Question A

[Jonetta]

Bobby Chin takes five-year old daughter, Elle, to a corn maze for Halloween. When they play a game of hide-and-seek, she disappears without a trace. Given what we knew up to that moment, who or what did you suspect?

[Charlene]

I guess I suspected his ex's boyfriend, if anyone at that point.

[Robin]

I didn't know if the ex-wife had someone snatch her or if it was a stranger.

[Jonetta]

I was actually giving Bobby the side eye because he was so adamant about doing that corn maze. It didn’t seem like a fun thing to do for a 5-year old that late at night. It all felt a bit weird.

[Sharon]

I was looking at the boyfriend. We loved doing the Halloween mazes as kids. I can see a dad who was having problems with the ex trying take the child out for a special night.

[Jonetta]

It was the time, almost 10:00 pm, that felt off.

[Sharon]

Jonetta wrote: "It was the time, almost 10:00 pm, that felt off."

Yes but he was supposed to be there earlier, but got tied up at work.

[Jonetta]

This may be one of this examples where Bobby didn’t exercise good judgment. His heart’s in the right place, though.

[Sharon]

True

[~Melissa~]

I was definitely thinking the ex wife and boyfriend had something to do with it. I just didn't understand why you would agree to do hide and seek in the cornfield when you knew the lights we going to turn off soon. That seemed odd to me. The whole outing seemed odd. I felt sorry for Bobby, at this point, as he was only trying to follow through on something he promised his daughter - to take her to a corn maze.

[Sandra]

At this point, I suspected Mom and/or the boyfriend.

[Jonetta]

I wanted it to be them.