Burbank Book Club discussion

Searching for Sylvie Lee
This topic is about Searching for Sylvie Lee
22 views
Part 2

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Laura | 81 comments Is anyone through Part 2 yet?
I feel like there's just a lot being left unsaid. If only the characters would sit down and talk to each other, they wouldn't be in the messes they are in. Sylvie and Ma assume the worst of each other, Sylvie and Helena despise each other but they never actually talk, Sylvie and Amy are jealous of each other. I feel like we're supposed to feel sorry for Sylvie, but maybe she is just "secretive" and "difficult."
Thoughts? What are your feelings about Sylvie?


Arpi | 4 comments I am close to finishing part 2. All I can say is that the lack of communication among the relatives is an issue and everyone is vulnerable in its way, even Helena.


Melliott (goodreadscommelliott) | 12 comments Well, that's the thing about suspense and unreliable narrators...they have to prolong your ignorance in order to surprise you later. I am most curious about what the husband's been up to. Also, did anybody else pick up on a possible romantic vibe between Sylvie and the cousin?


message 4: by Anita (new)

Anita | 11 comments Is it weird that my favorite character is Estelle?? She brings some lightness to this heavy story. And I absolutely agree, there’s definitely much being left unsaid between the family members. Something I’m not picking up on though is jealousy between the sisters. They seem to adore each other (for different reasons) and speak highly of each other. What am I missing?


Melliott (goodreadscommelliott) | 12 comments Anita wrote: "Is it weird that my favorite character is Estelle?? She brings some lightness to this heavy story. And I absolutely agree, there’s definitely much being left unsaid between the family members. Some..."

I didn't see the jealousy either, Anita. They do both see something in the other that they feel they don't have within themselves, but it seems mostly wistfully admiring, to me.


Laura | 81 comments Maybe I read the jealousy wrong, but yes I’m definitely picking up a romantic vibe between Sylvie and Lukas, and a really creepy vibe between Willem and Sylvie.


Melliott (goodreadscommelliott) | 12 comments Laura wrote: "Maybe I read the jealousy wrong, but yes I’m definitely picking up a romantic vibe between Sylvie and Lukas, and a really creepy vibe between Willem and Sylvie."

Between Willem and EVERYBODY. Dude is creepy.


Melliott (goodreadscommelliott) | 12 comments I have finished the book and am dying to talk it over. When do we meet? Is it not going to be until the end of the month? If that's the case, I'd better make some notes. I will save my Goodreads review until after, so there are no spoilers.


Laura | 81 comments Thanks, yes, we probably won't meet until the first week of June just to give everyone a chance to finish. But I'm eager to discuss as well!


message 10: by Arpi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Arpi | 4 comments Melliott wrote: "I have finished the book and am dying to talk it over. When do we meet? Is it not going to be until the end of the month? If that's the case, I'd better make some notes. I will save my Goodreads re..."

I finished the book today. I expect to have a very interesting discussion with you all.


message 11: by Anita (new)

Anita | 11 comments I finished too! Look forward to getting the discussion date on my calendar 😊


back to top