Book Riot's Read Harder Challenge discussion

1887 views
2022 Read Harder Challenge > #4: Read a book in any genre by a POC that’s about joy and not trauma

Comments Showing 51-100 of 114 (114 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Regan (new)

Regan Slaughter | 46 comments Cato wrote: "Has anyone read Elatsoe, Klara and the Sun, Raybearer or Binti? Do any of these qualify for this task?"

I just finished Elatsoe! It was phenomenal, and definitely works for a book with an asexual or aromantic protagonist, but I don't think it works very well for this prompt. There are elements of joy in it, but a lot of the central conflict is on both personal and racial trauma.


message 52: by Simone (new)

Simone (simonec75) I think I'll go with middle grade for this one. I chose: Where the Mountain Meets the Moon


message 53: by Cato (new)

Cato (cato-the-cactus) Regan wrote: "Cato wrote: "Has anyone read Elatsoe, Klara and the Sun, Raybearer or Binti? Do any of these qualify for this task?"

I just finished Elatsoe!..."


Thank you for replying and sharing your opinion. I will definitely read Elatsoe at some point. Has anyone read the other books mentioned and can tell me if they fit the task?


message 54: by Kari (new)

Kari | 32 comments Cato wrote: "Regan wrote: "Cato wrote: "Has anyone read Elatsoe, Klara and the Sun, Raybearer or Binti? Do any of these qualify for this task?"

I..."


I read Binti, and it really depends on your interpretation of "joy"? It definitely has a lot of trauma and pain, and some of that is tied up in the racial politics of the protagonist's world. But there's also an undercurrent of joy/elation/pride that she takes in her unique abilities, and that was fun to read. I'm struggling with my own interpretation of this prompt, so I hope that helps you decide.


message 55: by Maura (new)

Maura Curran | 21 comments Kari wrote: "Cato wrote: "Regan wrote: "Cato wrote: "Has anyone read Elatsoe, Klara and the Sun, Raybearer or Binti? Do any of these qualify for t..."

I wouldn't count Binti for this prompt since it specifies joy and NOT trauma - like Kari said, there's a good amount of joy and pride in Binti but also trauma. The later books in the trilogy highlight the trauma aspect (as well as the pride and growing into herself elements).

I wouldn't count Raybearer either, though I loved it as a book.

I loved Elatsoe but agree with Regan that it counts for other prompts (e.g. #11, asexual MC) but not for this one.

Haven't read Klara and the Sun.


message 56: by Tricia (new)

Tricia (books2hooks) | 80 comments Cato wrote: "Has anyone read Elatsoe, Klara and the Sun, Raybearer or Binti? Do any of these qualify for this task?"

I read Klara and the Sun and it isn't about joy. It's a beautiful story about an AF (artificial friend) and her person. But a large part of the book deals with illness, the struggles kids go through, and the separation that comes when children grow up and leave their toys behind. I don't think it would count.


message 57: by Cato (new)

Cato (cato-the-cactus) Thank you all for your help!


message 58: by Roman (new)

Roman Colombo | 10 comments I was going to reread The Bride Was a Boy, but I kept seeing Bingo Love and it looks delightful.


message 59: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie | 13 comments I started the year with World of Wonders by Aimee Nezhukumatathil. Was beautiful. Fits here.

Also how do you all get these books recs to be links and look nice?


message 60: by Lauraellen (new)

Lauraellen | 40 comments Stephanie wrote: "I started the year with World of Wonders by Aimee Nezhukumatathil. Was beautiful. Fits here.

Also how do you all get these books recs to be links and look nice?"

Hi Stephanie, I think you can only do it on the desktop site, not the app - when I'm on the computer I can click a little tag that says "add book/author" that isn't there when on your phone. I think you could probably use html to do it on the phone but that is beyond me, sorry.


message 61: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie | 13 comments Lauraellen wrote: "Stephanie wrote: "I started the year with World of Wonders by Aimee Nezhukumatathil. Was beautiful. Fits here.

Also how do you all get these books recs to be links and look nice?"
Hi Stephanie, I ..."


Gotcha. I figured it may a limit in the app. Maybe I'll post from my PC here from now on. I've noticed I"m more likely to check a book rec when I can click through to it's page. Thanks for the info.


message 62: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca Huerta | 126 comments I am going with the NY Public Library recommendation of Yoke: My Yoga of Self-Acceptance by Jessamyn Stanley. The audiobook is great!


message 64: by Nid (new)

Nid | 13 comments does the sun is also a star by Nicola yoon count?


message 65: by Nisha (new)

Nisha (therootedreader) | 6 comments Would either Cemetery Boys or Light from Uncommon Stars work for this prompt?


message 66: by Elin (new)

Elin | 6 comments Lisa wrote: "Would The Girl Who Saved the King of Sweden work for this one?"

Sadly, no. The author Jonas Jonasson is very white. It's a very funny book though, perfect beach read.


message 67: by [deleted user] (new)

I Can’t Think Straight by Shamim Sarif


message 68: by Caroline (new)

Caroline Builta (carolinerose-reads) | 21 comments Alex wrote: "I'm so late but I'll finally read the Brown Sisters trilogy by Talia Hibbert :)" Oh, I think this is going to be mine as well!!!


message 69: by Regan (new)

Regan Slaughter | 46 comments Nisha wrote: "Would either Cemetery Boys or Light from Uncommon Stars work for this prompt?"

I think Cemetery Boys would be pretty questionable, since a whole lot of it is trauma, but Light from Uncommon Stars would be a great pick! (It's also a great book!)


message 70: by Cato (new)

Cato (cato-the-cactus) I will read Light from Uncommon Stars then.


message 71: by Caroline (new)

Caroline Builta (carolinerose-reads) | 21 comments I’ve switched my pick to The Fastest Way to Fall.


message 72: by Jaime (new)

Jaime | 4 comments Would Instructions for Dancing fit here? I am thinking yes, but wondering if someone who has read it can confirm.


message 74: by Takako (new)

Takako | 1 comments I bought Pride by Ibi Bozoi a while back - it's a contemporary retelling of Pride and Prejudice. I started it but haven't gone back to it (it happens!). Would this qualify?


message 75: by Jess (new)

Jess (jessefozbom) | 18 comments Anyone read Queenie by Candice Carty-Williams? Would it fit this prompt? I'm trying to find a synopsis without spoilers, and have seen it described as joyous, but not sure the focus is on joy...


message 76: by Milena (new)

Milena (milenas) | 104 comments Jess wrote: "Anyone read Queenie by Candice Carty-Williams? Would it fit this prompt? I'm trying to find a synopsis without spoilers, and have seen it described as joyous, but not sure the focus is on joy..."

It doesn't, sorry to say. Lots of trauma.


message 77: by Juulna (new)

Juulna | 14 comments Lotsa SFF doesn’t ignore it but it isn’t the focus by far. I mean, unless you’re Octavia Butler. 😅 I love her though.


message 78: by Juulna (new)

Juulna | 14 comments Also, actually, I read A Master of Djinn and it was glorious and very filled with hope looking forward.


message 79: by Ron (new)

Ron I seriously don't know where to start with this one.

Which nonfiction book out there has pure joy in it?


message 80: by Sneha (new)

Sneha Bhattacharjee (snehabhattacharjee) | 1 comments Swing Time by Zadie Smith. I will read this for this prompt


message 81: by Milena (new)

Milena (milenas) | 104 comments Ron wrote: "I seriously don't know where to start with this one.

Which nonfiction book out there has pure joy in it?"


How about The Book of Joy: Lasting Happiness in a Changing World?


message 82: by Ron (new)

Ron Milena wrote: "Ron wrote: "I seriously don't know where to start with this one.

Which nonfiction book out there has pure joy in it?"

How about [book:The Book of Joy: Lasting Happiness in a Changing World|29496..."


Thanks.


message 83: by Julie (new)

Julie (jehart904) | 5 comments Here's a listopia for this prompt, hope it's helpful to some!

https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/1...


message 84: by Blake (new)

Blake | 18 comments I’m reading “Get A Life, Chloe Brown” and i don’t think i will finish it. I actually really enjoyed the first three quarters, but now i’m just bored.


message 85: by Beth (new)

Beth (drippingfaucet) | 13 comments Takako wrote: "I bought Pride by Ibi Bozoi a while back - it's a contemporary retelling of Pride and Prejudice. I started it but haven't gone back to it (it happens!). Would this qualify?"

Yes! There's discussion of gentrification but it's overall a lighthearted romance in the vein of the original.


message 86: by Mandie (new)

Mandie (mystickah) | 218 comments Mandie wrote: "I'm thinking of conquering Taste Makers: Seven Immigrant Women Who Revolutionized Food in America for this."

After reading this, I don't think it fits this prompt as well as I thought it would.


message 87: by Biana (new)

Biana I read The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek
The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek by Kim Michele Richardson
It was an amazing book that I'm going to recommend for ages still. I sent my mother a copy.

Yes, it's about being a POC and it's full of sorrows and pain and regrets as well as joy and happiness. But that's life, isn't it? It was more about the life of this blue woman of Kentucky.

Yes, blue. I Googled it.


message 88: by C. S. (new)

C. S. (c_s_rambo) | 7 comments M wrote: "I feel like I'll Be the One is just pure joy."

Thanks for this, I just got it from the library and it looks like so much fun!


message 89: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth (elizabethlk) | 365 comments I finally got to With the Fire on High, so I'm counting it for this (and loved it, especially as an audiobook). I'm also reading and loving Act Your Age, Eve Brown right now, but I finished the other first.


message 90: by Ron (new)

Ron I'm trying to find nonfiction books that fit this genre but it's kind of hard to find any that work.


message 91: by Jess (new)

Jess (jessefozbom) | 18 comments Anyone read Klara and thge Sun who can tell me if it fits this prompt?


message 92: by Bonnie G. (new)

Bonnie G. (narshkite) | 1413 comments Jess wrote: "Anyone read Klara and thge Sun who can tell me if it fits this prompt?"

Klara and the Sun is definitely not about joy.


message 93: by Jess (new)

Jess (jessefozbom) | 18 comments Thanks. It's really hard to find this one prompt without spoilers!


message 94: by Bonnie G. (new)

Bonnie G. (narshkite) | 1413 comments Jess wrote: "Thanks. It's really hard to find this one prompt without spoilers!"

No problem, its definitely a bleak view of the future, regardless of how specific storylines turn out. I read Xeni if you like romance, it was pretty fun. I often read more than one book per prompt, and I am also considering

Music Is History
My Year Abroad and
The Son of Mr. Suleman: A Novel


message 95: by Jess (new)

Jess (jessefozbom) | 18 comments I think I've settled on Mr Loverman by Bernadette Evaristo. I'm still going to read Klara and the Sun too anyway, because I'm getting it for my birthday on Friday!


message 96: by Jess (new)

Jess (jessefozbom) | 18 comments Autocorrect! *Bernadine


message 97: by Suzanne (new)

Suzanne Ron wrote: "I'm trying to find nonfiction books that fit this genre but it's kind of hard to find any that work." The Book of Delights by Ross Gay was pretty joyful.


message 98: by Bonnie G. (new)

Bonnie G. (narshkite) | 1413 comments Jess wrote: "I think I've settled on Mr Loverman by Bernadette Evaristo. I'm still going to read Klara and the Sun too anyway, because I'm getting it for my birthday on Friday!"

I was looking at Mr. Leverman too - I loved her last book. Hope you enjoy!


message 99: by Hannah (new)

Hannah Matsubara | 18 comments Yearning by Bell Hooks


message 100: by t ♡ (new)

t ♡ (pearlescence) | 14 comments I read Mr Loverman which was delightful! (LGBTQ+, BIPOC rep)


back to top