Historical Romance Book Club discussion

How to Train Your Viscount (The Astley Chronicles, #1)
This topic is about How to Train Your Viscount
63 views
Gaol/BOTM > BOTM 1 - October 2021 - How to Train Your Viscount

Comments Showing 51-74 of 74 (74 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Merry (last edited Oct 09, 2021 07:41AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Merry  (jewelhound) | 858 comments Nalambari I understand exactly what you mean about insta love or lust.
Chapter 28 (view spoiler)


Merry  (jewelhound) | 858 comments I just finished the book and can't improve on the review Lauren left above. Enjoyable and look forward to reading the next in the series. I


Sandra Moreira | 1122 comments Mod
Lauren, we eat codfish at 24th dinner, not in all of Portugal, some places eat octopus. At 25th we eat baked turkey and in same places a kind of lamb. I don't mind very much because I'm not a fried cakes kind of person.


message 54: by Susan (last edited Oct 10, 2021 03:00PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susan | 853 comments Mod
That was an easy and fun read. The banter was witty - which I always enjoy; and there were interesting side characters. However it was a bit too slap stick and predictable for me to rate it too highly, and I suspect it will be quickly forgotten.

I think the author shows promise and I would consider reading the next in the series - hopefully the next novel will have a bit more depth. She has introduced a few interesting side characters for future novel development.

...and....two such beautiful privleged, kind, intelligent people as the H and h....I like a few more flaws


Sandra Moreira | 1122 comments Mod
What I really miss it's the Convent sweets and cakes, that is my kind of Xmas desserts!


Sandra Moreira | 1122 comments Mod
I did liked the book, but I didn't like very much the modern sex talk of the couple, but in a way I understand the way the things went and how far and fast they went, they were talking about what each one would like and like to do to the other, so I suppose it was natural to happen that way. On the contrary I don't understand very well how the same happens in other books with not having this kind of talk between the couple.


message 57: by Ida (new)

Ida (ida_my) | 62 comments Read it some week ago, and found it to be quite entertaining and fun. But I already had to read some of your comments to remember the plot... I think I'm mixing it ut with a Meredith Duran book about a father that has an obsession with Egypt :)


Mamacita aka MawMaw  (mamawantsbedtimestory) | 417 comments Mama's always late to the party but...




message 59: by Jan (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jan (jan130) | 2707 comments I'm sorry to say I have given up at 53% and dnf'ed. The sex scene was completely unconvincing to me. A sweet, gently-raised, innocent young lady just would not have behaved that way on her first experience, and also the sex talk was too modern. Just nope, nope, nope.

The book just wasn't working for me and I decided to stop wasting my time, and try another one of the BOTMs instead. It's good some of you are clearly enjoying/have enjoyed the book, but we all have different tastes, and this book just isn't for me.


Mamacita aka MawMaw  (mamawantsbedtimestory) | 417 comments I never made it past Ch 7. I just could not get into it. IDK what my problem was.


Mamacita aka MawMaw  (mamawantsbedtimestory) | 417 comments Susan wrote: "That was an easy and fun read. The banter was witty - which I always enjoy; and there were interesting side characters. However it was a bit too slap stick and predictable for me to rate it too hig..."

I will go back to it later cause I love me some witty banter. That's one of my favorite things but I just couldn't get into the mystery of the Stolen artifacts.


message 62: by Missy (new) - rated it 1 star

Missy | 1488 comments My problem is that I prefer audiobooks to ebooks so I'm making slow progress reading this ebook. Another problem is that it's not really catching my interest but now that I'm in chapter 11 and they'd agreed to work together, I'm hoping for more scenes with them and things will start getting interesting.


message 63: by Jultri (last edited Oct 19, 2021 05:34AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jultri | 409 comments Merry Jewelhound wrote: "Chapter 13 does anyone think that Caro's parents would leave her alone in the house with just the servants?"

Agree, the second half lost me. As Jan said, there were a lot of things that were a bit of a stretch and Henry, I just wanted to knock some sense into him. (view spoiler) Overall, I think this author has great potential but maybe a 3/5 for this book? On a positive note, how great was Fanny's character?!


Merry  (jewelhound) | 858 comments @Jultri I think your spoiler is very valid. I enjoyed the authors writing. I just think she needs to pick an era. Historical or fantasy or modern. BUT the trend for mixing all of the above though is here. Netflix Bridgertons has done so.


Jultri | 409 comments Merry Jewelhound wrote: "@Jultri I think your spoiler is very valid. I enjoyed the authors writing. I just think she needs to pick an era. Historical or fantasy or modern. BUT the trend for mixing all of the above though i..."

True. Netflix's Bridgertons worked because it was a visual treat and hey, we all want to see more of Regé-Jean Page, so the sex scenes were not at all gratuitous! :) I think when it comes to books, those of us who have read HRs for many years are a bit more particular and protective of the 'authenticity' of the genre.


Merry  (jewelhound) | 858 comments Jultri wrote: "Merry Jewelhound wrote: "@Jultri I think your spoiler is very valid. I enjoyed the authors writing. I just think she needs to pick an era. Historical or fantasy or modern. BUT the trend for mixing ..."

I do agree having the visuals make a big difference. I prefer old school HR.


Lady Nilambari Reads HR (ladynilambari) | 160 comments Jultri wrote: "Merry Jewelhound wrote: "Chapter 13 does anyone think that Caro's parents would leave her alone in the house with just the servants?"

Agree, the second half lost me. As Jan said, there were a lot ..."


Ohhhh Franny deserved a medal! I gave her an honourable mention in my review!


message 68: by Milly Jane (last edited Oct 21, 2021 12:36PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Milly Jane Maven | 32 comments This was such a fun book. Rom-com and Regency, my favorite combination. I was frustrated by Henry's refusal to tell the truth at times, but he did redeem himself, his father was a complete total jerk, but was dealt with kindly but appropriately (for his era) in the end. Like many others have mentioned, I really liked Fanny the maid, and Billy the tiger was funny.
The next installment centers upon Anne, Caro's sister but I hope there will be a story involving Lord Graverley in the future.


message 69: by Missy (last edited Oct 22, 2021 09:09PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Missy | 1488 comments I'm at the 56% (Chapter 19) (view spoiler)


Lauren | 1430 comments I thought so too. She gets her first kiss then an hour later......


Merry  (jewelhound) | 858 comments Milly I also enjoyed the maid and Missy agree with your spoiler.


message 72: by Missy (new) - rated it 1 star

Missy | 1488 comments So back in chapter 6, when Caroline had male callers. (view spoiler) I hope Graverley gets his own book, too.


message 73: by Missy (last edited Nov 02, 2021 02:38PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Missy | 1488 comments Just like the other BOTM for October, (The Gentle Art of Fortune Hunting), I forced myself to finish this book because she's a new-to-me author. I couldn't connect with the characters. Their behaviors and language were too modern for me. Any other time, I probably would have DNF'd the book. The sneak peek at Anne's book has me intrigued, so I will be reading her book when it's released.


message 74: by Joanna Loves Reading, Bluestocking of HR novels (new) - added it

Joanna Loves Reading (joannalovesreading) | 4120 comments Mod
I did not get a start on this book but maybe my reading speed will pick up again soon.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top