The Hobbit, or There and Back Again question

Gandalf. Obviously. Dumbledore died.... And STAYED DEAD. Gandalf died.... And DIDN'T STAY DEAD.
There are many more things I could say, but this is the most important one.

Gandalf is the superior because he is a maiar. A half god. No offense Dumbledore but he is just a normal wizard there is nothing special about him that nobody else have. All are wizards in the world of harry potter. In the world of Tolkien there are only five and Gandalf is one of them. A half god vs a normal magician = winner: the half god.

Is this going to happen in the online book club?? I didn't see anything about it there... https://www.readingbetweenthewinesboo...

Please post a link! I want to join in, or at least read along!

Gandalf is way better than dumbledore, that's just my opinion though

dumbledore because he took on so many more bad guys and he is special within the special where as gandalf is just a wizzard I here by stand that dumbledore being reconized as the best by his equels not non wizzards shows that he is more powerful