Question K

[Jonetta]

Kim and her team believed Carl Wilkes, one of the brothers responsible for the shelters’ general maintenance, was the killer. We’re you swayed by that red herring, too? If so, why? Did you ever suspect Nigel?

[Lisa - (Aussie Girl)]

The red herring definitely reeled me in. I suppose it was too obvious, I never twigged to Nigel at all.

[Jonetta]

Oh, I bit! Nigel never crossed my mind, either. I even suspected Louella before even thinking of him.

[~Teresa]

Never suspected Nigel, at all! However, Carl seemed to obvious.

[Charlene]

Yes, I still have a fishy taste in my mouth on this one!

[Jonetta]

Hahaha!!!

[Sharon]

I never suspected Nigel. I was sure Carl was the murderer.

[Sandra]

I didn't suspect Nigel at all. I don't think clues were set up to lead to him. But I knew it wouldn't be Carl...too obvious.

[Lynn]

Charlene wrote: "Yes, I still have a fishy taste in my mouth on this one!"

I agree, Charlene. This red herring was pushed pretty hard.

[Robin]

I was lured into the whole Marianne/Carl thing. I thought she was asking him to kill these pedophiles. Nigel never crossed my mind.

[Lisa - (Aussie Girl)]

Looks like we all got sucked in to the red herring.

[Jonetta]

Yep!

[Lynn]

This red herring is going to make me skeptical of clues when we read on in the series.

[Robin]

I was actually happy with this red herring and the fact that I fell for it. Up until that point in the book, I loved the characters but thought the mystery/villain was too obvious. When it turned out that things weren't as they seemed and the killer was someone I hadn't even considered, I have the book 5 Stars. I love when an author can give us great characters and a twisty story where I'm surprised at the ending.

[Sharon]

I agree Robin. I like a good red herring.

[Brittany]

I never suspected Nigel at all!