DumbleDORKS discussion

225 views
Harry Potter > If You Could Own a Deathly Hallow, What'd It Be?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 54 (54 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Ruxi (new)

Ruxi | 1 comments I would very much like to own the invisibility cloak.So I could go and steel candy from the stores:)


message 2: by Julia (new)

Julia I would also say invisibility cloak. You could sneak up on people and they would never know! And get candy, not get into trouble... The likes.

And it seems to be the less... dangerous, I guess? of the other three.

The elder wand would be cool though.


message 3: by Rachel (new)

Rachel (rjscottie) Elder wand. Then I could put a disillusion charm on a cloak and it would work like the invisibility cloak.


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

Invisibility cloak without a doubt. The stone was just creepy...
I'd sneak onto planes so I could travel the world for free! Mwhaha! But if somebody asked to see my passport after I'd entered the country it would show i hadn't paid for a ticket...I think... How do passports work, exactly? I might just wear it all the time to avoid suspicion


message 5: by Emily (new)

Emily Karn (goodreadscomemily-karn) | 6 comments I agree, the invisibilty cloak would top my must have list.


message 6: by Monique (new)

Monique | 4 comments Invisibility cloak!! so many possibilities, i'd sneak into hogwarts and take all the classes, sleep in the common room by the fire, steal butterbeer (then leave money on counter) and hope that no one ever noticed me!


message 7: by Anika (new)

Anika | 5 comments The invisibility cloak.


 Ѕυϻϻεг {"sнσш ϻε λ нεгσ, λπd I'll шгιτε ψσυ λ τгλɢεdψ"} (leovaldez5819) | 1030 comments invisibility cloak its the only brother that didnt die


message 9: by bean (new)

bean :) Resurrection Stone. True, tragic ending for the middle brother, but still, wouldn't it be pretty cool to be able to bring back people like Amelia Earheart, for instance, just to talk to them? I'd love to meet Audrey Hepburn. That would be so cool.

I tried so hard to make a case for the Resurrrection Stone righ there, but let's be honest. The Invisiblity Cloak is totally the best.

We're all muggles. So really, the Elder Wand would be pretty much useless. And the stone, well, it doesn't even resurrect properly. So yup, cloak for mee.


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

@Summer good point! XD
I might be a ghost... No way to know on the Internet!


message 12: by Michaela (new)

Michaela | 8 comments I think the invisibility cloak would be more than useful... Though I wouldn't mind and unbeatable wand either... Hmm this decision may take awhile


message 13: by Michaela (new)

Michaela | 8 comments I think the invisibility cloak would be more than useful... Though I wouldn't mind and unbeatable wand either... Hmm this decision may take awhile


message 14: by Inkweaver (new)

Inkweaver | 6 comments Definitely an unbeatable wand. You can make yourself invisible with a charm, and you can see dead loved ones in the moving photos.


message 15: by Inkweaver (new)

Inkweaver | 6 comments Squibs can use wands! (Kind of)


message 16: by itslenasophie (new)

itslenasophie | 2 comments The elder wand or the invisibility cloak.. I can't decide ,both are so great✌️


Joseph ~ The Madman with a Box (themadmanwithabox) | 30 comments As much as I'd hate to say it…I'd choose the resurrection stone.


message 18: by Mars (new)

Mars Montufar (AresKingofHell) | 70 comments Resurrection stone, so I can bring back loved ones.


message 19: by Jazzy (new)

Jazzy (stairstepjitters) | 155 comments Invisibility cloak, easily. The resurrection stone and the elder wand would feel like I was playing God.


message 20: by Hollie (new)

Hollie Molloy | 2 comments Elder wand. I love power and dominance.


message 21: by Emily (new)

Emily  (prettylikeapoem) Invisibility Cloak seems the safest, it doesn't really change you like the elder wand or the resurrection stone would. I mean, I would love the stone, but I'm sure it would just be really heart breaking having it and hard to deal with.


The-Impossible-Girl- (Kaya/Alex) (trueshuckfaceoverhere) | 36 comments cloak,come on it would make your life much easier:D


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

I'd say the Invisibility Cloak. As everyone before has pointed out, the Resurrection Stone doesn't truly bring back the dead. And the Elder Wand tends to attract a lot of unwanted attention and violence. However, the cloak has so many possible uses. Harry has proved this, and there are so many more possibilities. He used it mostly for sneaking around, but he also solved mysteries, hid from Death Eaters and saved the world with it!


message 24: by Thelivingmuffin (new)

Thelivingmuffin | 14 comments Invisibility cloak just so I can be invisible. And win hide and seek all the time.


message 25: by L.Y. (new)

L.Y. Levand (lylevand) | 1907 comments I'd probably pick the invisibility cloak. Provided I was thinking like a sane person at the time. xD If I had a bout of "I don't care about the consequences!" I'm pretty sure I'd end up with the wand, lol.


message 26: by Raquel (new)

Raquel | 17 comments The invisibility cloak


message 27: by Bethany (new)

Bethany (bfmmcdermott) Invisabilitu Clock


Ravenpaw/claw~Raise a Glass to Freedom (ravenpawclaw) | 750 comments Cloak! The I could eavesdrop on people! Plus it rocks.


message 29: by [deleted user] (new)

Invisibility cloak.


message 30: by areeba (new)

areeba (bookish_fantasies) | 108 comments The elder wand! I could make myself invisible that way too. There should be a spell somewhere...


message 31: by Anna (new)

Anna | 58 comments Invisibility cloak!


message 32: by Megan (new)

Megan The elder wand.


message 33: by Adia (new)

Adia W. | 83 comments Elder Wand


message 34: by Ida (new)

Ida Wessel | 3 comments I'd choose the invisibility cloak. The other two just seems like to much responsibility!


message 35: by Demi (new)

Demi (demid13) Invisibility Cloak!

The stone just creeped me out and the elder wand feels like too much responsibility.


message 36: by Samantha (new)

Samantha | 129 comments The invisibility cloak. That way I could read without interruption as no one would be able to find me :)


message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

I like that, Samantha. Great idea.


message 38: by Ana (new)

Ana (zurchana000) | 2 comments The Cloak!!!!!!!


message 39: by [deleted user] (new)

Ana are you a swimmer?


message 40: by Kittycat (new)

Kittycat | 1 comments Monique wrote: "Invisibility cloak!! so many possibilities, i'd sneak into hogwarts and take all the classes, sleep in the common room by the fire, steal butterbeer (then leave money on counter) and hope that no o..."
definatley!!!!!!


message 41: by Bianca (new)

Bianca I'm gonna ignore the fact that the stone doesn't really work and that the wand is dangerous, because who would take anything other than the cloak with those downsides.

But if I just look at what they're supposed to do, I would definitely take the stone. Bringing people back from the dead (and I mean for real) would be awesome.


message 42: by Arihs (new)

Arihs Green (agust_d) | 184 comments The cloak for sure. The Elder Wand corrupts (because as we all know, absolute power corrupts absolutely), and the Stone is really depressing. In my opinion, the dead should stay where they are. (However, if someone chooses to be a ghost and not move on, then that's cool.)


message 43: by Arihs (new)

Arihs Green (agust_d) | 184 comments Also - INVISIBILITY. SO COOL.


message 44: by Eve (new)

Eve (arweneve) | 2344 comments The cloak for sure!


message 45: by Alyeska (new)

Alyeska definentley the invisibility cloak!


message 46: by Andie (new)

Andie N (andie-n) | 195 comments After a short debate with myself, I decided TWO things.
1. If I was a witch who already had a wand, the Invisibility cloak.

2. BUT, if I were still a muggle like I am now(haven't recieved the letter yet.) I would want the wand becuse you can still be invisible, just not as easily., and you can do all sorts of other spells.


message 47: by Nina (new)

Nina (nainafainant) | 27 comments I would choose the cloak because it is the only one that could not potentially get me killed. I like my life thank you very much.


message 48: by Andie (new)

Andie N (andie-n) | 195 comments Don't we all!


message 49: by Deejay (DZ) (new)

Deejay (DZ) (deejayreads) | 5 comments The cloak definitely !
So that I can sneak up on people lol


message 50: by Nikko (new)

Nikko Jake (dejesusnikkojakegmailcom) | 2 comments the elder wand


« previous 1
back to top