Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2020 Challenge - Regular
>
19 - A book set in a country that begins with "C"
message 51:
by
Ira
(new)
Nov 30, 2019 03:26PM

reply
|
flag




Yes, this makes a lot of sense. The English letter C is very confusing since it can sound like κ or Σ but also has sounds not found in Greek to the best of my knowledge, and there are letters in Greek that don't sound like English ones.

Yes, this makes..."
That is exactly the problem. When there are prompts with letters I usually just ignore Greek and just go to English.

I get confused because I studied Koine Greek which is VERY different than Greek today and also because English scholars have some odd pronunciations. I wish I'd learned modern Greek when I was growing up. Actually, my first choice would be Icelandic since my mother's family spoke that and the alphabet is a lot closer to English although there are three letters English doesn't have. But also Greek.

I get confu..."
Yes pronunciation can be a problem. I had the same problem with English, since not all teachers had good pronunciation. It took a lot of listening to English audiobooks to improve in that area.I wish I could understand Icelandic since they say it is close to Ancient Norwegian, but when I hear Icelandic people talk I understand nothing. But I do understand some Danish and Swedish when they are not talking too fast.

Yes, Icelandic is VERY close to Norse 1000 years ago (so middle Norwegian, I guess). Icelanders can understand Norwegians fairly well, but Norwegians can't understand Icelandic. My mother's family all originally came from Iceland and she was fluent in it until she was 11 and her grandmother died-then she lost a fair bit, but her parents could read, speak and write it even though they were born in Canada (into an Icelandic community there). My dad's parents came from a complicated background, and once they came to Canada they could speak, read and write 4 languages with two alphabets (they had to learn Russian in school but also knew Ukranian even though those weren't their first languages). SO, I envy you being able to know at least three languages. European education is much better that way.

I have no problem understanding Swedish and Norwegian (but I have to "tune in" my ears. And I lived in Sweden for half a year when I was younger so I picked up on a lot of the differnces between Danish and Swedish).


Does anyone know if this would count?


I have no ..."
That's interesting. My cousin, and anglophone who went to school in French in Canada for complicated reasons, got a scholarship to get a degree in Icelandic after she got her master's degree, became a citizen and has lived there for well over a decade. She loves it.
I can't do it now, nor do I speak them, but when I was still in BC and living in the city for university (where I grew up the city meant Vancouver) I could tell the difference between Cantonese and Japanese and those two from all other east Asian languages. I had no idea at that time that Cantonese is a minority language because back then most Chinatowns out west had primarily Cantonese speaking immigrants. Vancouver has North American's largest and did back then as well.
I spoke High German plus a German dialect that is a different language (some of them are very different than Hoch Deutch) for a year when I was little and now that I am studying classical voice I am very choosy as to which accent I want to learn the pronuncuation--I find a professional from Germany who has an accent I like (there is no such thing as one German accent). I can also always hear American accents in other languages so don't go only by my voice teacher (well, his Italian is VERY good since he actually studied there) but always find native, professional singers to record myself speaking to.
But I can't control my normal speaking accent which changes regularly depending on where I am.


also Do Not Say We Have Nothing would be a good one if you haven't read it.

I personally like to have more than 50 percent of a book set in a country before I count it for country challenges (unless they specify a larger amount), but I am not sure that there is any rule about how much of it. But to me a book is not set in a country if only a small portion of it takes place there. I don't know this book so can't say.


The challenge is in English, so it's the English names.
But, then, of course, as this is for fun, it's OK to bend the rules. There's no POPSUGAR reading challenge police taking away your reading license if you do that :-D

Like, there's tons of books set in Prague. Which is, of course, the capital of the Czech Republic.
Also, a lot of authors set their books in their home country.
It doesn't always work, though. I was a bit disappointed to find out that Dubravka Ugrešić sets her books mostly outside Croatia. They sound really interesting to me. :-)

The Devil of Nanking
are both good, set in China"
I thought The Devil of Nanking was set in Tokyo? I know Nanking itself is in China, ..."
Yes, Devil of Nanking is set in Japan, not China.


On my TBR I have:
Station Eleven (Canada)
One Hundred Years of Solitude (Colombia)
The Wolf in the Whale (Canada)
Spaceman of Bohemia (Czech Republic)
Anna Dressed in Blood (Canada)
Edited to add: I can't believe I forgot Cinder (China)! It was really good.


https://uncannymagazine.com/article/f...



Its non-fiction and very interesting. I had never thought about what happened when the US closed all its air ports on 9/11

Jade Dragon Mountain by Elsa Hart
This also counts for author with flora and fauna in name, since a hart is a male red deer.


And Ball Lightning is sci-fi set in China.




This is a great idea!



Yes, it's set in Chile.

Son of a Trickster (Trickster trilogy)
A Darkness Absolute (Rockton series 5 books)
Czech Republic
Silence Fallen (#10 of 12 book series; only this one works)
Daughter of Smoke & Bone (3 book series)


I loved that book both times I read it!
Books mentioned in this topic
Anne of Green Gables (other topics)A Mind Spread Out on the Ground (other topics)
In the Shadow of the Banyan (other topics)
Ghost Stories of Nova Scotia (other topics)
Taaqtumi: An Anthology of Arctic Horror Stories (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
L.M. Montgomery (other topics)Louise Penny (other topics)
E.K. Johnston (other topics)
Louise Penny (other topics)
Drew Hayden Taylor (other topics)
More...