EVERYONE Has Read This but Me - The Catch-Up Book Club discussion

Moby-Dick or, The Whale
This topic is about Moby-Dick or, The Whale
173 views
BUDDY READS > Moby-Dick or, the Whale - Buddy Read

Comments Showing 151-200 of 231 (231 new)    post a comment »

message 151: by Shaina (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shaina | 358 comments Frances wrote: "It's harder to draw the line when it comes to violence towards animals that we consume personally as food versus what we don't consume/utilize...."

Frances, I completely agree with you! I have never eaten something I have seen alive. I feel that we can be humane towards all livestock. I particularly dislike cruelty towards animals, in any form.

I was very upset when I first heard how "foie gras" was acquired. I try and stick to free range/farm products.


message 152: by Shaina (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shaina | 358 comments Nóri wrote: "Heaven have mercy on us all —Presbyterians and Pagans alike—for we are all somehow dreadfully cracked about the head, and sadly need mending."

Nori, I, too, was grinning when I read this. It makes so much sense, doesn't it?


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments Shaina wrote: "Frances wrote: "It's harder to draw the line when it comes to violence towards animals that we consume personally as food versus what we don't consume/utilize...."

Frances, I completely agree with..."


Dagnabbit! I just asked my daughter about foie gras now and she told me, so I looked it up! Gosh! I am so uneducated about food! I just found out about veal too! I don't eat these so I didn't know! Gosh!!!! I am appalled!!!


message 154: by Nóri (last edited Nov 24, 2020 05:09AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nóri | 39 comments Laura, about the secret part of the Town-Ho's story:

(view spoiler)


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments @Laura, @Adele, @Trisha, I came across a chat here dated Oct 30 for Middlemarch scheduling it for March! Whoops! I had gone through our old chats looking for the Audible link and came across it.

Anyways, we are to start in April, and Laura will set up a thread for us. I'm sorry if I have confused us all.


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Nóri wrote: "Laura, about the secret part of the Town-Ho's story:

I think it might be the part where Steelkilt was planning to murder Radney anyway, so Moby Dick killing him before he could was something like ..."


Thanks Nori - that makes sense! It's so helpful having everyone else's input!


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @Frances - I've set up threads for Gone with the Wind (Feb) and Middlemarch (April) in the Buddy reads discussion so we're ready to go! :)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments CHAPTER 70: The Sphinx - 72: The Monkey-Rope

More interesting insight into the whaling processes and another Moby Dick legend....among some other strangeness!

(view spoiler)

I love Ishmael's philosophical asides.


message 159: by Tr1sha (last edited Nov 25, 2020 12:48AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Tr1sha | 629 comments Shaina wrote: "@Frances, "As pretty as Melville's prose sounds, I find myself spacing out and wondering what it was that I just read" I face the same challenge. Quite often, I have to stop the audiobook and go ba..."

Shaina, I agree with you & Frances. I’m glad you said that, as I’m new to using audiobooks & thought it was that rather than the book itself that caused problems. Like you, I also read The Old Man and the Sea recently (for the second time) & enjoyed it. Your spoiler comment about it is perfect.


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments Trisha, I agree. Shaina contrasted it perfectly, didn't she? We should all read Old Man and the Sea at this point of the book.


message 161: by Laura (last edited Nov 25, 2020 03:01PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Thought this might be useful as a visual comparison:

FMIB 44647 Right Whale to Show Whalebone (1); Sperm Whale Showing Teeth (2)


message 162: by Laura (last edited Nov 25, 2020 03:08PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments CHAPTERS 73: Stubb and Flask Kill a Right Whale to 75: The Right Whale's Head

Some more whale anatomy and a bit of superstition.

(view spoiler)

Also I'm progressing through Old Man and the Sea and it's an interesting contrast.


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments Ch. 77 The Great Heidelberg Tun

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-L4...


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments Regarding The Old Man and the Sea, if you check out the Spoilers Thread, a member named Avni posted what I thought was a wonderful analysis of the novella.


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @Kaisser - thanks for the link
@Frances -thanks I'll check it out when I'm finished.

Chapter 76: The Battering Ram - 78: Cisterns & Buckets
(view spoiler)

So some more anatomy and a misadventure.
I love Queeqeg so much!


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Whale Head diagram:
Sperm whale head anatomy (skull cutaway)


message 167: by Frances (last edited Nov 26, 2020 07:04PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments Thank you for the diagrams/illustrations, Laura! This book would be so much easier to understand if they had them throughout. Rather than an audiobook, an instructional video would actually be best!!! I'm trying to describe to my daughter what medium I need to "read" Moby Dick in -as I'm listening to the Audible version, but have the book open, and am looking up illustrations also!!! This is so frustrating.

Mr.Heald talks too fast, and is at times not pronouncing words quite clearly enough, or some words are strange -so I still have to refer to the book, even if Audible is quite entertaining. The book has no illustrations. I need to look them up frequently. So, yes, definitely, an instructional video, as this book has recently been a how-to-be-a-successful-whaler, would be awesome medium to "read" Moby Dick. Ha ha 😅


message 168: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments Thanks for recommending The Old Man and the Sea


message 169: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments Chapters 76-78

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Kaisser wrote: "Chapters 76-78


I was so confused reading the first two chapters. I only began to understand the descriptions after I saw Laura's diagram. This book is humbling down my English pretty hard.

Melvi..."


I'm finding a lot of the language challenging! I've never had such a lits of new words to look up - admittedly some are whaling terms but definitely not all. I agree this was a very funny analogy - I wonder if it will be symbolic?


message 171: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments I find it almost eery how well the 3 chapter division works. It's been two "essay" chapters and one plot chapter per day for a while.


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @ Kaisser - yeah I hadn't noticed that but now that you mention it! I prefer the plot chapters to the essay ones!


message 173: by Laura (last edited Nov 28, 2020 03:09PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments CHAPTERS 79: The Praire - 84: Pitchpoling

(view spoiler)


message 174: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments Chapters 85 - 90

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @Kaisser - I totally agree!

Chapter 85: The Fountain - 90: Heads or Tails

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Chapters 91: The Pequod Meets the Rose-Bud - 93: The Castaway

A little more explanation and a little more action..

(view spoiler)


message 177: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments What do you think the rant at the end of Chapter 96: The Try-Works is about? I don't really see what he's trying to say


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Chapter 94: A Squeeze of the Hand - Chapter 96: The Try-Works

Some insights into more of the parts of the whale and a weird incident/warning?!

(view spoiler)

@Kaisser I wasn't sure what to think of that passage either - I found this link: https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/mobydi...
- an interesting interpretation?


message 179: by Shaina (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shaina | 358 comments Samuel wrote: "What do you think the rant at the end of Chapter 96: The Try-Works is about? I don't really see what he's trying to say"

I do use sparknotes as an accompanying guide for Moby Dick. I also found the link by @Laura helpful. Here is my understanding of Ishmael's rant.

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Hey Shaina,
I love your thoughts - thanks!

I also thought..
(view spoiler)


message 181: by Shaina (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shaina | 358 comments This makes sense, Laura. I think the same. To support your thought I'll share some interesting information:

In Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick (1851), Ishmael describes being on duty monitoring the pots of burning whale oil to fuel the Pequod. He becomes mesmerized by the fire, fearing the visions of “fiend shapes…capering half in smoke and half in fire,” which then “begat kindred visions in my soul” (354). He warns us, “Look not too long into the face of the fire, O man!” In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s short story “Ethan Brand” (1852), the titular character is a lime-burner who lived a “solitary and meditative life” monitoring the kiln fire, until one night he threw “his dark thoughts into the intense glow of its furnace, and melted them, as it were, into the one thought that took possession of his life” (422).

For those who want to read the entire article, here is the link.

https://my.vanderbilt.edu/themindfulp...


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments I'm running behind schedule. One of my kitties, Daryl, had to spend a few days at the Vet, so for several days my brain was mush and I couldn't read. He's back home so I was able to read 7 chapters today. I'm at Ch. 85 The Fountain


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @Frances -oh I'm sorry! I hope kitty is ok?!
You're catching up!


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Thanks @Shaina - I'll check out the article!


message 185: by Shaina (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shaina | 358 comments Frances, I love cats and can completely understand how it feels. I hope he is better now..meow


message 186: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments @Laura and @Shaina, love your interpretations. Perhaps we are reaching a turning point and we'll see more of Ahab soon? I really liked The Doubloon.

@Frances, best wishes for your kitty! Hope he gets well soon


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Chapter 97: The Lamp - Chapter 99: The Doubloon

Some more philosophical ruminations.

(view spoiler)


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments I'm catching up! I'm at Ch. 89. Schools and Schoolmasters

I just wanted to share some of my thoughts so far on Ch. 87 The Grand Armada etc.

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @ Frances - I totally agree re illustrations. There are so many vivid images mentioned that the possibility for diagrams and illustrations is huge!
I keep seeing this edition with Rockwell Kent illustrations and they look beautiful - although a physical copy seems to be a collectors item!
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Moby-Dick-Wh...


message 190: by Laura (last edited Dec 04, 2020 07:24AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments I found an article re illustrating Moby Dick:

https://www.apollo-magazine.com/herma...


message 191: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments @Frances, (view spoiler)


message 192: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments @Laura and @Frances, I agree so much about the illustrations. There is a lot of imagery that would make for beautiful pictures, (view spoiler), and some diagrams would be really helpful.


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Chapter 100: Leg and Arm - Chapter 102: A Bower in the Arcacides

An interesting encounter and some very different reactions to Moby Dick

(view spoiler)


message 194: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments Ch 103-105

(view spoiler)


message 195: by Samuel (new) - rated it 5 stars

Samuel (kaisserds) | 90 comments Ch 106-111
(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments I'm catching up!
Thoughts on Chapter 103:Measurements of the Whale Skeleton - Chapter 111: The Pacific

(view spoiler)


message 197: by Laura (last edited Dec 09, 2020 02:05AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments Chapter 112:The Blacksmith- 114:The Gilder

Some interesting chapters - Ahab's madness continues!

(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments How is everyone getting on? Who's still with us?
I think we've still got myself, Samuel, Frances and Shaina.
Good effort :)


Frances (francesperez) | 352 comments I'm still here! I'm stuck at Ch.93. The Castaway. I have to put all reading on hold for a few days. I've aggravated a neck injury. Aging sucks. Ha ha. 👵 I'll try to resume tomorrow. I'm going to finish this whale-of-a-book!

To my fellow readers: hold your books/mobile phones/ereaders up. Avoid reading with your chins down, and your books/mobiles/ereaders at chest level.

@Kaiser, I re-read Ch.81 The Pequod Meets The Virgin
(view spoiler)


Laura  (Reading is a Doing Word) (readingisadoingword) | 345 comments @Frances - Ooh a sore neck is the worst! I hope it eases off soon. I certainly read in some funny positions sometimes so I know how easy it is to get a crick or upset sth.
Sending get better thoughts:)


back to top