How the Grinch Stole Christmas!
discussion
Is the Grinch gauche in the end?
date
newest »
newest »
Please do not try and ruin this wonderful story. There is no reason to show cynicism on a kids tale. This is no more gauche than A Christmas Carol, another wonderful Christmas tale.
Papaphilly wrote: "Please do not try and ruin this wonderful story. There is no reason to show cynicism on a kids tale. This is no more gauche than A Christmas Carol, another wonderful Christmas tale."^ Yah, what he said!
Papaphilly wrote: "Please do not try and ruin this wonderful story. There is no reason to show cynicism on a kids tale. This is no more gauche than A Christmas Carol, another wonderful Christmas tale."
Goody Two-Shoes
Goody Two-Shoes
Gregory wrote: "Papaphilly wrote: "Please do not try and ruin this wonderful story. There is no reason to show cynicism on a kids tale. This is no more gauche than A Christmas Carol, another wonderf..."Maybe I am, but then I also do not want to destroy the magic of Christmas for children either. Lighten up.
What's magic about a drunken father and smashed toys?!
BTW, I think Dahl was an atheist who just didn't like baloney.
Gregory wrote: "What's magic about a drunken father and smashed toys?!"???
Gregory wrote: "BTW, I think Dahl was an atheist who just didn't like baloney."What does Dahl have to do with Dr. Seuss?
Im getting lost on this convo. Maybe Greg is mixing up his authors. Dickens and Seuss.
Carrie wrote: "Im getting lost on this convo. Maybe Greg is mixing up his authors. Dickens and Seuss."I am assuming Roald Dahl.
Papaphilly wrote: "Gregory wrote: "What's magic about a drunken father and smashed toys?!"
???"
My father loved Christmas, but he had problems.
???"
My father loved Christmas, but he had problems.
Papaphilly wrote: "Gregory wrote: "BTW, I think Dahl was an atheist who just didn't like baloney."
What does Dahl have to do with Dr. Seuss?"
Both men were nonsense writers, but Dr. Seuss was the most loving of the two.
What does Dahl have to do with Dr. Seuss?"
Both men were nonsense writers, but Dr. Seuss was the most loving of the two.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
A Christmas Carol (other topics)
A Christmas Carol (other topics)
A Christmas Carol (other topics)
How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
A Christmas Carol (other topics)A Christmas Carol (other topics)
A Christmas Carol (other topics)
A Christmas Carol (other topics)
How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (other topics)
Was it bad faith to do so?