Doctor Who: The Library of Carsus discussion
The Doctor's Infinite Library
>
Random chat
message 1651:
by
Travis
(new)
Jun 30, 2023 06:38PM

reply
|
flag

It has it's moments, but it's also a mess.
Eric Saward loves a high, brutal bodycount, and his attempts to counter the "silliness" he saw in the show is grim, heavy handed and not much fun.
good cast makes this better than it has any right to be.
And Tegan's leaving scene is much better than I'd remembered.
Another story that set up several story threads for later, which neither the show or BF has done much with.
Going into the home stretch of the Davidson era.

I can appreciate the amount of stuff they are trying to do: write out Turlough and Kameleon, explain Turlough, introduce the new girl, and, if you can fit it in, maybe tell a story.
It's a mess, full of good bits, but it never fits all the pieces into a coherent or satisfying whole.
Mark Strickson does some of the best acting of his Who career, the supporting cast is pretty solid, considering how little they are given, Anthony Ainley is entertainingly over the top and the leaving scene is nice.
Despite how much Kameleon is given to do, he's treated like crap by the Doctor and his end feels lazy and out of character for #5.
The first half, Peri is painfully annoying. She gets better in the last two episodes.
One more to go.

Unfortunately, I’ve not read any 12th Doctor novels yet. So I got nothing.

Good to hear.
Never much of a Barbie fan, but it seems to be made by somebody who loves that world and I'm always happy when that happens to a franchise.
Hopefully, this leads to more Mattel based movies and we'll get the live action Rockem, Sockem Robots we've all been hoping for.

What, you didn’t think Real Steel (2011) with Hugh Jackman was exactly that? Although, come to think of it, it is based on a short story by Richard Matheson and was a Twilight Zone episode.

So far, yes."
Okay.
That seems weird, as in 'Rose' it's implied the Doctor recently regenerated, but yet there's several box sets of stories before Rose.

Yes. I agree. But then there’s lots of inconsistencies in the both the classic and new series anyway. 🤷🏻♂️

Yes. I agree. But then there’s lots of i..."
Part of why I am reluctant to get too into BF.
It's a full time job making the TV show continuity make any kind of sense, I couldn't afford the tequila I'd need if I tried to do that with BF or the novels.

Were there a bunch of Trion prisoners on Earth?
If Turlough was the only one, what did he do when Turlough disappeared?
A law firm that dealt with aliens on Earth...?
Tell me this doesn't have 'Madam Vastra and company' level potential.
Call me, Mister Briggs, I already have scribbled notes for a potential story.

It's very well written, acted and filmed, but it's not a lot of fun to watch.
So grim and everybody, but the Tardis crew, is up to something or just outright evil.
Do like the chemistry between Peri and Doctor #5.

Much better than between Peri and Six. 😹😹😹



I just found those films tedious."
Only watched the first one. It's a mixed bag.
Great looking movie and the expanding the world gave me the first spark of interest in the franchise I've had in years, ( 30's G-men with magic wands...!) but you really can't overlook the baggage that HP comes with now.
But, the main four do a solid job and I could easily see them running from Daleks.
Maybe it's because Eddie Redmayne looks like he's cosplaying as Matt Smith..?

I can see that.

Apparently there's a teaser trailer out there on the inter web and amazon has a listing (but no release date yet)
Happy dance!!
Hopefully this means the animation recreations are coming back, as the next one rumored was the smugglers!


I'm going to try and be optimistic.
Will be sad if this is the end of the line, but will be happy to get two more stories.


No idea what the plan is, and some doubts they have one, but if a couple times a year, we get a lost story back, I put it up with it.

Cool.
Trailer looks fun.
Crazy month, so unless my daughter is looking for someone to go with, I'll probably wait for streaming.


I'm a Ted Kord guy, but this version is my daughter's fave and she has gotten me to appreciate him.
Ah, it's DC, if you get your own made up city, that's a sign you've made it into the big leagues.

Still don't like it.
The only timeless children I acknowledge are Peter Cushing, Richard E Grant and Jo Martin.


Going to see it Friday with my daughter.
I'll let you know.

🤦🏻♂️

It's a very good looking movie, the core cast is solid and likable.
It's one of the laziest scripts I've ever seen.
It has no middle act. It is split down the middle between intro/set up and immediately to dramatic/action climax.


Jamie and his sister felt like siblings.
Most all of them gave the tropes and cliches they were handed and gave them a bit of heart.
Not perfect, but stuff like this and Ms. Marvel have been a nice break from the "Woe is me, I am the lonely super hero" stuff.



Yeah, I get what you're saying.
I think, the family being likable made me more forgiving.
I found the girlfriend (can't even remember her name, that's a good sign) such a generic placeholder, and Susan Sarandon was just walking through being 'generic evil person'.
The sheer laziness of that writing and the fact that the actors just seemed to stop trying made them the more offensive to me.
Shame, as it is a great looking movie.


The scripts biggest sin is you can so obviously see the 'we need to get from A to B to C..."
Occasionally, it's done in a fun way but most of the time you just sit there going 'Yeah, we get it it, he has to meet the girl etc...'

That's not fair, Encanto is freakin' amazing!
I at least went with an 'okay' show, Ms Marvel for my comparison.
Almost no movie stands a chance against Encanto.

I love the Prisoner, but I don't want to hear each episode reviewed four times!
Couldn't one of you have picked The Avengers, or maybe Sapphire and Steel...?

Own the book, but never the actual cartoon.
Plus, I have some ideas for fanfic involving the Cushing and Grant Doctors, so this counts as research.

Was thinking of tracking it down, and have completely blanked

I love the Prisoner, but I don't want to hear each episode reviewed..."
😹 Sorry dude. I remember when I was trapped at home during the pandemic shutdown, I rewatched almost every franchise film series I own. I guess they all just went “Hey, here’s a series I’ve not watched in awhile.” 😹
Books mentioned in this topic
The Insidious Dr. Fu Manchu (other topics)The Insidious Dr. Fu Manchu (other topics)
Master of Kung Fu Epic Collection, Vol. 3: Traitors to the Crown (other topics)
Master of Kung Fu Epic Collection, Vol. 3: Traitors to the Crown (other topics)
Doctor Who: The Chimes of Midnight (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Shearman (other topics)Robert Shearman (other topics)
Justin Roiland (other topics)
Justin Roiland (other topics)
Jim Henson (other topics)
More...