On The Same Page discussion
2022 Independent Challenges
>
Ioana's 2022 Independent Challenge




I hope to eventually read that book, but, like you, I've read a lot from the WW2 genre and in these times, it reminds me how little we humans learn at all.

This book (I mean the original one) was different, and a 5 star for me. Not about the Nazis and the French resistance, not about the Nazis and the Jews, but about people from Lithuania and how Russians treated them during and after the war, during the Stalin repression and their Siberia deportation. These were not war enemies...
Highly recommended.


Woohoo! This is one of my absolute favorites. So glad you enjoyed it 😀
Ioana wrote: "Book #19 of 2022: The Rook. Fantasy, not my go-to genre, this was fun and thoroughly enjoyable. Thank you Alondra for recommending it, I need to get #2 in this series, in preparatio..."
I loved the TV series. I've got both books awaiting my attention.
I loved the TV series. I've got both books awaiting my attention.

I watch so little TV...I had no idea there was a series. When?

It took me a while, but I got to it eventually 🤣

I watched the TV series unaware it was based on a book. Was released in 2019

This is on my TBR list- should I bump it up?
Alondra picks usually get bumped up since she knows what she's talking about ;-)

Alondra picks usually get bumped up since she knows what she's talking about ;-)."
I would say 'yes'. There's little fantasy that I enjoy, but this book was one of them. Fresh concept, lots of fun, yes, read it!

Glad you enjoyed it Ioana. The Rook is terrific.

Did you read the next one, Stiletto?

Did you read the next one, Stiletto?"
I did. It was also a strong book and I enjoyed it but not quite as much. The second book changed narrators and I missed the old one.

A lot of time the 2nd book is not as strong as the 1st one. But hey, a 3rd one is coming out this year!
Desley (Cat fosterer) wrote: "Bill wrote: "Ioana wrote: "Book #19 of 2022: The Rook. Fantasy, not my go-to genre, this was fun and thoroughly enjoyable. Thank you Alondra for recommending it, I need to get #2 in..."
Same here
Same here

There is hope in the end, the community gets smarter, acquires knowledge and gathers the will and means to stand up for what's right, for their land and way of living, but this was not easy fight. A book that rings trues and poses lots of questions, I think it would be a great book club read. 3 stars.

On the TBR. Glad to see it is a challenging read.

I think you would like it, the audiobook is excellent.


They are both good, for different reasons, different moods and different purposes. No reason why you can't/shouldn't read them both :-)

Book #22 of 2022: A Drink Before the War. Another good first in the series (also a mystery), Dennis Lehane does not disappoint. Interesting characters and back stories, looking forward to the next one. 3 stars.
Ioana wrote: "Books #21 of 2022: Every Dead Thing. I enjoyed this mystery, but not as much as I thought I would, but enough to make me read the next one in the series. It was my first John Connolly..."
I've only read one Connolly so far too. I do want to explore more.
I've only read one Connolly so far too. I do want to explore more.

That cover is haunting"
I know, right? Have you read her Behold the Dreamers? Very good, too.

Book #24 of 2022: The Death of Vivek Oji. Recommended by Veronica, this was a very good one. We know from the title and the first few lines that Vivek is dead and the entire book, told in several voices (mother, cousin, friends) is the way we find out why and how. This book touches on so many subjects, love, identity, understanding, acceptance, friendship, it would make a great book club read and I'm sure would spark interesting discussions. If you can, get the audiobook, it's wonderfully narrated. 4 very well deserved stars, recommended.

Book #24 of 2022: The Death of Vivek Oji. Recommen..."
I haven't read Salem's Lot but don't feel bad about not liking it. I catorgorize all Stephen King books into Great King, Good King or Bad King. I don't know what it is but sometimes I really don't like one of his books - so Bad King. I think Good King and Great King vary from person to person. For instance, if you want another very unpopular opinion, the entire Dark Tower series is for me Bad King. Sorry! On the other hand, The Shawshank Redemption - Great King.

Michelle wrote: "I haven't read Salem's Lot but don't feel bad about not liking it. I catorgorize all Stephen King books into Great King, Good King or Bad King. I don't know what it is but sometimes I really don't like one of his books - so Bad King. I think Good King and Great King vary from person to person. For instance, if you want another very unpopular opinion, the entire Dark Tower series is for me Bad King. Sorry! On the other hand, The Shawshank Redemption - Great King.."
I love this Michelle! He's such a prolific writer that categorizing his work that way makes sense. And, it's great because it's different for each of us. Great King for me would be 11/22/63, Good King is The Shining and Bad King The Dark Towers (sorry Alondra!!)- only read the first one but I'm pretty sure I won't revisit the series.

Michelle wrote: "I haven't read Salem's Lot but don't feel bad ab..."
11/22/63 would definitely be Great King for me too. It is Good King but the ending is Bad King. I have theories about why his work is this way for me but I think you hit on one theory. He has written so much they can't all be winners. I will say though he is a wonderful story teller and when he is really trying his writing is amazing.

I so much agree with this, and your split: great, good, bad. It applies to how I feel about his books, too. 11/22/63 is definitely great, probably my favorite. That, and Shawshank Redemption. And The Green Mile.


Yeah, me too...both in the "bad" category... I think we should both run now.


I was afraid I'd be alone here...too bad neither of you enjoyed IT (how did you feel about 'Salem's Lot?), but good to have company 🙂

I gave it three stars, so Good King for me. Not Great King. I totally agreed with your assessment. :-)
Lea wrote: "I'll join you both in putting It in the Bad King category. It is my least favorite King book thus far. It's so unfortunate, it is a favorite for so many, but I'm glad that Desley and ..."
I think it depends what you want from King; downright horror or something more. I tend to like his early more basic horror; Cujo, The Shining, etc. I do like others like The Green Mile, The Gunslinger books, The Stand but some like Rose Madder, The Dark Half, Dolores Claiborne, Gerald's Game (his middlish period I guess) left me cold and kind of turned me off reading anymore of his books. I have tried a few of his latest books, still kind of on the cusp (no, there is a proper expression here which escapes me this morning) with him right now. I've got a few on my shelf to explore.
I think it depends what you want from King; downright horror or something more. I tend to like his early more basic horror; Cujo, The Shining, etc. I do like others like The Green Mile, The Gunslinger books, The Stand but some like Rose Madder, The Dark Half, Dolores Claiborne, Gerald's Game (his middlish period I guess) left me cold and kind of turned me off reading anymore of his books. I have tried a few of his latest books, still kind of on the cusp (no, there is a proper expression here which escapes me this morning) with him right now. I've got a few on my shelf to explore.

For me, it's all a mix. My favorite book by King is The Shining, but I also loved 11/22/63, The Stand, Misery, Under the Dome, Mr. Mercedes trilogy, The Institute, Everything's Eventual. I ended up liking the Dark Tower series, but I did not enjoy the first book, The Gunslinger. I wonder if I might like it more now that I've read the entire series. But It was the worst for me, that's one I won't re-read. :-)

My least favourite (that I generally get the title wrong of!) is The Girl who Loved Tom Gordon.

Interesting question, Bill. Definitely not downright horror, just a good story that moves, with interesting characters. I just checked, I've read 30 of SK's books...and there are a lot more on my TBR. Some I loved, so I thought were very good, some ok, some did not like.
But with so many books that are so different, it's just natural that different books appeal to different readers. I'll keep reading them 🙂

Lea, I haven't read all of these, but the ones I've read were all 4 or 5 stars, so I totally agree with your list. I must put the others on my TBR, if they are not already: Misery, The Institute, Everything's Eventual.
I agree about The Gunslinger, but I enjoyed the rest of the series (mostly). Song of Susannah dragged a little bit too much...

I haven't read that one...yet. I try to do a couple SK every year, and I still have a lot. According to this list, there are 94 novels and novellas: https://www.hookedtobooks.com/the-com...

Good to know, that one is not even on my TBR, so let's keep it that way. Thank you!
Ioana wrote: "Book #23 of 2022: 'Salem's Lot. Unpopular opinion...it was ok, definitely not my favorite SK. I'll run and hide now.
Book #24 of 2022: The Death of Vivek Oji. Recommen..."
Seriously??? *sigh*.... probably the only book that still creeps me out. Don't worry, I shall find something else to recommend. 😈
Book #24 of 2022: The Death of Vivek Oji. Recommen..."
Seriously??? *sigh*.... probably the only book that still creeps me out. Don't worry, I shall find something else to recommend. 😈

Keep recommending books, you're good at it, you little 😈
Ioana wrote: "Yeah, I had a feeling you'd say that. Sorry, it did not work for me, but with very few exceptions, SK was an unexpected (good) surprise for me. I was afraid of him and I started reading him because..."
Hehehehehe... do NOT encourage me. 🤔😏😏
Hehehehehe... do NOT encourage me. 🤔😏😏
Books mentioned in this topic
The Lightning Rod (other topics)The Lightning Rod (other topics)
Fever Dream (other topics)
Fever Dream (other topics)
Carrion Comfort (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Richard Bachman (other topics)Susanna Kearsley (other topics)
LOL, working on in...but still looking for that rare 5 stars one.