Reading the Detectives discussion
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread, 2019-2020
After seeing the nomination for our October read, The Widening Stain appeared in my library's ebook selection and I grabbed it. Not sure how this will affect my vote as it is unlikely I will remember any details into October.

I'm now halfway through listening to The Roman Hat Mystery by Ellery Queen - audiobooks always take me a very long time, but I think the narrator of this one, Robert Fass, is brilliant. He has such a great voice and does slightly different voices for the different characters.
My review for The Widening Stain : While the ending to the mystery was a bit clunky the book was a wonderfully amusing look at life in a university library, interspersed by the author's limericks. Too bad the author was busy doing serious work to continue his mystery authorship.
Still not sure how I'll vote.
Still not sure how I'll vote.
I really enjoyed The Problem at Two Tithes by Clara Benson, and have now started another forthcoming buddy read, Light Thickens by Ngaio Marsh, which so far seems as if it will be very enjoyable too.


I do think there's a huge variation in quality of Christie's characterisations. Murder At The Vicarage, which is one of her earliest, is not very good at all. (Although Mysterious Affair At Styles, which was her first, is much better. She's so perplexing in this way. It's the same with her very last books, most of which were pretty terrible but there's the odd gem.)
I am just rereading Towards Zero, which is one of my favourites in terms of the characterisation. I find myself so caught up in the characters that I don't mind whether there's a murder or not. The Hollow is the same in this way. Yet in others, the characterisation is perfunctory at best.
Hopefully you will find Christies you like better - but as someone said further up the thread, we all have our different preferences and it doesn't matter if we don't all like the same things.

Hollow is also pretty good from the perspective of characterization
I've been intermittently reading some Margery Allingham short stories, The Allingham Minibus - I'm finding some of them are very enjoyable although, as with other collections of her short stories, the quality is quite variable.
I was listening to the podcast Tea or Books? and they did an episode on Christie or Sayers. One of the presenters disliked Wimsey, so chose Christie on terms of plot. The other liked Sayers characters, over Poirot or Miss Marple. Luckily, I enjoy both, but, also luckily, we don't have to like the same things :)
I am currently listening to The Problem at Two Tithes
for our forthcoming buddy read. I have read the Christianna Brand (characters duly listed for you Judy!) and have yet to start our last Ngaio Marsh - other than the recent sequel to the series.
I am currently listening to The Problem at Two Tithes


Always sad to get to the end of a long-running series, Carolien, but then, as you say, you have the joy of going back to the beginning again :)

Definitely bittersweet Carolien. And I'm sad to think she came so close to completing the alphabet, but wasn't given that time.
I've read quite a lot of the Sue Grafton books in the past and hope to catch up with the ones I've missed some time. I agree it is sad that she didn't quite get to the end of the alphabet.
I've finished the Allingham Minibus now - it was a bit uneven and only had 3 short stories featuring Campion and at least one of those I'd read in another collection. But there was also a long story featuring a character from the "Campion universe", Lugg's old associate Thomas Knapp, which was a fun read.
I've now started Crossed Skis: An Alpine Mystery
by Carol Carnac aka E.C.R. Lorac - this one was on Kindle Unlimited, and I thought it would be nice to read a winter sports mystery during the current hot weather!
I've now started Crossed Skis: An Alpine Mystery

Hope it cools you down, Judy!
I have just finished The Problem at Two Tithes
and will embark on
Light Thickens later today.
I have just finished The Problem at Two Tithes


Thanks Susan! I've read and enjoyed both Two Tithes and Light Thickens - my audiobook of Death of Jezebel is still in the post from the US, so I may be slightly late to the party with that one, though I'm hoping it will arrive any day now!
I've just set up a favourite authors thread for E.C.R. Lorac, please pop over to discuss this author (whose book Bats in the Belfry is currently in the lead in our October group read poll!)
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...






Have you seen the TV adaption? I really enjoyed this. Stunning scenery too!


I haven't seen it Tracey, that's why I chose this series of hers rather than the Vera Stanhope series. I prefer to read the books first so I don't get a particular actor stuck in my mind.

I haven't seen it Tracey, that's why I chose this series of hers rather than the Vera Stanhope series..."
I agree it's quite difficult to unsee a particular actor in a role.



The 1931 newly formed Detection Club members wrote one chapter each, one the prologue, and another a close for The Floating Admiral, and all devised solutions included in final publication. Authors then: Anthony Berkeley, G.K. Chesterton, Agatha Christie, G.D.H. Cole, Margaret Cole, Freeman Wills Croft, Clemence Dane , Edgar Jepson, Milward Kennedy, Ronald Knox, John Rhode, Dorothy L. Sayers, Henry Wade, Victor L. Whitechurch.
This should be a treat!
I'll be interested to hear what you think of The Floating Admiral, Shaina - I thought some bits of it were much better than others, but I don't remember now which authors' bits were my favourites!
I've started
and am remembering how much I like Brand's style. Also glad to get an explanation of the cover which confused me.

I've started listening to Evan Can Wait, one of the Constable Evans mysteries by Rhys Bowen - I'm so delighted that Roger Clark has recorded all the rest of the series for Audible!
The only very slight disappointment is that the cover is black, saying "cover art to come" - not sure if I will get the Welsh landscape turning up when they decide to add one!
The only very slight disappointment is that the cover is black, saying "cover art to come" - not sure if I will get the Welsh landscape turning up when they decide to add one!
Judy wrote: "I've started listening to Evan Can Wait, one of the Constable Evans mysteries by Rhys Bowen - I'm so delighted that Roger Clark has recorded all the rest of the series..."
I have the third one, Evanly Choirs to read / listen (I have both versions though the library wants their book back soon). I was wandering around Audible as I have a couple of credits expiring in a month and saw the rest of the series is now available. Decided I could always spend those credits on the series if I like it on audio.
I have the third one, Evanly Choirs to read / listen (I have both versions though the library wants their book back soon). I was wandering around Audible as I have a couple of credits expiring in a month and saw the rest of the series is now available. Decided I could always spend those credits on the series if I like it on audio.
I have a selection of short stories going on audio, Anne Perry Presents Malice Domestic. Out of the first three stories, two were fun and the other okay, but not remarkable.
For non-mystery, I'm loving a selection of early Terry Pratchett stories, The Witch's Vacuum Cleaner: And Other Stories. The audio even has sound effects.
For non-mystery, I'm loving a selection of early Terry Pratchett stories, The Witch's Vacuum Cleaner: And Other Stories. The audio even has sound effects.
Sandy wrote: "Judy wrote: "I've started listening to Evan Can Wait, one of the Constable Evans mysteries by Rhys Bowen - I'm so delighted that Roger Clark has recorded all the rest ..."
Wow, I didn't realise the credits could expire - must have a look at the ones I have! I am also intending to buy the rest of the series. Thanks Sandy.
Wow, I didn't realise the credits could expire - must have a look at the ones I have! I am also intending to buy the rest of the series. Thanks Sandy.


The 1931 newly formed Detection Club members wrote one chapter each, o..."
I look forward to your thoughts on this as well. Such an intriguing concept.

For no..."
I adore Pratchett, must try this audio.



I have to agree, Phryne Fisher is great fun!

I recently got this one, as I loved the (parts of the) series, but don´t know when I´ll find time to read it! :P


I've already ordered a second in the series. They probably shouldn't be read too close together though.

It is always so nice to find these hidden treasures in our shelves. This looks fascinating.
I'm reading Open and Shut. My first book by the author and I'm pretty sure it was a recommendation in this thread that pointed me in this direction originally. Thank you - I'm enjoying it very much.
Elizabeth (Alaska) wrote: "I'm picking up a Nero Wolfe this evening - Too Many Women. I look at my Read dates, and see it's been over a year since I've been with Archie and Wolfe. Must rectify that!"
I must get back to Wolfe too!
I must get back to Wolfe too!

It's not the most satisfying detection puzzle but as a thoughtful study into post-war life, it's intriguing. Next up, The Hollow, which always amazes me with its intense focus on characterisation, so that the crime plot seems largely irrelevant.


Tara, I really enjoyed the book. I must say what I enjoyed the most was the collated endings the various authors had written. Sayers in the introduction to the Detention Club explains the rules applied. The authors when writing the chapter were also supposed to share how they saw the story progressing and who they thought was the murderer and why. This had to be shared with other authors at the end and has been printed in the book.
I think I am going to read all the books in the series.

Judy, I really enjoyed the book. I liked the feeling of how each author tried to link their chapter to the previous one. I also like the various opinions of who they suspected at the end.

I recently got this one, as I loved the (parts of the) series, but don´t know when I´ll find time to read it! :P"
Michaela, I thought the same when I got the series in July. I managed to read the first 4 this month. They are quite short but they had me hooked from the start.
I read them between heavier books. I love the Miss Fisher Series on Netflix. That's how I heard of the books.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Constant Rabbit (other topics)The Thursday Murder Club (other topics)
Gallows Court (other topics)
The Thursday Murder Club (other topics)
Gallows Court (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
P.D. James (other topics)Vanda Symon (other topics)
Michael Robotham (other topics)
Domenica de Rosa (other topics)
Elly Griffiths (other topics)
More...
Hope you enjoy it, Kirsten! All our Marsh threads are still open if you want to take a look or add comments. :)