Reading the 20th Century discussion
Archive
>
What books are you reading now? (2020)
message 801:
by
Susan
(new)
May 19, 2020 11:32PM

reply
|
flag
That's a nice way of reading Proust, Susan. I'm more impatient to find out how things develop - now on vol. 5 The Prisoner and love that we're back in the narrator's obsessive head. Oddly, the supposedly 'slow' parts of the sequence overall are the ones that I prefer. Have to smile that the narrator is just a smidgen away from becoming a pathological stalker!
Judy was responsible for my trying Proust. I am very thankful she gave me the literary 'push.' :)

I bought Proust when I was an undergrad but never got round to reading him till a year or two back when I did the first two volumes but then other stuff got in the way. It's definitely worked for me going back to him now since working from home and no commute has translated into extra reading time for me. We're clearly all different types of reader but pushing through the books in one go is working best for me - with two volumes to go, the end is in sight!
I did join one of the Year of Reading Proust groups, but I didn't keep up with the reading schedule. However, I did keep going and I really missed reading him, when I got to the end.
Susan wrote: "I really missed reading him, when I got to the end."
Yes, his prose is quite hypnotic, once you succumb to the flow.
Yes, his prose is quite hypnotic, once you succumb to the flow.

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I have begun Men at Arms by Evelyn Waugh. It is the first of the Sword of Honour Trilogy. Although fictional, it has to some extent autobiographical content. I am reading this b/c a number of group members have recommended it.
Susan wrote: "Judy was responsible for my trying Proust. I am very thankful she gave me the literary 'push.' :)"
I hadn't remembered that, Susan - I knew we read it at the same time though, and enjoyed our discussions! I was very glad to have read it too. :)
I hadn't remembered that, Susan - I knew we read it at the same time though, and enjoyed our discussions! I was very glad to have read it too. :)

I read Passing by Larsen and thought it was really good.
Chrissie wrote: "I have begun Men at Arms by Evelyn Waugh. It is the first of the Sword of Honour Trilogy. Although fictional, it has to some extent autobiographical content. I am reading this b/c a number of group members have recommended it."
Probably too late now Chrissie, however Sword of Honour was originally published as three separate volumes Men At Arms (1952), Officers and Gentlemen (1955), and Unconditional Surrender (1961)>
Waugh extensively revised these books to create a one-volume version 'Sword of Honour' in 1965, and it is this version that Waugh wanted people to read.
The Penguin Classics version of 'Sword of Honour', contains numerous informative and interesting footnotes and an introduction by Angus Calder, each time Waugh changed the text there is also a note. Most of sections that Waugh changed or removed was with a view to ensuring that his "hero" Guy Crouchback is perceived as more worldly and experienced than was the case in the original version of the books.
Probably too late now Chrissie, however Sword of Honour was originally published as three separate volumes Men At Arms (1952), Officers and Gentlemen (1955), and Unconditional Surrender (1961)>
Waugh extensively revised these books to create a one-volume version 'Sword of Honour' in 1965, and it is this version that Waugh wanted people to read.
The Penguin Classics version of 'Sword of Honour', contains numerous informative and interesting footnotes and an introduction by Angus Calder, each time Waugh changed the text there is also a note. Most of sections that Waugh changed or removed was with a view to ensuring that his "hero" Guy Crouchback is perceived as more worldly and experienced than was the case in the original version of the books.
The Reading Gods have smiled upon us and Proust has appeared as an Audible Deal of the Day - should anyone be interested. Details in the Audible Thread.

I knew the three had been published together in one, but not what you say here. So he wanted to make readers were less critical of Guy? Is this what you mean?
Could you fill me in on another thing? Is Waugh critical of the Catholic religion and / or the Roman Catholic Church? Clearly, he is critical of military powers.
I didn't have any other choice than to read each book separately, a rather typical phenomenon at Audible. I have purchased all three. I don't like the narrator--Christian Rodska. He over-dramatizes, which is to say he exaggerates to make sure the listener understands what the author's words imply. The result is you have to hear disagreeable people screeching. Part of the fun of reading a book is analyzing the author's words. I don't like this being spelled out through a narrator's interpretation..... and sometimes narrators get it all wrong.

Are you interested in a funny story. When I was in Paris a number of years ago I was thinking of picking up the whole series in French. I had not read any yet, not even the first. So I asked the secondhand book dealer if the books really, REALLY, were good. Stupid of me to ask a French person, a bookseller and particularly a French bookseller. His reply was that they were magnificent. The books were expensive, so I used my head and decided to read one first, rather than immediately investing in a a whole bunch.
Did Waugh also change Crouchback's age? I seem to remember that in one he was 35 and in the other closer to 40 but as I started reading Men At Arms and then switched, on Nigeyb's advice, to Sword of Honour I can't remember which way round it is.
Susan wrote: "The Reading Gods have smiled upon us and Proust has appeared as an Audible Deal of the Day - should anyone be interested. Details in the Audible Thread."
If the narrator's right, I bet it works brilliantly on audio and could become an immersive experience.
If the narrator's right, I bet it works brilliantly on audio and could become an immersive experience.

In Men at Arms, he is thirty five at the start. Maybe somebody who has read The Sword of Honour Trilogy knows how old he is said to be there. How long is the time period covered?

If the narrator's right, I b..."
It is not fun being immersed with disagreeable people though! Luckily the obnoxious person has topped talking.
I can't remember the detail of Sword of Honour now. I doubt he would be critical of Catholicism in the book - he isn't in his other works. As a convert he seemed to retain that zeal throughout his life.

Thanks, makes sense what you say, but there are situations drawn where that intended is rather ambiguous. There was a statement about God not caring much about the continuation of an aristocratic family line. A reply is made that God cares even for sparrows. I was not sure what Waugh was trying to say. It was difficult to judge on which side he stood.
Chrissie wrote: "There was a statement about God not caring much about the continuation of an aristocratic family line. A reply is made that God cares even for sparrows."
I don't remember this particular exchange either but perhaps it would be helpful to think about who is speaking? Not every, or even any, character is a direct mouthpiece for the author.
I struggled with the trilogy overall as I found myself at odds with Waugh's essentially reactionary and conservative politics - but there are some hilarious scenes which still make me smile in memory: the thunderbox!
I don't remember this particular exchange either but perhaps it would be helpful to think about who is speaking? Not every, or even any, character is a direct mouthpiece for the author.
I struggled with the trilogy overall as I found myself at odds with Waugh's essentially reactionary and conservative politics - but there are some hilarious scenes which still make me smile in memory: the thunderbox!

YES, there are funny lines. You sort of get a British M*A*S*H!
I have just come to the "thunderbox". I am not yet clued in on what is going on.
And I should say I am now liking Christian Rodska 's narration. I do sometimes change my mind as I read, both about a book itself and its narration.

Where You Once Belonged by Kent Haruf - 3 stars - My Review
Chrissie wrote: "and I do tend to over analyze......."
I don't think we can ever over-analyse a book! :)
I don't think we can ever over-analyse a book! :)
Interesting discussion - from memory, I would have said Waugh is quite critical of Catholicism at times in Brideshead Revisited, especially through the portrayal of Lady Marchmain.

I'm a fan of Haruf's "clear, crisp" style. However, even though great writing can't totally save a badly drawn plot, it can make the trip a bit more pleasant and take a book from a 2 star to a 3 star read. Thanks for the review.

Thanks. I like hearing different ideas.

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Ah, I've finished Proust! By the time I got to the end, I understood those people who reread it endlessly, we're sort of invited to start again now that we understand the end point.
As a contrast, I'm starting Simenon's Three Bedrooms in Manhattan - something short!
As a contrast, I'm starting Simenon's Three Bedrooms in Manhattan - something short!
I did download the Audible version. I am afraid, though, that if I even start to listen to it, I will get hooked... I loved it, but it's very, very long.
... and the audio even longer. I'd also be tempted as it would be exactly the kind of thing I'd love while commuting. I think rereading would be a different experience from reading the first time, as we know how it all fits together now. I'd be interested in how you find the narrator.
I've started reading Red Plenty: Inside the Fifties' Soviet Dream ready for our next group read - although I still have several previous group books on the go too.

The Sand Pebbles by Richard McKenna - 4 stars - My Review

I almost remember the film, starring my heart throb Steve McQueen.


I've read all three of Pulley's novels, which are densely-plotted, slightly supernatural affairs set in the 19th century, with murky Victorian fogs and exotic foreign climes. I enjoy them a lot although they can also be frustratingly over-complicated. What I find interesting about all Pulley's books is that the main characters are always Empire-building, adventurous men. It's like reading John Buchan or Biggles. There's barely a woman to be seen and they are usually conveyed as charmless and unsympathetic. In these #MeToo times, this is very, very unusual.
On the plus side, there's also an adorable clockwork octopus.

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
I have quit Waugh's trilogy after the second book and gone on to a book by Émile Zola--The Masterpiece. I am liking it a lot.

Yes, the movie is on this weekend on TCM (for Memorial Day)! I recorded it since I've not seen it before. Talk about timing!
Just finished a book published in 1993 and set in and around the Orkney Islands. The writing is lovely. It is really a better book than my 3-star "personal enjoyment" rating implies (literary quality is excellent).
Vinland by George Mackay Brown - 3 stars - My Review



The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro - 5 stars - My Review

At Hawthorn Time by Melissa Harrison My review
Scenes from a Childhood by Jon Fosse My review
Saving Lucia by Anna Vaught My review
The Loser by Thomas Bernhard My review
Handiwork by Sara Baume My review
Mothlight by Adam Scovell My review
The Philosopher's Pupil by Iris Murdoch My review
Forensic Songs by Mike McCormack My review
Generosity by Richard Powers My review
Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line by Deepa Anappara My review

I just finished this Pulitzer Prize winner published in 1974 about the American Civil War Battle of Gettysburg:
The Killer Angels by Michael Shaara - 3 stars - My Review

My review of The Masterpiece: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
After immediately closing one book by Émile Zola, I have picked up another, this time it's The Drinking Den / L'Assommoir. I think it will be a buddy read later this year, but I didn't want to wait.
I am reading 1913 The Defiant Swan Song
It looks at the year from the perspective of various cities: London, Berlin, St Petersburg, Vienna, Rome, Paris and New York. It is a bit of an over-view, but very readable and enjoyable.

It looks at the year from the perspective of various cities: London, Berlin, St Petersburg, Vienna, Rome, Paris and New York. It is a bit of an over-view, but very readable and enjoyable.


It looks at the year from the perspective of various cities: London, Berlin, St Petersburg, V..."
Another surprise on my kindle shelf.

Stoner by John Williams - 4 stars - My Review

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Now I have begun How I Became Hettie Jones by of course Hettie Jones, a female author of the Beat Generation. Having enjoyed Come and Join the Dance by Joyce Johnson, I have wanted to try another female author of the period.
Books mentioned in this topic
Anna of the Five Towns (other topics)Riceyman Steps: A Novel (other topics)
Anna of the Five Towns (other topics)
Riceyman Steps: A Novel (other topics)
The Namesake (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
P.G. Wodehouse (other topics)Jhumpa Lahiri (other topics)
Arnold Bennett (other topics)
Vladimir Nabokov (other topics)
Arturo Pérez-Reverte (other topics)
More...