You'll love this one...!! A book club & more discussion
Off Topic Chat
>
Movies - What Have You Just Watched?

Has anyone else seen the movie?

I watched The Help for the first time a few nights ago and cried my eyes out for quite a significant portion of it. I loved the book when I read it last year and they did do a very good job with the film too. There were a few things left out but nothing major. My partner really liked it too




Has anyone else seen the movie?"
I saw the movie some time ago. Apparently, the movie portrayed Walt Disney as very cooperative, when in reality, he wasn't quite as sweet. But then, it was a Disney movie so who would expect otherwise?



Yes. I must agree. Add to that, that the starting point of the plot is scientifically completely wrong.




I agree, Janet, to both!

I really enjoyed the movie, but there is so much more depth to the book.


They looked very cute in the trailers I have seen for it too :) I'm not sure if I will go and see it. I might just wait for the DVD.


Oh, I was looking forward to Still Alice. :(
Has Paper Towns been released for anyone yet?



ceeeeg, could you elaborate more?? Like was it a good documentary? Where they as impartial as possible or at least backing up their claims with real info?? And did they make it over sensational?
I really liked the book and it's going to be a bit before I watch it due to not getting any HBO.

were they fair and impartial?...its a hard question to answer...i think it should rightfully be called an expose...i was unaware there was a book, but i am assuming, from the title, it was not favorable to the Scientology 'canon' or its practices...this documentary is not either...
the bulk of it is made up of high ranking members of the 'church' who have decamped and come out to speak up about the...
if a 1/4 of what they had to say is true?...it's horrifying and dangerous...i think the film is important to debunk and perhaps prevent others from falling into it in the future
also a lot of footage from inside the meetings they hold and of interviews previously given by T. Cruise and John T....they say they did repeatedly request fresh interviews, which they did not respond to...
so...i think they did an in depth investigation of the extant facts, interviewed key sources...as to whether they are reliable ones, i think one has to decide for themselves...

It sounds like the documentary did the same thing.
Scientology has always been a pretty curious religion and, like you say, even if only a little bit of it is true, it's still pretty disturbing.


ETA - I quit watching it because it was annoying me. I don't think that the way I worded it above made it clear that I quit watching it by "turning the channel".


I also have the second season of A Game of Thrones sitting on my table, but I want to read A Clash of Kings first.




Perhaps the people who didn't like the movie had already read the book. No matter how great a film, I've never seen a movie that's completely captured excellent prose. And Suite Francaise is really a gem of a book. Keep in mind it's been at least three years since I've read it, but I still remember her use of language. The way the author used sentence length to highlight details- long sentence with tons of commas and semicolons followed by a three or four word sentence.

My husband and I just finished up with season one of Outlander. We both liked it a lot, and will continue watching in season two.
I want to check out Wayward Pines when it starts soon.


Books mentioned in this topic
The Invisible Bridge (other topics)The Flight Portfolio (other topics)
A Man Called Ove (other topics)
A Man Called Ove (other topics)
We All Looked Up (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Agatha Christie (other topics)Agatha Christie (other topics)
Jessie Burton (other topics)
James S.A. Corey (other topics)
Nicholas Pileggi (other topics)
More...
What movie(s) have you just watched?