November 2014 Group Read - Sidney Chambers and the Shadow of Death by James Runcie

[Louise]

Sounds fun!

[Bill]

P3 'manifold sins & wickedness' - from the General Confession in the Book of Common Prayer.

[Bill]

P3 'manifold sins & wickedness' - from the General Confession in the Book of Common Prayer.

[Cristal]

I've read the first couple of stories, which are great fun, short enough to keep me interested.

[Ruth]

BBC Radio 4 Extra are serialising this at the moment. I've just listened to the first episode - very enjoyable.

[Bill]

A quick glance @ wikipedia reveals the 1st Tupperware party in England wasn't till 1960. Good historicals are so hard to do.

[Ruth]

Bill wrote: "A quick glance @ wikipedia reveals the 1st Tupperware party in England wasn't till 1960. Good historicals are so hard to do."

I wonder if he read the passage about the Tupperware Party being a good way for women of the 1950s to work and enjoy the benefits of earning an income, without reading on to the mention of it not coming to this this country until 1960.

[Bill]

Sarah wrote: "Bill wrote: "A quick glance @ wikipedia reveals the 1st Tupperware party in England wasn't till 1960. Good historicals are so hard to do."

I wonder if he read the passage about the Tupperware Part..."

Actually I did but why do you ask?

[Bill]

I'm DNF on this one after one story. Reasons on the spoiler thread.

[AngryGreyCat]

I just got this from the library so might start it tonight or tomorrow

[Bill]

On reflection, I think this one should adapt beautifilly to television, especially with the lovely settings.

[Ruth]

Bill wrote: "I wonder if he read the passage about the Tupperware Part..."

Actually I did but why do you ask?

Sorry, I meant I wonder if the author read the first part of the Wikipedia entry about Tupperware in the 1950s in America but didn't spot that later on it mentioned that Tupperware didn't arrive in the UK til 1960.

[Bill]

Sarah wrote: "Bill wrote: "I wonder if he read the passage about the Tupperware Part..."

Actually I did but why do you ask?

Sorry, I meant I wonder if the author read the first part of the Wikipedia entry abou..."

Thanks. These things are tricky. Now that DNA analysis, CCTV cameras, & mobile phones have made so many traditional plot elements obsolete, detective story authors have been drawn increasingly to historicals & as we fossils who can actually remember the '50s shuffle off this mortal coil fewer anachronisms will be noticed. It's the little things we take for granted that sneak (& when will the 1st supposed '50s character say 'snuck'?) in, not obvious anachronisms like laptops. I've spotted @ least 4 stories set in the '20s,'30s & '40s with married Englishmen wearing wedding bands. Not too long ago one of the members of our group was surprised to discover that men's shirts used to have detachable collars (which I gather are making a come-back thanks to Downton Abbey).