:
Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-Earth

There is an older translation of this book which only contains 1 part of the original book (older translation is only Part Two: The Second Age):
قصه‌های ناتمام نومه‌نور و سرزمین میانه

New edition is combination of that old translation + the remaining parts which were translated recently. The book is now complete and has 3 translators separated by , bellow. Second in person translator section is me

* Title: قصه‌های ناتمام نومه‌نور و سرزمین میانه
* Author(s) name(s):
Author: J.R.R. Tolkien
Edited by: Christopher Tolkien
Translators: رضا علیزاده, محمدحسین شکوهی, ناهید خسروی
* ISBN (or ASIN): 6222344704 (9786222344702)
* Publisher: انتشارات روزنه
* Publication date: 24 August 2022
* Format: Paperback
* Page count: 660
* Language: Persian
* Description:
قصه‌های ناتمام نومه‌نور و سرزمین میانه مجموعه‌ای از حکایات است که وقایعِ روزگارانِ کهنِ سرزمین میانه را تا پایان جنگ حلقه بازگو می‌کند و شامل روایت پرهیجان گندالف درباره چگونگی فرستادن دورف‌ها به آن میهمانی معروف در بگ‌اند، نمایان شدن خدای دریا اولمو در پیش چشمان تور در سواحل بلریاند، و شرح مفصل ساز و کار نظامی سواران روهان است. این کتاب شامل تنها داستان به جا مانده از روزگاران دیرین نومه‌نور پیش از سقوطش است، به علاوه تمام چیزهایی که از پنج ساحر، پلان‌تیری، یا افسانه آمروت وجود دارد.

جی. آر. آر. تالکین در سال ۱۹۵۵ به هنگام نوشتن ضمایم برای فرمانروای حلقه‌ها گفته بود: «کسانی که از کتاب تنها به عنوان «رزم‌نامۀ عاشقانه» لذت می‌برند، و «پس‌زمینۀ توضیح‌داده نشده» را تنها جلوه‌ای ادبی می‌دانند، ضمایم را نادیده می‌انگارند که همینطور نیز هست.» برخلاف آنچه که گفته شد، قصه‌های ناتمام مشخصاً برای کسانی است که هنوز در سرزمین میانه، زبان‌هایش، افسانه‌هایش، سیاست‌هایش و شاهانش به طور کافی کنکاش نکرده‌اند.

کریستوفر تالکین این مجموعه را ویرایش و عرضه کرده است. او همچنین نقشه فرمانروای حلقه‌ها را در ابعادی بزرگ‌تر مجدداً ترسیم و تنها نقشه‌ای که جی. آر. آر. تالکین از نومه‌نور ساخته بود را بازآفرینی کرده است.


* Book in publisher website:
https://rowzanehnashr.com/product/%d9...

* Cover JPEG URL:
https://rowzanehnashr.com/wp-content/...


محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments this edition is still not added. there are w size (and different page numbers) of this book and different covers. newer one is added (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6...) but not the one i made thread


message 8: by Christine (new)

Christine | 2061 comments The book has been added by someone (on the 11th of december 2022):

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6...

The page count is different from the one you gave, but otherwise it seems to be the exact same edition.


محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments Christine wrote: "The book has been added by someone (on the 11th of december 2022):

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6...

The page count is different from the one you gave, but otherwise it seems to be the..."


content is the same, yes, but page size, page count and cover are different. this edition i posted is "paperback" and the other one currently online is "hardcover". i have both of them and you can see them side-by-side. front:

bindings:


hardcover has an additional bonus map of Beleriand too

if this doesn't counts as another edition, sorry for bothering


message 10: by Christine (new)

Christine | 2061 comments Thank you for the information. Paperback and hardcover are in fact different editions and should be classified separately. But the edition that we already have in the database, is classified as a paperback there, and it has the ISBN 9786222344702 that you gave for the paperback. Thecover image is that of the hardback, though. Something seems to have been mixed up.

As you own both editions, can you please specify which ISBN belongs the the paperback and which to the hardback? (If possible, please give both the ISBN10 and the ISBN13.)
Also, is it correct that the paperback has 660 pages and the hardback 876?

Thank you very much.


محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments Christine wrote: "Thank you for the information. Paperback and hardcover are in fact different editions and should be classified separately. But the edition that we already have in the database, is classified as a p..."

thank you for your fast and detailed response

yes, it seems mixed up. i went to check and i noticed ISBN 10 & 13 of both books are the same! i checked back of the book and inside (2 places inside!) and it seems even the publisher mixed them up. publisher website was no help either. i can ask them but i don't know when i get answers. here is back of the books:


but for the things you asked:
ISBN10: 6222344704
ISBN13: 9786222344702

page count for Paperback is correct (660), there might be a problem for Hardcover though, it's printed to page 873 but after page 873 where book ends there are 3 white pages, back of 873 is white and two side of another page are blank after that. publisher website states it has 876 pages which is technically correct but 3 of them are completely white pages, i don't know about the rules of page count though


message 12: by Christine (new)

Christine | 2061 comments Thank you for the information. It is very unusual that both editions have the same ISBN. I created a new entry for the hardback edition but had to leave the ISBN field blank, because it is not possible to enter an ISBN already in the database a second time. The other data, including the cover images, should be correct now:
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6... (paperback, new photo may take a little while to become visible)
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/7... (hardback)

Please let me know if there are any mistakes left. Otherwise, please edit the title of this thread and add "[DONE]". Thank you.


محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments Christine wrote: "Thank you for the information. It is very unusual that both editions have the same ISBN. I created a new entry for the hardback edition but had to leave the ISBN field blank, because it is not poss..."

thank you very much for your time.

yes, it's indeed unusual, i'll have a meeting with publisher, i can ask more on the matter then.

paperback page number is still 876 (https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6...) and can you please fix my name in paperback edition too? it's correct in hardcover which you kindly added, but not in paperback one which was wrong. it should be "محمدحسین شکوهی" just like the other one.
and if you want the exported cover photo (not my captured photo) you can use this image:




message 14: by Christine (last edited Jan 24, 2023 01:50AM) (new)

Christine | 2061 comments Thanks for your feedback. I have exchanged the photo and corrected your name as well as the page count in the paperback version. (Not yet visible, it takes a llittle while for the database to update.)

Hopefully, your name is correct now! I do not read Persian, it's hard to see the difference. Otherwise, just let me know – we will get there in the end.


محمدحسین (mhshokuhi) | 14 comments Christine wrote: "Thanks for your feedback. I have exchanged the photo and corrected your name as well as the page count in the paperback version. (Not yet visible, it takes a llittle while for the database to updat..."

thanks you very much. everything is correct now and it's fine really, i remember old times that a lot of browsers didn't even render Persian correctly and we had to use a lot of workarounds back then when wanting to communicate these stuff xD i changed the title to closed and again thanks for your time :)


back to top