The Lightning Thief
question
Who has better character and morals : Harry or Percy?

I am aware these books are immensely different, but yet comparable still
reply
flag
I feel that Harry's character is better and he is smarter, more responsible and more relatable. But I feel that Percy is the more innocent one, who would do anything to help those he loves. So I feel that Percy has better morals and reasons to do what he does.
Honestly, I love them both.
Honestly, I love them both.
Hmm.... this is a tough question. I'm not really a fan of either, but I think that Percy may have better morals? Harry really does have some good ones though.
Percy. I love Harry but his angst is just soap opera level.
I think Percy wins more. He's more rational in his decision making and also as a character and somehow more realistic in a sense than Harry ( I love Harry btw)
(to quote me...)
Percy Jackson's emotional depth comes with a "no diving" sign. Keep splashing in the shallow end.
Percy Jackson has nothing on Harry Potter because Rick got his ideas from JK. Of course, PJ started off as stories Rick told his kid, which is why his blatant rip off wasn't that big of a deal... unit he put it into writing. You know he patch-worked it a bit, added something different here and there but in essence, the similarities are uncanny.
And to anyone who says HP isn't relateable... you're not even in the swimming pool. Ahem.
-Remember that time when Ron and Harry totally fudged their divination homework by making up random nonsense that would happen to them?
-Remember all those times when Ron and Harry got Hermione to do their homework whilst profusely complaining about it?
-Remember all those times when Harry and Ron thought they were going to die because they had to take a test?
-Remember all those times when Harry was the definition of anyone's teenage angst?
-Remember when Harry Potter dealt with racism, class, and allusions to important historical stuff like the Nazis and Hitler with Voldemort and his followers?
-Remember when Harry Potter got dark because of life isn't cherry pie all the time?
-Remember when JK had the gall to kill off deeply beloved characters to teach kids real loss?
-Remember who ACTUALLY died for the greater good. Harry.
-Remember how Harry was the god of sass?
-Remember when HP taught you to get over prejudice and to accept people warts and all? (@Luna, Hermione, and Neville)
-Rember when HP taught you about the importance of family and the ire of a mother? (@the Weasleys)
Oh, and by the way, I can't hear you over the screams from the Harry Potter theme parks.
Percy Jackson's emotional depth comes with a "no diving" sign. Keep splashing in the shallow end.
Percy Jackson has nothing on Harry Potter because Rick got his ideas from JK. Of course, PJ started off as stories Rick told his kid, which is why his blatant rip off wasn't that big of a deal... unit he put it into writing. You know he patch-worked it a bit, added something different here and there but in essence, the similarities are uncanny.
And to anyone who says HP isn't relateable... you're not even in the swimming pool. Ahem.
-Remember that time when Ron and Harry totally fudged their divination homework by making up random nonsense that would happen to them?
-Remember all those times when Ron and Harry got Hermione to do their homework whilst profusely complaining about it?
-Remember all those times when Harry and Ron thought they were going to die because they had to take a test?
-Remember all those times when Harry was the definition of anyone's teenage angst?
-Remember when Harry Potter dealt with racism, class, and allusions to important historical stuff like the Nazis and Hitler with Voldemort and his followers?
-Remember when Harry Potter got dark because of life isn't cherry pie all the time?
-Remember when JK had the gall to kill off deeply beloved characters to teach kids real loss?
-Remember who ACTUALLY died for the greater good. Harry.
-Remember how Harry was the god of sass?
-Remember when HP taught you to get over prejudice and to accept people warts and all? (@Luna, Hermione, and Neville)
-Rember when HP taught you about the importance of family and the ire of a mother? (@the Weasleys)
Oh, and by the way, I can't hear you over the screams from the Harry Potter theme parks.
Percy is less of an anxiety teen with daddy issues than Harry:)
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic