Doctor Who: The Library of Carsus discussion

120 views

Comments Showing 1,351-1,400 of 2,386 (2386 new)    post a comment »

message 1351: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "Excuses, excuses."

Whatever. šŸ™„


message 1352: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Watching the old BBC sitcom "Last of the summer wine" and keep thinking Peter Sallis (Later to be the voice of Wallace) would have made a good Doctor


message 1353: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Perhaps. I’m not that familiar with the actor’s work.


message 1354: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Perhaps. I’m not that familiar with the actor’s work."

Aside from Wallace and Gromit, I've just seen him in a couple sitcoms.
The character he plays in Summer Wine just has an odd philosophical air and dry sense of humor that seems very Doctor-ish to me.


message 1355: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "Aside from Wallace and Gromit, I've just seen him in a couple sitcoms. The character he plays in Summer Wine just has an odd philosophical air and dry sense of humor that seems very Doctor-ish to me."

Cool.


message 1356: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments The great rewatch resumes!

Castravalva: one of the best regeneration stories.
The two halves work together quite nicely.
Always fun to see the Tardis team trying to cope without the Doctor and I'd forgotten how much I liked Davison's low-key Doctor and his quiet sense of humor.

Good stuff.


message 1357: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments I just listened to, over the past several days, the Big Finish 1963 trilogy:
Doctor Who: 1963: Fanfare for the Common Men
Doctor Who: 1963: The Space Race
Doctor Who: 1963: The Assassination Games
Which they produced as part of the 50th anniversary celebration. Loved the first one with the fifth Doctor, was disappointed with the second featuring the sixth Doctor and really, really enjoyed the last with the seventh Doctor.
Doctor Who 1963 Fanfare for the Common Men by Eddie Robson Doctor Who 1963 The Space Race by Jonathan Morris Doctor Who 1963 The Assassination Games by John Dorney


message 1358: by Rick (last edited Jul 09, 2022 11:43AM) (new)

Rick | 2260 comments I also find it interesting and fascinating how all three feature some aspect do the Cold War in addition to how Doctor Who: 1963: Fanfare for the Common Men is looking at the music mania of 1963, Doctor Who: 1963: The Space Race is looking at the race-to-the-moon contest between the US and the USSR, and Doctor Who: 1963: The Assassination Games is looking at the assassinations that plagued the 1960s.


message 1359: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments 4 to Doomsday:
way better than I remembered.
The plot almost feels like a Star Trek script.

While I want to dopeslap Tegan and Adric, I get why they acted the way they did: this is a very new Tardis team, they barely know each other.
I do like how the Doctor is so low key and quiet that you think he's out of his depth and then he does stuff that reminds you, he is the smartest guy in the room.

The spacesuit Adric wears in episode 4 is just repainted Sontarian armor!


message 1360: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "… The spacesuit Adric wears in episode 4 is just repainted Sontarian armor!"

😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹😹


message 1361: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Also like how Four to Doomsday keeps of the tradition of the Doctor just letting random people have a space ship.
There's these guys, the pirate crew from Black Spot, Ghostlight and Co.
They're all over the place.


message 1362: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments I never really thought about it, but yeah he does.


message 1363: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Started watching 'battlebots' and now have this image of K-9 participating in the robot fight contest.

No idea what to do with it, but it's such a clear image, it's stuck in my brain.


message 1364: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rumor has it, Disney + may be getting the Doctor Who rights.
Mixed feelings, as it's one less reason to put up with amazon, but also don't like the idea of the mouse owning everything.


message 1365: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Kinda: strange and trippy, but really well done.
The sort story new Who would try and do.

While, I've always liked this Tardis team, rewatching makes you see there was more going on.
Wether the actors or the writers, there is the structure of a traditional Tardis team, but there seems to be a bit more...depth maybe, or at the least more shades of grey to them and their interactions.

NewWho pretended to be the more adult version, but this feels like they actual did it, without feeling the need to announce it.

Interesting


message 1366: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Visitation: fun romp.
Like the Terriliptils. They should come back.

The highwayman, Richard Mace is on my list of 'would have made a great companion' and I am still enjoying how dysfunctional this Tardis crew is.
The 5th Doctor has a bit more Hartnell in him than I remembered.


message 1367: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments I have a spotify account and the listing for available BF episodes is enormous!!
It's all main range stuff, so Doctors 5-8.

My wife has made a huge mistake, getting me easy access to this stuff.


message 1368: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Well, July has come and gone and no congratulation e-mail from Big Finish.

Not that I thought my chances of gettin g picked for the writing contest were high, but I'm still a little sad.

But, I got my entry in, so I know I can do it again next year.


message 1369: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "… But, I got my entry in, so I know I can do it again next year."

Start working on a new entry now! Get it polished and scrubbed so it’s all ready and SHINEY by the next deadline. 😸


message 1370: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "I have a spotify account and the listing for available BF episodes is enormous!!
It's all main range stuff, so Doctors 5-8.

My wife has made a huge mistake, getting me easy access to this stuff."


Sweet! 😸


message 1371: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments If the Ruth Doctor is pre-Hartnell, then why is her Tardis a police box?
How did that work?
I like her, but every time they show the Tardis, I get very distracted.


message 1372: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Did I mention Britbox has 'Blake's 7'?
Think I know what I'm watching after the Prisoner.


message 1373: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "If the Ruth Doctor is pre-Hartnell, then why is her Tardis a police box?
How did that work?
I like her, but every time they show the Tardis, I get very distracted."


Wibbly wobbly timey whimey?


message 1374: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "Did I mention Britbox has 'Blake's 7'?
Think I know what I'm watching after the Prisoner."


I’ve still got to dig out and rewatch: The Prisoner & UFO.


message 1375: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "If the Ruth Doctor is pre-Hartnell, then why is her Tardis a police box?
How did that work?
I like her, but every time they show the Tardis, I get very distracted."

Wibbly wobbly ti..."


Yeah, I'm gonna need more than that.
I like the Ruth Doctor and hope RTD does right by her, but she could also end up on the same shelf with the Valyard and finding out what blew up the 11th Doctor's Tardis.


message 1376: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "Did I mention Britbox has 'Blake's 7'?
Think I know what I'm watching after the Prisoner."

I’ve still got to dig out and rewatch: The Prisoner & UFO."


I'm about 33 episodes away from finishing the Prisoner.
Such a good series!

I enjoyed UFO but not sure it I'd rewatch it.
Couple good episodes, but knowing we never get answers keeps it off my list of 'great shows'.


message 1377: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "I'm about 33 episodes away from finishing the Prisoner. … "

Uh, there are only 17 episodes (maybe a couple more if you count the variant edits and such)(scratching my head).


message 1378: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "Yeah, I'm gonna need more than that.
I like the Ruth Doctor and hope RTD does right by her, but she could also end up on the same shelf with the Valyard and finding out what blew up the 11th Doctor's Tardis."


And who tells everyone why it’s a Police Call Box? We know The Doctor lies. They’re an unreliable narrator. And an almost worthless primary source.


message 1379: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "I'm about 33 episodes away from finishing the Prisoner. … "

Uh, there are only 17 episodes (maybe a couple more if you count the variant edits and such)(scratching my head)."


Hit the button too hard.
3 episodes


message 1380: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "Yeah, I'm gonna need more than that.
I like the Ruth Doctor and hope RTD does right by her, but she could also end up on the same shelf with the Valyard and finding out what blew up ..."


The Doctor lies was told to us by River Song, the ultimate unreliable narrator, so I'm gonna call BS on that bit of wisdom.


message 1381: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "The Doctor lies was told to us by River Song, the ultimate unreliable narrator, so I'm gonna call BS on that bit of wisdom. "

Doesn’t mean she wasn’t right about that. 😹😹😹


message 1382: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "The Doctor lies was told to us by River Song, the ultimate unreliable narrator, so I'm gonna call BS on that bit of wisdom. "

Doesn’t mean she wasn’t right about that. 😹😹😹"


Yeah, let's trust the liar when she tells us someone else is a liar.
Moffett loves having an awful woman lecturing the Doctor on how he's a bad person.

and it still doesn't explain the Tardis, as we saw it in 'Unearthly Child' and first heard the Chameleon circuit wasn't working in that story.


message 1383: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Won't be posting reviews on my Prisoner rewatch, but I will say how much I've enjoined the three 'filler' episodes before the grand finale.

All three are clever, experimental and well directed.
Kind of amazing to see that they took something they were contractually obligated to put together and decided to have fun and push the boundaries of what they could do.


message 1384: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Black Orchid: Nice little romp, thats only flaw is it really needed a little more room to breath.
At three episodes, this would be better regarded.
At two, it's rushed.

Everyone seems to be having fun.
Nyssa gets more to do, Tegan finally relaxes, while Adric just eats and looks confused by everything.


message 1385: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Prisoner rewatch: all done and it's still brilliant.
I get why the ending is controversial, and why it's love it or hate, but I'm in the love it camp.

It gives the show an ending, but it's an ending where you have to fill in some blanks and make your own decisions.


message 1386: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments I’m in the love it camp as well.


message 1387: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "I’m in the love it camp as well."

I get why it's divisive, and I don't begrudge people that it doesn't click for, but man, I love it.

One of those things where every time I come in contact with it, I get the urge to write fanfic.

Curious to see the AMC reimagining or whatever er they made.
Don't think prime has it.


message 1388: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "… Curious to see the AMC reimagining or whatever er they made. Don't think prime has it."

The mini-series with Sir Ian McKellen? It’s very, very different. But good in its own way. The original is certainly better, but I did really enjoy the new series as well. But then I’d probably find watching McKellen write out his grocery list spellbinding.


message 1389: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "… Curious to see the AMC reimagining or whatever er they made. Don't think prime has it."

The mini-series with Sir Ian McKellen? It’s very, very different. But good i..."


That's the one.
And Ian McKellen is the big selling point.


message 1390: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Found a site that is streaming the short-lived 'Logan's run' TV show.

It's very late 70's sci-fi, and an endless quest show, but it's fun and the three leads are decent.


message 1391: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Travis wrote: "Found a site that is streaming the short-lived 'Logan's run' TV show.

It's very late 70's sci-fi, and an endless quest show, but it's fun and the three leads are decent."


I think I watched the first episode or two when it aired, couldn’t get into it. Part of that being the book is so much better than the film, but also I had a HUGE crush on Michael York. Between Cabaret, The Three Musketeers, The Four Musketeers and then Logan’s Run - I was a lost cause.


message 1392: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Travis wrote: "Found a site that is streaming the short-lived 'Logan's run' TV show.

It's very late 70's sci-fi, and an endless quest show, but it's fun and the three leads are decent."

I think I..."


Like the movie, don't remember much about the books, thought they were okay.
The show is fun and cheesy, but I get why it only lasted a season.

York is definitely in the best film version of the Three Musketeers.
It's funny, as York is the Hugh Jackman of the 3 musketeers, as he looks nothing like the description of D' artanigan (sp?) from the book, but he's what everyone thinks of.
Other movies pick actors that resemble York to play the character.


message 1393: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments He’s just so … dashing. 😻


message 1394: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments Just watched Lightyear. The movie that is Andy’s favorite film from Toy Story. Non-stop cheese and endless clichĆ©s - I loved every second of it.


message 1395: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "He’s just so … dashing. 😻"

He is annoyingly good looking and charming.


message 1396: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments Rick wrote: "Just watched Lightyear. The movie that is Andy’s favorite film from Toy Story. Non-stop cheese and endless clichĆ©s - I loved every second of it."

I like the idea that Lightyear is the movie that inspires the toys.


message 1397: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments At what point did the Doctor get control of the Tardis back?
In New Who he can go wherever he wants, treats the Tardis like an uber for companions and the idea that he doesn't know where he's going is BS.

But, it seems like McCoy's Doctor was able to steer where he needed to go.
Moreso in the books, but several episodes in his last season.

Did all that messing with the Tardis the Time Lord's did during the 6th Doctor's era knock something back into place?
Did the 7th finally decide to to fix stuff?


message 1398: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments I’ve often wondered this as well. I was only half paying attention to this the last time I went through the whole run, so I do t think these an exact point when it happens. New Who is definitely ā€œhas complete controlā€ while classic is is various levels of ā€œhow do you steer this thing?ā€ I’m almost tempted to say it was during the eighth Doctor’s time, or maybe during the Warrior’s tenure in the TARDIS. Maybe the Time War fixed it. That would certainly explain why toward the end of the classic Who series, the Doctor has some degree of control and other times not so much. Tentacles of the Time War reach back to earlier incarnations and forward well into the more recent Doctor’s eras as well.


message 1399: by Travis (new)

Travis (travishiltz) | 2397 comments I'm going with the 7th Doctor.
he had shenanigans that could be connected to the Time War.

The 6th Doctor may have been used by the Time Lords, as part of the war, but the 7th was definitely up to something.


message 1400: by Rick (new)

Rick | 2260 comments There are Big Finish dramas with every Doctor from at least the Third, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Ninth, Tenth, Eleventh and the Warrior (aka War Doctor), dealing with some aspect of the Time War - that I know of. And even some very tangential stuff that connects with the First, Second and Twelfth, and then there’s also the War Master range as well, and the Gallifrey Time War range, etc. etc. When you break time, cause and effect cease to have meaning and words like past, present and future are no longer applicable. There’s even an alternate Fifth Doctor now that’s is technically a War Doctor, portrayed by Colin Baker: Doctor Who Unbound: Doctor of War 1: Genesis & Doctor Who Unbound: Doctor of War 2: Destiny.


back to top