Janet Evanovich Book Group discussion

This topic is about
Tricky Twenty-Two
Stephanie Plum Series
>
Plum #22 (Tricky Twenty-Two)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Brittany
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Feb 16, 2015 09:57AM

reply
|
flag




Yes! Great plot ideas!


I would rather wait longer for a great book than have a mediocre one every year.



That's 20 years our time, book time seems to move slower. There are quantum physicists working on that puzzle as we speak!

I agree with you Anita. I'm okay with the lack of "growth". Technically every book almost picks up where the last left off. It's not like every book is a new year for her. You would think after 21 books I'd be tired of the same thing, but honestly I look forward to each book.

I guess all my reading is for joy and fun. I have enough drama in real life, I don't need it in books. That is just me, I understand that.


Yes and no. IMO, it's a fine line that needs to be walked. In books, tv, movies. Sequels (tv season renewals) happen for a reason. They work. People like something and they want MORE! However, they also don't want the exact same thing. They want familiar but with a hint of something. You know a blast of the 'new car smell' even if they are still driving their same old 1988 Honda Accord. Sometimes there literally is growth in that you watch a tv show or a movie series and you see the character go from a child to an adult (think any sitcom that ever start out with little kids, sometimes you just see character growth. In this I often think of shows like Buffy, Angel, Supernatural. They went from shows characters seemed kind of flat, but transformed into complex characters. You have to admit the Angel you saw at the start of his series (never mind how he was in Buffy) is quite different from the one who said he always wanted to slay a dragon in the final episode of the series.
That being said, I think the same holds true in books, to a certain degree. With some of these characters (who often we come to think we know of as almost family) we spent a ton of time with, go on countless adventures. Often they change as well. I can help but consider how Eddie Dean is in Drawing of the Three and how he is by the time we reach the final book in the Dark Tower series. The trials and tribulations our favorite literary characters go through often changes them, it has to. It's kind of needs to. Character arch and all that.
However, I don't think it needs to be radical, and honestly when it comes to books that are humor focused I don't think it really should. Look at sitcoms, characters really don't make major changes. And secretly (or not so secretly) we don't want them to change. Would we really want Steph to learn through all her bumblings, become 'competent' at taking down perps? She wouldn't be the same character, which might be fine for a different type of series. I don't mind a little growth in my comical characters, but seriously when Jerry's door flies open and Kramer steps in I was always thrilled to see or hear him say something completely insane. Giddy up! That same holds true for Stephenie. She's a reliable friend. When I need a laugh and a break from reality, I know I can grab the next book, see her car get destroyed, Lula threaten to shoot someone with a giant gun, and watch them stumble along until they catch their man/woman/whatever. Am I like others a bit tired of the Morelli/Ranger thing? Yeah, maybe. I imagine Janet could come up with some insanity if she were to have her get engaged to one or the other, but in the end I'm fine if she never chooses.
I consider these books to be like sitcoms, I kind of check my logical brain at the door (which please don't take to be an insult, I strive for this in some of my own writing) and merely sit back and enjoy. I have plenty of other series I read that are serious, that seem massive character change.
Plus as I mentioned (and others did as well) in this thread and perhaps a few other threads, we really don't have a real clear idea of how much time has gone by in Steph's universe. People are slow to change, so if all this insanity has happened over only a couple of years, then her having no serious discernible growth isn't that bit a deal to me.
wow, sorry to ramble on so long!



If the books had been written in a series of adventures without showing the passage of time then I could see how you could just enjoy the books, ala Sherlock Holmes or Hardy boys, without feeling the need to see character development. But when you have some of the characters moving forward and the main character not it starts to feel disjointed. Stephanie almost comes off as juvenile.
I absolutely loved the first nine books. There were actual scary moments offset by the hilarity of the writing and the plots. Now it just seems like the plots are recycled, friend or family is accused of murder, Stephanie gets the crap beat out of her after doing something incredibly stupid and then sleeps with Joe or Ranger or both.
Perhaps, I just invested too much in these books because I loved these characters so much I wanted to see a progression in the stories. I think I will be following a previous commenters advice and wait until the end to see who and where she ends up and skip the next few books.
Brittany wrote: "It was posted on JE's Facebook and Twitter pages that the book will be published November 17, 2015 and that the title should be released sometime this week (the week of 2/16). I'm personally bummed..."
Didn't know new one is coming out.
Didn't know new one is coming out.





Stephanie Plum might not be the world’s greatest bounty hunter, but she knows when she’s being played. Ken Globovic (aka Gobbles), hailed as the Supreme Exalted Zookeeper of the animal house known as Zeta fraternity, has been arrested for beating up the dean of students at Kiltman College. Gobbles has missed his court date and gone into hiding. People have seen him on campus, but no one will talk. Things just aren’t adding up, and Stephanie can’t shake the feeling that something funny is going on at the college—and it’s not just Zeta fraternity pranks.
As much as people love Gobbles, they hate Doug Linken. When Linken is gunned down in his backyard it’s good riddance, and the list of possible murder suspects is long. The only people who care about finding Linken’s killer are Trenton cop Joe Morelli, who has been assigned the case, security expert Ranger, who was hired to protect Linken, and Stephanie, who has her eye on a cash prize and hopefully has some tricks up her sleeve.









Be sure to post your review. I am interested to see how the dire=hard faithful like this book.

I get what you say about the old I Love Lucy series. No, Lucy never did "grow up". I don't expect that Steph will ever change either. Frankly, I don't care. I just want a book with a funny, sexy, some mystery plot.

Exactly, as long as I'm entertained, I'm happy.

Link your review. I really want to see what everyone thinks of the book. I got my e-book from the library today so I will start after Church and the grandkids go home.

My Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

I like both Ranger and Morelli, but I think Stephanie and him need to stop at some point acting like they're still in their early twenties and grow up. They don't have to get married and have kids and everything right now, but they don't even seem able to have a series discussion, or hold one. They don't even live together, aside when Stephanie had to stay there for awhile, but enjoys her independence or whatever too much, or they have a fight and neither can deal so one or the other walks out.



Also she needs to stop rewriting the back story to every character in every book. Seriously a good 1/3 of the book is now exactly the same every single time.
I understand that in a series you need to 'hook' on new readers and let them know some of the background, but this is book 22 - who picks up a book at 22 without reading any previous ones? Plus the rest of us have all read it 21 times before...we know it! Stop repeating it word for word.
Ugh every year I say I won't read another one, but I think this time is it. At least I didn't pay for the last ten or so, they've all been library books.



Books mentioned in this topic
Turbo Twenty-Three (other topics)One for the Money (other topics)
One for the Money (other topics)